The parents of a critically ill boy who was told “get a taxi” when he called 119 for an ambulance and subsequently died without ever receiving medical attention are suing the city responsible.
The 19-year-old Yamagata prefecture student suddenly fell ill at home one morning at 5AM in late October, suffering severe vomiting and delirium.
He managed to call 119 for emergency services, but instead of being dispatched an ambulance he was told “take a taxi to hospital,” with the dispatchers refusing to send help, a taxi, or to inform the hospital.
Help never came and he was unable to find his way to hospital. His parents became concerned, and had his landlord call on him 10 days after the call, whereupon he discovered the boy’s remains at home.
Recordings of the call which somehow escaped mysterious loss, deletion or misfiling audibly demonstrated him having difficulty breathing, being only barely able to speak, and apparently not in full possession of his faculties.
His parents have filed a lawsuit against the city responsible, asserting that not despatching aid to a dying man is a clear dereliction of their legal obligations and demanding ¥10,000,000 in compensation.
The city has so far declined to comment, citing the pending litigation.
The case has understandably sparked outrage amongst Japanese:
“This is horrible. Somebody who doesn’t regularly use taxis wouldn’t even know their number, and for them to tell someone sick enough to have called for an ambulance to find the number of a taxi company and call one himself, go outside and wait for one whilst sick on a winter morning… are they devils?”
“Since they are only asking for 10 million it really sounds like they are more interested in finding out why they let him die than just claiming compensation.”
“That’s a trifling sum for a 19-year-old’s death.”
“The city ought to at least comment on why they didn’t send out an ambulance!”
“At least they didn’t send him an ambulance only for the hospital to refuse him.”
“He could have at least asked them for the right number.”
“Because telling someone who called 119 at 5AM to come to hospital themselves in a taxi is just such basic common sense, right!?”
“Blame this on all the idiots who call 119 for no good reason.”
“Why haven’t they established his cause of death fully? They are getting off lightly if he really did die because of this.”
“They probably don’t have tons of money to start a huge suit against the city. I expect their lawyer plans to start off with this and then use the proceeds for further litigation.”
“What about the poor taxi driver who’d be expected to drive a fatally ill man to hospital…”
Saijaku Muhai no Bahamut “Dragons & Mechs?”
Monster Hunter X Megaman Event Profusely Blue
Love Live! Sunshine!! MV “Will Brighten Up Your Day!”
Top 10 Best Anime Girls of 2015
Hai to Gensou no Grimgar “Has Oppai!”
Picking Up Japan Express Vol. 36 Worth a Pickup
Dimension W Out Of This World
Odin Sphere: Leifthrasir PV Certainly Nostalgic
One-Punch Man Soundtrack PV Packs A Wallop
XmasTrickStar “A White Christmas Indeed…”
Wo-Class Carrier Ero-MMD In Dire Straights
Voice Translation Tool Promotional Video “Inexcusable!”
Luck & Logic Far From Lucky
Yandere Simulator Possibly Headed to Kickstarter
Top 20 Recent Anime Most In Need Of A Sequel
Hyrule Warriors Legends PV Clashes Interminably
Akagami no Shirayukihime English Dub Surfaces
Koukaku no Pandora Really Opens That Box
Gate Season 2 Darker Than Ever
Super Sweet Sonico Bikini Figure
Delectable Dizzy Cosplay by Lechat
Dark Elf Cosplay by Non Very Dark Indeed
Titillating Tamako Cosplay Perfectly Pink
Goddess of 2ch: “Full of Lust & Urges (& Also Videos)!”
Raunchy Reisen Inaba Cosplay by Tsuyato
Haruhi Bunny Girl Cosplay Rocks Out
Youmu Ero-Cosplay by Madoka Adachi Deadly Sexy
Comiket 89 Cosplay Sickeningly Sweet
Comiket 89 Cosplay A Guilty Pleasure
Comiket 89 Cosplay Ceaselessly Sexy
Japan, don't become China.
I was like "meh, China"
then I was "OMG" I was wrong
Same here. It's really sad, poor young man...
Why would you think this would ever happen in China? The dispatcher would've gotten the public execution China style, as opposed to Japan, where public servants are considered immune to worldly laws or common sense.
I don't know, maybe because shit already happen there before, like a child who got run over on purpose?
I suppose this is why all shit are now stereotyped as "China"?
In China taking a taxi to the hospital is a preferred method over an Ambulance. Not only because it's faster, but because they're cheaper too.
This won't happen in China because ambulance service are run for profit.
I think you missed the point.
The situation as it is stated would not happen due to the penalties involved.
The kid in China getting run over is basically unrelated.
In China, ambulance rides you to hospital.
What happened was sad but the China case cannot compare to this.
The mother of the child was negligent and her child got run over end of story.
This is a dying man calling emergency services and being denied his remedy.
*Sigh* Fools chalking everything up to China.
It's not really the hospitals fault, kid was just unlucky it was an ass hole who answered the phone.
But the asshole works for the hospital, under their rules. which means that the hospital is responsible.
119 is a public service under local government. they decide which hospital is the nearest to the patient's location and call the hospital to dispatch ambulance
yeah, that's what i was gonna ask
isn't 119 managed by the Police and/or the Town's Emergency Department?
Tragically, this almost happened in Canada. While I was volunteering for community services, I received a call from a middle aged man living in a remote region who was immobilized from the liver pain he was suffering.
He called the ambulance but the ambulance stopped about 15 minutes from his house and told him the snow is too heavy, they cannot cross the bridge to get to him and he had to walk out to meet them. The ambulance said they would wait 30 minutes and if he doesn't come out they will have to turn back.
Fortunately someone at dispatch had some common sense and ordered the ambulance back to him along with a snowplow truck to clear the way , and we avoided pulling a Japan.
You're right, it's not the hospital's fault. EMS units are not run by the hospital. Ambulance services are run by an independent company, which partners with the hospitals within an X-mile radius. This is why you get a separate bill, with a ridiculous fee attached, if you need the service of one.
The city should have to pay his family the equivalent of a few million USD and the asshole dispatcher should be charged with criminal negligence and manslaughter.
Agreed with the criminal prosecution. If I did this to someone, refused to take them to the hospital when I knew that they were sick even if unrelated to the person in question, I could be charged with negligent manslaughter.
The culpability level is even HIGHER when it is a town-hired person running the ambulance service.
Hate to break it to you Japanohiles but this happens often in Japan.
japan has always been shit
has any of you ever lived in this shitty excuse of a country?
got into car accident, taken to ER
QUESTIONED and asked to FILL FORMS
the guy is half dead
what the fuck, japan?
Oh and I suppose you are from the greatest country ever? Every country has their problem. Stop being so narrow minded and judge Japan just by reading things off the internet.
Idiot.
As someone who has lived in Japan for 6 months as part of the JET program, I can say, without a doubt, you, sir, and the rest of you accusing us of being "weaboos" are asshat trolls.
Good day, faggots.
And where are you from? The country of great fatasses?
u mad bro?
They're weeaboos, of course they haven't!
why yes, i've lived in japan
and it was great c:
Because you did not need to call 119.
No.
Most people know Japan from anime and that is NOT Japan at all. Not even close.
Here we are people, someone with actual logic.
whis is a rare thing between sankaku visitors
what? you mean japanese dont actually summon creatures from a card game? or get raped by tentacles? what about an average loser guy being liked by multiple, cute, big breasted, blue, pink, and red headed school girls?
I can vouch for your disapproval. But remember, this website is full of weeaboos not living in reality.
Well if by 'weeaboos' you mean beta asians that practice their social withdrawal and pretend they are into asian culture by whacking off to pixels. Judging by the tear-induced down vote bitch moves whenever a news story that asspains them appear, this seems very likely.
Or worse, the U$A.
At least if I called 911 I would have gotten an ambulance sent to me or at least an officer sent to check it out.
This is pretty bad.
Yep, in USA they send someone to you, then charge you if the call was false.
wtf 10,000 dollars???? that sucks.
lol really? you must not watch the news, there have been tons of stories like this in the states.
Frankly, I'd rather die than have an ambulance pick me up, there's no telling how much that would cost me, I had to go to the emergency room once, my heart was fluttering, my breathing was heavy, I saw sparkling white lights, my head tingled, and when I put my hands up to it, the tingling spread to them. I was in the hospital for 2 days, and the doctor only came to see me once, he said "you're heart rate is high, blood count is low, your oxygen levels are low, and we don't know why" what kind of doctor just says "we don't know why" should have said, "we havent figured the reason, but we are still working on it" but no, after that he left, a nurse came back and said "we are discharging you because we need the room" I then got a bill a week later charging me exactly $10,000. They never figured out what happened to me, so I'll never pay that bill, even if I had that kind of money.
That guy saying "At least they didn’t send him an ambulance only for the hospital to refuse him" makes me said that it sounds like it's the exact same way over there.
google 911 hangs up
and see how great 911 treats you.
"there's no telling how much that would cost me"
Find out? You didn't even tell us how much they charged for the ambulance ride. In my country without cover and ignoring the government health care programs an ambulance ride is $600.
Anonymous 19:04, I have never heard of them doing that latter thing, locking you up when you show up at the station to complain.
That would be ILLEGAL in and of itself and wouldn't fly.
at least in England you'll almost never get turned down. The waiting room is a fucking pain, but if its serious they'll get you to a ward immediately and if theres no room they'll do treatment in the ambulence.
@18:15
It's actually $125000 and not 10000.
@17:27
Your doctor was honest with you as he should. If he says "we are working on it" when they are just monitoring you for changes, he'd be lying.
Yep, in the states they send someone for you.
Unless they decide to tell you to fuck off and hang up. And then lock you up when you show up at the station to complain.
Kinda too late. It's already beein censored and amaericanised at full speed.
Might come a reality now that Obamacare is the law of the land here in the USA. In order to get a ambulance, government bureaucrats will need to assess the costs.
Was that irony or are you really that stupid?
If it wasn't irony, stop watching FOX News.
Either your a rich idiot, or a idiot who has never needed $urgery. A lot of people can't afford health insurance and even if they have it the insurance firms often leave them high and dry when they refuse to honour the claim. Affordable healthcare is a fantastic move and something that many other countries already have.
The IPAB can only make suggestions on procedures performed by doctors for purposes of reducing costs. While yes, this is both a worrying and controversial aspect of the bill, there are no provisions anywhere that would allow them to deny ambulance service under any respect. Additionally such service should always be at least partially covered by the new mandatory insurance programs (assuming you're not being fraudulent).
While there is something to be said for mandating people to buy into insurance plans, nothing in Obamacare actually impacts recieving emergency care via 911 currently. At worst the IPAB can do something stupid in the future, but it won't effect ambulance service.
You know who increased the bureaucracy the most in recent years? Conservative Republican GOD, Ronald Reagan. You can blame him for any cost analysis assessment. Go ahead and look it up.
And if you're bitching about Obamacare? Don't bother, Romneycare is almost the same, so save it for when Obamacare is repealed w/ executive order #### and Romneycare does exactly what Obamacare did except we just wasted huge amounts of taxpayer money.
Think about that. Or not, won't make a difference, either way it's all going to sh*t.
Fuck man, im glad im living in Germany and have access to 24h Medical Care.. i pity you Americans and all the other Countries who dont have suche a Medical System like in Germany.
Simply taking care of the sick isn't popular enough here in America.
A system of paying protection money for mixed results is much better. =)
I dont know anything about Obamacare, but Im sure that doesn't matter.
You clearly dont know what Obamacare is.
I actually live in Japan and it's not all roses. Stop knee-jerking about Obamacare. The hospitals here are full of lonely old people who use up space and time at the drop of the hat because it's 'free' and they are bored. Meanwhile pregnant women who have an emergency die because they can't find a hospital to take them. Stories like this aren't that unusual here.
TANSTASFL. The sooner you learn that, the better off everyone else will be.
i like how every new topic that pops up on sanc has to be compared to the USA LOL. prooves that you are the no1 most hated country on the planet hands down!
Rest of the world = Tsundere
You are wrong! It's not like we talk about it so much because we like it or anything!
Diemeow fails.
well this is quite sad indeed
@20:27
an insult to tsunderes
P.S. if this was a double post I apologise
@20:27
Please don't it's an insult to actual tsuderes
@20:27
Please don't it's an insult to actual tsuderes