Top 25 Worst Anime of Winter 2012
- Categories: Anime, News
- Date: Apr 25, 2012 21:17 JST
- Tags: Bakemonogatari, Black Rock Shooter, Comparison, Mirai Nikki, Otaku, Rankings
The anime of the winter 2012 season which were rubbish, disappointments or merely widely hated for some petty or inexplicable reason have been handily ranked by anime fans in this distinctly controversial list, intended as the mirror image of the winter 2012 top anime ranking.
1. Black Rock Shooter
2. Lagrange: The Flower of Rin-ne
3. Senki Zesshou Symphogear
4. Nisemonogatari
5. Chihayafuru
6. Mirai Nikki
7. Inu x Boku SS
8. Gundam AGE
9. Last Exile – Pham of the Silver Sky
10. Guilty Crown
11. Danshi Koukousei no Nichijou
12. Zero no Tsukaima F
13. Natsume Yuuhinchou 4
14. Shakugan no Shana 3
15. Thermae Romae
16. Kill Me Baby
17. Tantei Opera Milky Holmes 2
18. New Prince of Tennis
19. Aquarion Evol
20. Papa no Iu Koto wo Kikinasai!
21. BRAVE10
22. HUNTER×HUNTER
23. Another
24. Ano Natsu de Matteru
25. Bodacious Space Pirates
For those wondering how an anime can place highly on both top and untop lists (Nisemonogatari placed 2nd on the top list and 4th on this list), a popular title can of course expect its own legion of detractors disgusted by its popularity, to say nothing of titles which betrayed expectations or otherwise failed to live up to their full potential.









|
Top 20 Hunkiest Pokemon
Wagamama High Spec Hot Indeed
Mayoiga Full of Mystery
Boku Academia: Battle for All Truly Heroic
The Empire of Corpses Gorily Grim
One Piece: Burning Blood Total Bikini Madness
Bakuon!! Wild & Rough
Milky Mimi Ero-Figure Deliciously Creamy
Dead or Alive Ero-SFM Doubly Dirty
Flying Witch “Cute But Boring…”
Phantasy Star Online 2 Phantastic: “What About the West!?”
Shounen Maid “A Fujoshi Delight”
Terra Formars Live Action Web Drama Announced
Dragon Quest Heroes II Quite Monstrous
KumaMiko Lovingly Innocent
Aqua Onahole Parody Hopefully Moist
A-Size Classmate Profusely Petite
One Day With Maria Raunchy & Romantic
The Reject Demon: Toko Chapter 0 Raises Its Voice
Hai-Furi in Troubled Waters
Kasumigaoka Utaha Cosplay Pretty Pure
Goddess of 2ch “Another Bathing Beauty!”
Tantalizing Hestia Cosplay Busts Out
Kashiwazaki Sena Cosplay Pure & Innocent
Minami Kotori Casino Girl Cosplay Takes No Chances
Shimakaze Cosplay by Ema Sakura
Harley Quinn Cosplay by Miyuko Colorfully Crazy
Sonico Ero-Cosplay by Yuka Hoshikage Super Sexy
Kasugano Sora Bunny Girl Cosplay Absolutely Admirable
Goddess of 2ch: “Barely Legal Beauty!”
and here comes the bitching of how this list is wrong as usual....
Most of the lists that Sankaku shows us ARE wrong. You don't have to remind us that.
Wrong is subjective you idiot.
You could read this fucking list backwards and get "Top 25 Anime of Winter 2012". There were only like 30 series airing at the time.
Yes. But in this time are the butthurted nisemonogatari and black rock shooter fanboys claim.
Looks to me like every second entry from the top should switch spots with every second from the bottom.
That might make the list a bit more accurate
Let the flame wars begin!
WRONG LIST FUCKING TROLL
it's a survey. A SURVEY. why not conduct one here too since this site has global members??
From the look of the list, most of the anime that showed during winter 2012 sucked? Did the guys who made this list even watch them or were they just being biased?
you can't say that BRS wasn't watched. i mean after all that OVA and game release that people had adequate reviews, you can't say it wasn't anticipated and watched.
As much as I agree, tell that to the people who say otherwise...
The fuck do you mean "say otherwise"?
Because they didn't like it, that means they didn't watch it? WTF logic is that?
THe majority of people didn't like it. That's not being biased. Do you even know what that word means?
dude, they could've started with episodes 1-4 then stopped when it was getting out of hand in the weird and stupid story plot
Gundam AGING should be higher.....
Black Shooter could have been longer....
Kill Me Baby was better as 4koma...
Guilty Crown was just a Code Geass Rip-off..
and HUNTER×HUNTER animation quality increased, but imho didn't leave up to it's original(felt more "kid-friendly").
Bodacious Space Pirates? What was that? Black Shooter Needs a sequel!
NO! it doesn't need a sequel! it needs a remaster!! the story was so bad that it felt like you put potatoes and eggplants on a fruit shake! it was an epic FAIL
BRS had potential. Te story just felt rushed. Not enough time was given to flesh out the characters and plot that much. But the core idea was good. it could have been one of the best of the season if it was a little bit longer.
I'd like to see an anime version of "BRS The Game", I'm sure this'll be more interresting.
Maybe they want BRS to be like controversial storyline and ending like Mahou shoujo Madoka.
IMO Black Rock Shooter would've been better without all that Schoolgirl, slice of life bit. Just focused on the original characters without their human alter egos.
Anon 00:22 speaks the truth! An anime version of BRS the game should be more interesting
the game might be or rather the best one. the winter animation was totally felt like the whole thing was just to milk money. way too messed up but hey, im just an anon
@assassinister
they take out these
-hypocrite character
-angst
-yan-yuri
-school life or those slice of life stuff to convey into
and maybe change the plot into something comedy in absurd form on BRS ego
maybe the show can be saved
tho honestly, i rather hope the hype dies, and no more stuff coming from this, it was good, but now it was soiled by the money rush
its moretsu pirates, great anime series, still ongoing
"Guilty Crown was just a Code Geass Rip-off"
you must be kidding me.
Code Geass is way better than Guilty Crown.
Go watch Dora instead... BAKA!
Wow. You fail at reading comprehension. Saying "Guilty Crown was just a Code Geass Rip-off" is EXACTLY the same thing as saying "Code Geass is better than Guilty Crown."
Duh. You don't say.
Gundam (R)AGE is a shame. It's in the ugly range, not the worst one. Why ? Because other than the main character, the rest of the character has no sense at all. It's intended for "kids" and if someone can enjoy it, they are "easy going" as kid.
I don't think you've seen Gundam AGE.
Wrong, I've seen up to the latest one. People who used to speak like you are just easy going at best.
The show has been watered down to a level for kids to understand. They try to create "Good/bad" so clearly that it's almost like Power Rangers. Even so, they created the wrong anti-war message "Evil must be judged as evil" when it's suppose to be "Men are good, war is evil". Beside, zipping 3 seasons into 50 episode left them no ground to exploit each side characters stories. The animation and story quality dropped over 2/3 the show.
If you can't see the different, go watch something like Unicorn.
lol watered down to kids level? Do you know all gundam series are geared to kids right, that they produce these shows to sell merchandise aimed for kids? Although in the West we may see a gundam series like 0079, zeta or even unicorn aiming for older people, in reality its all for kids. So for saying that gundam age is a watered series made for children, I guess you dont really understand gundam at all.
Gundam Age has been declared by Sunrise that its targets is kids (like Ben10) at this point. It's you who fail to understand the matter.
I can't understand people like you who keep saying the others gundam series is for kids. I don't know where your sources is but clearly, Gundam series have very mature contents.
According to Nikkei MJ, the rating of Mobile Suit Gundam AGE has been hovering around the 2% level. Although the main target of the TV series is preteen boys, the rating among the kids sometimes goes down to zero. Bandai has been aware of the unpopularity of Gundam AGE among kids and have tried to identify the reason by conducting a questionnaire. What they found from the survey was that kids today are unfamiliar with wars and space colonies. To draw the attentions of those kids, Bandai featured scenes at school in Asem's Arc, but their attempt failed to obtain the expected result.
Despite the failure of Gundam AGE, Ueno Kazunori, the President of Bandai Namco HD, has been keeping his composure with the business. At the beginning of this year, Ueno encouraged the disheartened staff of Gundam AGE by saying, "Don't be in panic." The reason for his calmness is the favorable status of the whole Gundam sales, which has grown by 18% year-on-year. The increase is mainly attributed to the success of Gundam Unicorn. Bandai Namco HD will expand the business by coordinating the subsidiary companies taking advantage of the popularity of Gundam Unicorn among fans in their 30-40s.
According to Nijigen Shinbun, a film project of Gundam AGE has been surfaced. The authenticity of the report is uncertain.
Sources: Nikkei MJ, Jpanimate, Cyzo, Nijigen Shinbun
"Wrong, I've seen up to the latest one. People who used to speak like you are just easy going at best."
I agree that the series has many flaws. The idea of a generational Gundam series was interesting, but it was ruined by poor execution. I think part 1 was pretty terrible, but we've seen a lot of improvement with part 2 wouldn't you agree?
"They try to create "Good/bad" so clearly that it's almost like Power Rangers. Even so, they created the wrong anti-war message "Evil must be judged as evil" when it's suppose to be "Men are good, war is evil"
I don't think the good/evil is that one dimensional. But I agree that you are mostly right in this regard. I think Flit's development is starting to blur the lines of good and evil much like our beloved OYW stories, but you are correct.
I do concede that as far as Gundam goes it's pretty terrible, but not the worst Gundam; and compared to the other series on this list I feel it's not as bad as a lot of them.
tl;dr
compared to good Gundam AGE is a failure, but compared to a lot of the other anime this season I feel it's not that bad.
If you're saying that Zeta Gundam is meant for children, you're out of your goddamned mind. Zeta would go over kids' heads, regardless of whether you show it to a child in the East or the West. Some of Gundam is ostensibly meant for the 13-20 crowd. Good luck getting your ten-year-old to build a Master Grade, too. The demographic for Gundam changes from series to series, and the dramatic shift from 00 to AGE is one of the key reasons why the targeting of a younger audience is more pointedly-observable than it has ever been before.
to be honest?
i rather watch AGE, in somewhat around asemu asuno arc, then watch unicorn, or watch around the end of flit asuno arc
unicorn is a convoluted piece of bullshit i can't digest & i hate to digest, hypocrisy & ultra angst teenager & lots of dumb adults around the plot, lack of plot explaininng
i rather take gundam AGE easyness to digest & straight-forward plot
00 was like that in season 1, then season 2 have some of the episode to cool down the pace, but the plot is easy to follow and not wangsty
if gundam unicorn & other UC century is as hard to digest as other UC movies (MS igloo counts to) i rather take my seed(no destiny thank u) thank you very much
if you seen age and truely understood, then you would be puking rainbows.
you are in the presence of a new GOD! just because this series wasn't a code gayass type lamefest like its seed and 00 predecessors doesn't mean its crap straight up
even if this series is hated, in seven years it will have a better reputation in the community than any of the other alternate universes ever made.
GO SUCK YOUR MOTHER
LITTLE COCK SUCKING FUCK GUILTY CROWN IS SOOOOO MUCH BETTER THEN CODE SHIT
the power of kings? an oppressed populace wanting to rebel? doesn't it sound awfully familiar to you?
wow go eat shit.
No one beats Lelouch and the sexyness of C.C. and not to mention Kallen's huge rack!
All the charachters look like females....you must be a pussy right?
^this guys gay
Wow. Rage issues or a troll. Either way, someone needs to deal with their immaturity.
No... Guilty Crown, other than some details was completely different from code geass. But you can see how many other popular anime it copied from
Thank you! The Code Geass Rip off argument is insanely stupid =/
i felt guilty crown was more of an elaborate supercell commercial than anything.
Code Gayass was shit but C.C and Kallen are nice! Guilty Crown was shit too.
Code Geass Shit? xDDDDDDDDDDDDDD dont make me laugh
Sorry, the truth is funny.
haha nice one ;D but honestly, code geass is pretty good. i guess it depends on tastes, oh well.
DOn't waste your time with lolicon's
you are shit
U mad, bro?
Guilty Crown was a rip-off from countless of anime shows and even from Hollywood Movies. Which I don't like.
The anime should be in a higher spot imo.
Gundam AGE was good Story !!!!!
Guilty Crown should have been, if not number one, at LEAST in the top 3. So dissappointed with it, even though episodes 13-17 were a ray of sunshine that pierced through the clouds of brown shit, alas not even those 5 episodes could have saved it :(