Anime fans have voted to determine the best Shaft anime, with the top spot a predictable battle between recent blockbusters Madoka and Bakemonogatari.
The ranking, based on votes from over 2,000 Shaft fans and with votes for multiple seasons merged:
4. ef – a tale of memories/melodies
7. Sore de mo Machi wa Mawatteiru
9. Maria Holic
10. Negima!?
Although the placement of Madoka and Bakemonogatari was hardly in doubt, despairing fans will be heartened to see just how closely Zetsubou-sensei trailed them – 362 votes to Bakemonogatari’s 370 and Madoka’s 383, with ef some distance behind with 261.
My list:
1. Bakemonogatari
2. ef – a tale of memories
3. Dance in the Vampire Bund
4. ef – a tale of melodies
5. Madoka Magika
6. Tsukuyomi Moonphase
7. Hidamari Sketch
8. Sayonara Zetsubou-sensei
9. Negima
10. SoreMachi
Bakemonogatari and Zetsubou Sensei yes fucking agree 😛
actually companies should give their licenses of visual novels to Shaft more.
they’re fucking geniuses 😛
Personally I think Natsu no Arashi, especially S2, was their best.
Oh please..Japanese have the long-term memory of a mere housefly. What the f♥♥k.
A pathetic overrated piece of garbage getting 1st place? Over Bakemonogatari?
Okay then…..well, guess there was an extra 13 dumbasses that voted.
(Yes, I just called it overrated and garbage. Umad?)
>Pathetic overrated piece of garbage
>Coming from a Bakemonogatari fan
Butthurt madofag located =)
It is garbage 😛
Madoka made my hope for the Mahou Shoujo genre drop 300x down.
Madoka’s plot makes it deserves top 3 position.
But considering it’s poorly drawn and animated, that give me eyes cancer –> bottom 3 position.
Even amateur artist such as this tucana guy can draw better.
I never finished Madoka due to the tsunami business that ruined it’s run. I can’t see myself going back to finish it either. I tried SO friggin hard to see what all the “OMG AWESOME” was about, but I failed. Is this like that thing where I don’t get why other people like The Office and they all want me to die for it?
Inb4downvote 🙂
I sense butthurt madofags looming over us 😛
Amen!
For a short show, It actually reminded me how fun the Mahou Shoujo genre was…unlike this s♥♥t…..
Besides, Pleiades has better art. Seriously, the pan-cake faces of this s♥♥t just screams “DROP NOW, BURN EVIDENCE AND WASH BRAIN WITH ACID”
Pleiades was a hell lot better.