“86%” of Chinese Would Help Crushed Girl

Its ironic you call out someone as hypocrites and then go and ask them to go help. I assume you are chinese, but what are YOU doing about it? What are you doing to help?
You are asking for proof as if the video didn't prove it enough? But didn't you just testified to it yourself? By doing nothing you perpetuate it and prove it every time. You are also suggesting that COMPASSION and SELFLESSNESS are traits only 1st world countries have. And china is a 3rd world country? Oh how the 2nd largest economy have fallen. Boasting how much 1st world countries are indebted to them. Still a third world? So much for communism, for the greater good and all that. What you really mean to say is CHINESE people itself lacks COMPASSION and SELFLESSNESS.

And an important fact that seems moronic. Good samaritans gets punish for helping? Do you not realized how stupid that is? China is the only country i know that breeds such a backwards culture that punishes good samaritans. Is it real or just a convenient excuse? And why aren't anyone doing anything about it? Not you, you said so yourself that you're useless. The way that it seems so ingrained in the chinese pedestrian mindset that it even appears in online surveys tells that its been happening for A LONG TIME. But someone else should have noticed how stupid it is, right? Oh right, human rights advocates don't do shit in china because they are in JAIL are labeled DISSIDENTS. Admit it, this is the CHINESE STATUS QUO and the chinese are ENABLING it and PERPETUATING the tragedy.

As for foreigners going there help. Im sure the chines government minders would love that. There are already people who trying to help but it be easier if the chinese government wasn't obstructing efforts or covering up those who do need help.

Another point. why didn't no one CALLED FOR HELP? Its not just 19 people there. Its a market place, with STORES with SHOPKEEPERS and CUSTOMERS. Most of whom could witness the tragedy right from the store. They've had to be willfully blind to say its a SCAM even then.

Even so, no one called the police or ambulance from their store? How much risk is that compared to burning or drowning? How much risk is calling anonymously?

Failing that, its a store Im sure they could find a bag to cover their faces and move the child to a hospital or atleast to a safer part of the street. No, not even that. It took a random passerby to help. So much for mindful shopkeepers who cares more for their goods than a bleeding child on the road screaming her life out.

If society, specifically the chinese one, can't be blamed for that then what is?

@17:02

Did you even read what I said or were you to raged up to even understand what I said. Throwing a strawmans and a tantrum shows that you are just side stepping the problems I pointed out with you people.

A single video? Are you in grade school that you have to rely on just a single video to prove that only Chinese people are like that? Then I assume that you already have a set bias against the Chinese without even thinking that this can happen anywhere whether we see it or not. But your bias is quite obvious since you so love picking out the Chinese are incompassionate and selfish. Or is that as far as your comprehension skills can go that you rely on a single video to base your assumptions on? I was crtisizing the fact that anyone would say only in China would happen can't prove it. Or can you prove to me that you know of every single incident that happens accross the world that involved someone in such situation and the victim got aid? The fact that you believe China isn't still calssed as a 3rd World tells me enough you know nothing of social and economic growth and population dsiparity.

Suggesting that only 1st world countries have selflessness and compassion? You're just throwing words in my mouth there. I guess your capability to understand the meaning behind "less unfortunate circumstances" is benign. Circumstances involve the corrupt government and the backwards ass law that aiding someone can land you in a shooting field or being punished. If you weren't living in a cave you'd understand that this also involves the the hardship that human rights groups face because of the government. But I guess you didn't understand that since you were too engrossed in laying into me for saying things I didn't say.

Why aren't I doing anything about it? Because I'm not that much of a hypocrite that I'd condemn the citizens for the governments inhumane laws that puts a ball and chain over the average Chinese mainlander and act like I could do better in their shoes. You think you can do better than the Chinese mainlanders on their grounds? Because that's what you're suggesting right there, if so go prove your metal. Go fight against the government. Go live in China. Let's see how much you can do with the government down on your neck almost every living second of your life.

All you've done is throw strawmans at me, put words in my mouth and quite obiviously showed you have a hate or dislike for the average Chinese and have been implying so from the start. Your racist undertones only proves to me that you know nothing about the situations and are jumping the bandwagon of "Durr Chinese people are heartless drones". The fact that you assume I'm Chinese is enough of evidence that you wanted to pick me out to lash with your Anti-Chinese swing. If anything you've just proved yourself to be another person in the midst of emotional rage who can't discren the reality from ideals.

@17:36

Now this I can work with. This is a lot better than your first reply. My reply to 17:02 is harsh but if I misundertood you then fair enough I am at fault and I apologize. That is if that one actually appears before this one does.

Again this comes down to civilian fear of the state. But not just that. The police can be just as corrupt. The problem is that when you have so many public services that is controlled by the state, how can you trust them, especially that of China? China is one of the largest, if not has the largest number of corrupt suits in government and public services (Can't remember who, but a politician admitted that). Triads also have infulence in the police force which makes going to the police a 50/50. That's what makes it so difficult other than have a heavy ass lawsuit that can hit you in the face. When you have both criminal organizations and corrupt politicians working together with the public services. Just "seeing" an accident could find you or your family dead the next day.

Put it this way, if you lived in fear from the government and even your own public service and scams from Triads. It's going to be risky to do anything. If the Triads have a hand in it and the child was an abducted child being used as a "Child Beggar". You really are risking your whole family for even seeing it, never mind going to aid. That's how deep the poison has reached in state and public services. You can't go to the police in fear they're in league with the Triads and the government isn't going to do anything. In a way the "If you aid the injured you will be held responsible" is an advantage to all the corrupt politicians in league with Triads. Which let's them maim, kill, target, blackmail anyone they see fit with little to no repercussions. I don't think I need to tell you this, but numerous people have gone missing just being a witness and nothing more.

The reality is, unless there's some inside upheaveal of the current governing state to rid the corrupt politicians, officers and so forth. People will live in continuous fear and turn a blind eye as much as possible. Which is unlikely to happen anytime soon. Most likely if someone did challange the current state and tries to wipe out the poison. They won't be around for much longer. You'll be making a lot of enemies. In both officals and the underground. If you're not gonna end up dead you'll be locked up for a crime you never did.

@19:22

So basically in a country of 1.5 Billion its run by the triad and corrupt politicians. I get it now.

What you are saying is China is more like Mexico now but without the gun battles and beheading, yet. Violence there happen right in front of everyone as a demonstration. But unlike Mexico, theres no overt intimadation there when the incident happen. Its also plain to see she is crushed under two vehicles. The drivers also lacks firearms besides the fact the they SLOWLY got away and left. And some more reading tells the little girl was the DAUGHTER OF A SHOPKEEPER there. I doubt other store clerks can truthfully say they don't know her.

Even so whats with the response of the passerby or shopkeepers. The passerbys completely ignored her as if some roadkill.
And again no calling for help from a ambulance/hospital or is that triad-runned too?
The other shopkeepers couldn't inform her MOTHER who was in their nearby store?

Nevermind triads, do chinese don't even trust their NEIGHBORS?

@Godot 20:41

Triads actually have a hand in hospitals aswell sadly. I don't remember the details that well but there was a few cases where doctors were reprimanded with triads when they were caught in backdoor dealings in drugs. Like I said if you knew how much of a hand these kind of people have in politics and public services as said previously, any person living there would think twice about going to hospitals.

As for the store clerks around. I honestly don't know what the relationship is between the store clerks and the victim of the parents are. Have they just moved in? If so I doubt anyone really even knew that the child belong to them. The video in all honesty isn't decisive on what's in the surrounding area is like. We can see people passing by, but other than that nothing much. But it still doesn't change the fact that people did just walk pass. But I will reiterate the point of triads. Even if there were other clerks around, if they saw this happen. They would think the triads was setting this up. Someone who brazenly runs over a little girl right in the open doesn't happen on a daily basis. Anyone would be suspicious about that. I'm not saying that is the case. But at least a likely to be the case. If I saw that happen over here, even I would think no one just does something to that degree out in the open (Though similar have happened in Africa and Jamaica) without having a purpose to do so. That's not saying I wouldn't call for police and ambulance since I have that confidence at least to trust my public services enough to do so in this country.

Again I say if this really was a case of triads being involved, just getting into contact with the child could put you on their blackmail list. They've been known to sit and wait in the shadows watching and ready to pounce on unsuspecting good samaritans helping out a "Child Beggar". Picking a fight with triads that might have connections in police and other public services isn't exactly a great idea.

I'm going to pull a stat out my ass in and say that majority of people on Earth don't trust their neighbours. So imagine a society like China where even putting trust in the police could be fatal. Trying to trust their neighbours 100% is near impossible then.

I can't express what's it's truly like living in China. I've never lived there so I wouldn't know if I would be the same as I am now if I was born then and was living there. But I have friends from China and believe me the majority of citizens just don't want to get involved with anyone because they are afraid of who it could be behind the scenes. Triads asking for "Store Protection" is still around to this day. It ain't no fairy tale. Just like how even Yakuza's are known to do the same in Japan. The only way for the average citizen in China can guarantee a safe (or safe enough) life is to not jump into things that stand out. It's sad but this is reality when you have criminals with power in charge of almost everything around you.

My beef is with the drivers more than anything else. I would like nothing more than unending torture for the 2nd driver. The people who walked pass and did nothing pissed me off. But I can understand from their point of view at least, or what could be their point of view. I pity the mainlanders because of the dangers they have to put up with everyday. It gets to you eventually if you survive long enough. I can't believe I'm gonna say this but as a certain quote implies "Would you rather die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villian?" If doing countless psychology courses has taught me anything. People in general all over the world end up the latter. Even if it's involuntary. I'm no exception.