Sankaku Complex Forums » Anime

Re: Equality Now Fraud Claims!

  1. WiseRooster said:

    cept the people in our neck of the woods?

    and don't forget 4 chan

    Ridley Timberlake said:

    That would explain all the hypocritical comments on fonzer's link. Most people probably don't even know what anime is until all this started.

    some can't even differentiate anime and Disney cartoon

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  2. Ridley Timberlake said:

    That would explain all the hypocritical comments on fonzer's link. Most people probably don't even know what anime is until all this started.

    ja man.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  3. momokiller said:

    some can't even differentiate anime and Disney cartoon

    That is a very common case. Remember the time Americans thought Transformers was theirs? Plus, most people watch anime but don't even know what it is. Example: Kids watching Azumanga daoih or Yu-gioh on 4kids. Also, some of America's cartoons are a copy of Anime. take a look at Totally spies or GIJOE. If you take a good look closely, they resemble a similar drawing style to a anime character.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  4. One of the main points I mentioned is basically that

    It was found after further study that negative ideas of pornography, foreign to Japanese culture, were accepted and particularly applied to visual depictions since they were the ones most likely recognized and thereby criticized by Westerners.

    One of the reasons that anime and hentai is targeted is basically
    1. its alien
    2. you can see what is about without any need to speak or understand Japanese
    3. clearly not racial, cultural, or political and thus free game
    4. deals with taboo subjects (particularly to western sensibilities)

    Also, the west has typically adopted a colonialist approach to asian intellectual property. Lets take Pokemon for example

    Its pretty obvious that its Japanese, and yet...
    http://www.psypokes.com/anime/censor.php
    Has the list - highlights include
    - calling the Temple Festivals in Japan a mythical event in Poke-world.
    - Onigiri = Ice Cream
    - Cutting any episodes with Jap-centric themes like Shinto Worship

    Such is life however, its not like the East doesn't hijack anything off the West! Although you think the culture shock thing would be wearing off five decades after Midway.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  5. Ridley Timberlake said:

    That is a very common case. Remember the time Americans thought Transformers was theirs? Plus, most people watch anime but don't even know what it is. Example: Kids watching Azumanga daoih or Yu-gioh on 4kids. Also, some of America's cartoons are a copy of Anime. take a look at Totally spies or GIJOE. If you take a good look closely, they resemble a similar drawing style to a anime character.

    Because of thius type oif thing i dunno what my first anime was really is annoying. Also Azumanga was on 4KIDS? I didn't know that, and another series that is DEFINITELY phoe anime is W.I.T.C.H. that was aired by disney and yes i did watch and enjoy it one of my guiltier pleasures. I did know yu gi oh was anime when i saw it but not transformers and i mean the old 80s one.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  6. put 4kids and Al Kahn in same sentence and I got a revenge fantasy that's bout as bloody as Ingolrious Basterds

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  7. Wuto said:
    Howdy folks, first post here, but long, long time reader. Having followed the whole Equality Now thing for some time I decided to put in my two cents via collaborated sociology research I did a while ago.
    ...

    Great post.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  8. Cheers <( ^^)>

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  9. The Drinks Are on Me tonight!

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  10. WiseRooster said:
    The Drinks Are on Me tonight!

    Save it for the fall of Equality Now in fact i say if they do fade we all have a drink on their downfall at midnight that day.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  11. Sorrior said:

    Save it for the fall of Equality Now in fact i say if they do fade we all have a drink on their downfall at midnight that day.

    I call Dibs on dancing on their grave.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  12. ah yes i found this poll on ign:
    http://boards.ign.com/teh_vestibule/b5296/180569382/p1

    Certainly i voted no and had to say something as usualy,but still more people voted for banning it then not banning it.
    Well it's actualy a pretty close result.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  13. WiseRooster said:

    I call Dibs on dancing on their grave.

    No lets have a orgy or just do our hentai thing on their grave ya know read loli manga watch loli hentai and so on.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  14. Sorrior said:

    No lets have a orgy or just do our hentai thing on their grave ya know read loli manga watch loli hentai and so on.

    lets have an orgy on their grave while watching loli hentai at the same time,it's genious!

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  15. We can have our party there. We have lolis, pr0n, horses and dogs...

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  16. I'll just call the waitress over and we can drink to our moe health!

    Attachments

    1. Faded_Coin_CG1.jpg 6 years old
    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  17. I know it took a while, and it isnt nearly as high quality as the first, but I'm and art student who just happens to have to take English 101, so here is the paper i asked about on the first page

    The Logic NOT behind Pornography Bans
    I believe that it is not our goals and objectives that make us the person we are, but the path we are willing to take to get there. There is currently a battle being fought, and it is many organizations of the developed world rallying against a minor part of Japans pornographic content. Like much of the developed world Japan has outlawed pornography of minors, however it currently does not have a ban on "Loli" porn which consists of drawn minors in the style of anime and Manga. I will explain the arguments of the many un-Japanese organizations who support a full ban on Loli porn, and also the defense given by the Japanese and other peoples who oppose the ban. I do not support the ban on the precepts of sheer logic, freedom of speech and expression (which is also in the Japanese constitution), and statistics.
    It is easy to justify a ban on any actual child appearing in pornography, but when organizations like Equality Now (American Feminist Organization) say things like “It is simply bizarre that any kind of Manga can be published simply because no actual people appear in it." and even "It is absolutely incomprehensible that they are allowed to do this to children just because they don’t exist.", it makes me question their logic. This basically sums up my argument on logic; the fact is that all you need to make Loli porn is a guy with pencil and paper. There are never any children hurt in the making of this, and it would be impossible to stop production of it even with a ban.
    Freedoms of speech and expression are two of the things this country was founded on, yet we constantly argue over how much those FREEDOMS should actually be allowed to the general public. The head of UNICEF has actually condemned Japan for not passing tougher anti-Loli laws and given quotes like “If it causes harm to children, freedom of expression should be restricted.” She is not the only one, UNICEF Japan(not officially part of UNICEF) also supports a ban, and its leader Agnes Chan(Former Chinese pin-up girl) have said things like “People who think of children’s nudity as a tool don’t need freedom of expression.” Many will agree with me that such a blatant display of wanting to suppress constitutional freedoms is wrong, but many still will agree to them because of their ideology.
    Statistics are important to get your point across, but a big argument against this ban is that there is no proof that pornography depicting minors, actually makes people want to have sex with minors. Equality Now (American Feminist Organization) has been hounding Japanese officials for some time now for bans on the principle that such porn incites action of the real things. However when asked were the proof is they say things like "I think it is wrong to think that just because there is no data supporting a link that Manga does not influence sex crime. It is nonsense to suggest you need evidence to support a ban.”, “In other countries they have bans. Only in Japan can we not get a ban. A ban is so obviously right that there is no need at all to provide an explanation or data to the mangaka groups.”, “They are suffering from denial, they keep arguing that you can’t ban something with no evidence against it. We have to think of a counter to this.”, “But there is no evidence that child porn Manga increases child rape. Of course, there is no evidence that the Manga exerts a cathartic effect and reduces crime either." The first few quotes may seem bad, but the last one could actually be FALSE, as over the past 20 years many countries that have cracked down on the content or availability of adult material have actually seen increases in sex crimes, while Japan who has made it easier to obtain the adult material they deem legal has actually seen a sheer drop in sex crimes.
    I personally don't mind if Japan creates porn about imaginary characters, it really doesn't affect me one way or the other. However, when organizations step out of line like this it infuriates me as an American that people would want to subjugate others on such an ill construed basis! It is one thing to say you want to "defend the children", but when you don't have the sense, the right, or the proof to support what you want to do, then you will only fail.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  18. Forgive me before you read, the inner Lecturer in me feels an intrinsic need to do this.

    it makes me question their logic. This basically sums up my argument on logic

    I think you need to punt this yardstick a little further, with something like 'implementing a legislation that cannot be enforced is beyond absurdity...' or 'This challenges the basic tenants of the freedom of speech.'

    such porn incites action of the real things.

    Clarify this into 'the availability of graphic art depicting minors does not have any statistical correlation with research associated with sex crimes involving minors.'

    The first few quotes may seem bad, but the last one could actually be FALSE,

    I think you need to clarify the flaw of their logic here a bit more rather than go for the goal kick just as yet.

    More importantly if you are presenting this to your class or making it public in anyway, I would definitely put more effort into clarifying that you are doing Loli (manga), define Loli (manga) and are talking about 2D drawings. The reason been that in a country with media hysteria about pedophilia like Australia, any note or mention of Loli will be associated by anyone and anyone with the Loli (pedo) and be a very awkward presentation indeed!

    And a little something I drew back when I was doing an art course ^^

    Attachments

    1. Aphreal_Version_One.jpg 6 years old
    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  19. AHHHH such a cute drawing good job.

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote
  20. Im all for showering their hypocrisy with irony but I'll go with my gig and just do the mexican hatdance while laughing like a hyena

    Posted 6 years ago # Quote

Reply

You must log in to post.