Comment on Top 25 Greatest Mahou Shoujo Ever by Sasazuka:

Avatar of Sasazuka

I can’t believe Sasami/Pretty Sammy is only #44 on the list and her nemesis/reluctant ally Pixy Misa doesn’t appear at all.

The PRETTY SAMMY OVA’s and TV series (MAGICAL PROJECT S in America) were pretty much the first anime productions to capitalize on the allegedly-unintended popularity of SAILOR MOON amongst the older male otaku demographic. I seriously doubt there’d be a NANOHA or MADOKA if PRETTY SAMMY hadn’t paved the way.


Sasazuka made other comments on this post:

  • Top 25 Greatest Mahou Shoujo Ever:
    The PRETTY SAMMY OVA’s or the PRETTY SAMMY TV series (MAGICAL PROJECT S in the USA)? Because the OVA’s had a bit of out-of-place adult humor (raunchier than the rest of TENCHI MUYO other than maybe the “Night Before the Festival” OVA special) while the TV series was somewhat cleaned-up for the “Family Hour” time slot. I also prefer the TV series because the focus is on Sasami and Misao and they didn’t try and shoehorn in most other TENCHI MUYO character for anything beyond single-episode cameos …

  • Top 25 Greatest Mahou Shoujo Ever:
    Pretty Sammy’s at #44, though, sadly, Pixy Misa isn’t anywhere to be found. When I first discovered Japanese doujinshi websites, Pretty Sammy and Pixy Misa were all the rage. Of course, it was 1996.

  • Top 25 Greatest Mahou Shoujo Ever:
    Third thing, where are the SAILOR MOON girls? Were they disqualified for some weird reason?

  • Top 25 Greatest Mahou Shoujo Ever:
    Also, while I adore RAILGUN, I don’t think of psychic girls as being “magical girls” in the traditional sense, though I suppose this list is mainly just girls with any type of power, even if they don’t have a baton or a frilly dress.

Recent comments by Sasazuka:

  • The Disappearance of Nagato Yuki-chan Revealed:
    Sasaki shows up eventually, in volume 6 of the manga, but I doubt they’ll get to her before season 2. There’s an arc in volume 4, terminating at the beginning of volume 5, that would seem to me to be an obvious place to end the first cour (season).

  • The Disappearance of Nagato Yuki-chan Revealed:
    Actually, Kyon’s design is fairly faithful to the YUKI-CHAN manga, where he’s drawn with a far less cynical face compared to the traditional MELANCHOLY version, being a far less cynical character in this universe. It’s also because the YUKI-CHAN manga is drawn by Puyo, who already took a lot of liberties with the original Noizi Ito designs from the light novels in the HARUHI-CHAN manga, also drawn by Puyo, and he (?) doubles-down on the character design changes in YUKI-CHAN.

  • Top 30 Most Appropriate Voices in Anime:
    I’m nowhere near fluent enough in Japanese to really judge how well a voice fits a character. I do notice tonal mismatches, when a character’s voice sounds far too mature for a character, and I am specifically thinking of Kuroko Shirai as voiced by the husky Satomi Arai, but Kuroko’s distinctly non-cute 14-year old middle-aged woman voice is half the appeal of the character and I wouldn’t want her voice sounding any different.

  • Top 10 Manga That Deserve An Anime:
    Azumanga Daioh was a 4-koma (excluding a few bonus chapters done in a traditional manga format) with minimalist artwork. Because the source material was mostly set-up, punchline, set-up, punchline, and because the manga art was fairly rudimentary, it would have been very difficult for J.C. Staff to screw up the anime adaptation (and they didn’t). I still find people who swear up and down that the AZUMANGA DAIOH manga is still much better than the anime even though the anime is a very faithful …

  • Top 20 Anime Guys That Should Star:
    If he counts as a “guy”, I’d think I’d like BAKA AND TEST: SUMMON THE BEASTS better if Hideyoshi Kinoshita was the main character.


Popular

Recent Articles