Top 10 Anime Based on 4-Koma Manga
- Categories: Anime, News
- Date: Jul 23, 2011 12:39 JST
- Tags: A Channel, Adaptations, Hidamari Sketch, Lucky Star, Moe, Rankings, Working!!
The 4 panel manga (yonkoma or 4-koma) format has become a staple of the gag and moe manga market, and some of the most popular anime around owe their origins to this style – anime fans rank their favourites below.
1. Working!!
2. Lucky Star
3. Hidamari Sketch
4. Seitokai Yakuindomo
5. A Channel
6. Kanamemo
7. K-ON!
8. Azumanga Daioh
9. Nichijou
10. GA Art Design Class
The era of K-ON!’s unreasonable ability to top any ranking appears rapidly to be drawing to a close…
AKB48 “Connected To Yakuza”
GungHo Stock Plunges: “The Social Bubble Finally Bursts!?”
Photo Kano Wet Meganekko Anime
Busty Maoyuu Maou Figure
Otaku Elect Fan Sex Rino in “Creepiest Ever” AKB48 Election
Louis Vuitton’s Hatsune Miku Figure: “Miku = Fashion Icon!”
“70% of Guys” Hate Nail Art
Top 20 Anime of the 21st Century
If My Heart Had Wings Announced
Xbox One “Clearly Inferior” To PS4, Sony Stock Surges
Microsoft Unveils Xbox One – “Enjoy Your TV & EA!”
China Quality Crossing: “Cross 100m in 5 Seconds…”
One Piece Cancelled Again as Eiichiro Oda Hospitalised
PS4 Revealed as “Square”
Top 25 Anime Girls Love & Guys Hate
Hyakka Ryoran Samurai Bride Naked Apron Anime
BlazBlue Gets TV Anime
Guilty Gear Xrd Sign: “In 3D & Using The Unreal Engine!?”
Electrifying Mikoto Misaka Figure
Japanese Makeup Terrifying as Ever…
Korean Plastic Surgery More Impressive Than Ever
Fancy Frontier 21 Cosplay Fancier Than Ever
Wonder Festival 2013 Winter Cosplay
Ultra-Sexy Babes of Tokyo Auto Salon 2013
“Why Are Seiyuu Such Great Artists As Well?”
Even More Comiket 83 Day 3 Cosplay
Comiket 83 Day 3 Cosplay Cuter Than Ever
Comiket 83 Day 2 Cosplay Has Otaku Wet With Desire
Comiket 83 Day 1 Cosplay Cool As Ever
Chinese Cosplay Pure Quality: “They Even Have Enako!”
http://i488.photobucket.com/albums/rr245/sexynewbie/ErioTouwa_creater_Sexynewbie02.gif
I made a GIF.
You're a good person.
nice
too bad the skirt changes its colours in the 2nd picture :(
-shrugs- i am just the man who put the pics together
I came here expecting Working!!
I was not disappoint
same here (with Lucky Star, hidamari sketch, azumanga daoih, and GA)
i demmand a working!! second season!!!
You're in luck, it's airing in October...
I came here expecting GA Art and Sketchbook manga to rank way higher. Somewhat disappointed..
Amen to that.
Came here not expecting working. However, pleased anyway. such a great anime.
Setokai Yakundomo FTW!!!
Oh don't worry about K-ON!, when the third season in the manga finishes and becomes an anime you'll see it come back in full force. ( Not that I'd complain seeing as how I love K-ON! ) ( Mugi is awesome btw )
and the new MugiXMio character
Yep. Sumire, Mugi's maid, cranking moe up to eleven.
Nichijou's a 4koma? Odd.
I mean with A-channel's anime I could see where every joke starts and where it's punchline arrives. But Nichijou felt considerably less predictable and contained.
only the hakase/nano scenes are yonkoma
I think they did a miraculous job of connecting multiple 4komas in Nichijou or just expanding one skit so much it becomes a whole segment of the episode.
Kyoto Animation did a great job with that manga IMO.
I guess Working! is POPLAR now!
u can said it more like 'popura'...
ok..SYD and a channel got in..im satisfied..
And Where's B-Gata H-Key? SEXILY GODLY 4KOMA!
yay SYD!!!
Azumanga should be above A channel, sorry but anime sort of sucked with its character songs in every ep.
Nichijou isn't 4-koma, and if it were it'd be in first 3....... I guess i can agree about the rest though
I have no idea what's being said, but that last panel in the title picture of Erio in the futon is ridiculously adorable.
Azumanga and Nichijou below A-Channel and K-On.
lol okay
Azumanga deserves a higher spot than K-ON! hands down.
good good.. I see azumanga and nichijou.. I'm fine
Really? Working? Err...I don't know about this list.
I like Doujin Work best.
been some time since a view a satisfying list
A huge surprise that Hidamari Sketch was even mentioned let alone being 3rd.
Azumanga Daioh should be at the top, followed by Working.
This is the first time I've come to this site and seen a list in which I am familiar with all series on the list. I guess this is my interest area.
The reason k-on isn't getting to the top anymore is because its summer and all the summer fags are doing the polls
Daaaaamn. Look at that booty.
I'd hit it from the back yo.
thats a let down
I came here to expect Lucky Star.
So when is season 2 comming?
Finally a ranking where I agree on the #1!
Azumanga Daioh, one of the most under rated school based slice of life Animes in my opinion. I wish it was out on bluray!
I want to see Sadomi made into an anime. It's a epic 4-koma manga.
Wo..wow.., is it a curse or a blessing that Geijutsuka always came up right on #10 despite being under-appreciated..?
Hurray for SYD~ <3
I count being in the top 10 to be a blessing, no matter if it's on the bottom half of it. at least GA didn't get an "Honorable Mention".
Doujin Work? Anyone else? All right then.
These people are forgetting about his other work, 'Mangaka-san to Assistant-san to'
but thats not fully 4koma isn't it like normal then 4koma style?
The thing I didn't like about some of these anime is that you could literally see the transition between the sets of 4-koma strung together. They didn't flow.
Well, that didn't happen to Working, A-Channel and K-on as far as I've observed. GA, Lucky Star and SYD do have them but they didn't bother me at all either.
(..cept for that extra scene in Lucky Star after the heartwarming "Kanata returns" part. It just spoiled the atmosphere of me shedding some manly tears.)
Working definitely deserves to be tops, it's consistent quality with every issue. Seitokai Yakuindomo and Lucky Star are also quite good.
Yeah, I actually clicked this link expecting to see bloody K-ON! at the top of yet another list. Remarkably, I was proven wrong, and I have never been happier to have made a false assumption. :)
I don't have any problem if K-on is anywhere above the Top 3, KyoAni did a terrific good job for being "not loyal" to the original 4koma.
Then again, Working! does deserve to be no.1 ... if not Seitokai Yakuindomo. Didn't expect Kanamemo is that famous though, definitely need to watch it soon.
Kanamemo didn't even bother hiding yuri content, French-kissing girls eight minutes into the 1st episode!
Yuri and lolis everywhere! Rejoice!