Kip said:
I think Aya's overhyped, but she has acting talent. I like what she can do.
It's too bad she's made immortal because of her two roles, when so many before her have worked in the industry for years to make a name, who are as good, and some, admittedly, who are better.
part of it also has to do with how memorable and likeable the character itself is, many people loved konata for being an otaku and others like myself like haruhi for being so wierd and having an interesting outlook on life. i don't know much about voice acting so i cna't say much about it, just that i liked the voices she gave those two.