I Want to Become a Woman! – Mental Health Through Manga
- Categories: Manga, News
- Date: Feb 24, 2010 07:50 JST
- Tags: Crossdressing, Marketing, Medical, Mental Illness, Translation, Web Comic
Why do so many men say they want to become women?
Yuu Mental Clinic, an accredited psychiatric clinic, provides an explanation of this facet of male psychology in manga format with the aid of doctor Ryo Shinnai and nurse Asuna Kangoshi, translated below:
The original Japanese version.
Yuu Mental Clinic is by Ueno station in Tokyo – those in need of mental health services can visit their site here; they also publish a series of web comics explaining the treatment mental health issues through manga.
See also “Pedophilia” vs “Lolicon” – Mental Health Through Manga.
















|
Mayoiga A Chaotic Mess
Undead Darling: “Necrophilia Never Looked So Appealing”
Energetic Anna Mochizuki Figure
Top 20 Anime That Boast The Best Battles
NieR: Automata Brings New Futa (?) To The Fray
Koutetsujou no Kabaneri Dead Sexy
Etrian Odyssey V Fences Furiously
Mushroom Lollipop CM Tastefully Phallic
Seitokai Yakuindomo OAD “The Perversion Continues!”
Puzzle & Dragons X OP – “For Kids!?”
Cheerful Yukari Yukata Figure
IdolMaster Nets Korean Live Action TV Drama
Top 20 Anime Deserving of a Second Season
Valkyrie Anatomia: The Origin Announced – But…
Strangers Fisting For Candy: “A Pretty Sweet Deal!”
Netoge no Yome Grinds Hard
King Of Fighters XIV Trailer Boasts Breasts & Brawn
Yuzuruha Figure Sexy & Sophisticated
IdolMaster: Platinum Stars Trailer Happier Than Ever
Top 10 Most Anticipated Anime of Spring 2016
Marie Rose Cosplay by Mike Undeniably Sexy
Tasha Tracer Cosplay Truly Tantalizing
Witch Craft Works Cosplay by Kagune Intensely Seductive
Kaine Cosplay by Yuricha Flawless
Kasumigaoka Utaha Cosplay Pretty Pure
Goddess of 2ch “Another Bathing Beauty!”
Tantalizing Hestia Cosplay Busts Out
Kashiwazaki Sena Cosplay Pure & Innocent
Minami Kotori Casino Girl Cosplay Takes No Chances
Shimakaze Cosplay by Ema Sakura
Actually pretty entertaining for something meant to be informative
I hope for other lessons can go like this too.
1. Pregnancy (with the risk of miscarriage)
2. Societal obsession with appearance
3. More likely to get raepd/unsafe to be alone in certain places at night
4. Feminine monthly lycanthrope transformation. Followed by...
5. Menopause. Ew.
6. Externally weaker body
7. Same work. Lower wages.
8. Going to school for almost 20 years only to leave your job to have a baby (which then might become another full-time job altogether).
9. "Upstream" status quo in society.
10. Master Key/Shitty Lock allegory...
And "socially acceptable behaviors" do have their trade-offs, you know. Much less expected and acceptable for a woman to look unclean or do rude things in public.
I prefer my manhood, thank you very much.
It's a privilege to be able to have a child.
It's something men can't do... you're just reasoning from your male oriented world.
1. privilige
2. applies to men too
3. men are more likely to get their ass kicked than women have of any kind of physical violence
4. a convient excuse
5. sperm eww..
6. but more flexible and requires less food
7. depends on the country, being away from work for child birth/raising doesn't count.
8. see #1, it's not mandatory btw
9. & 10. mehh...
Try standing next to a guy and woman fighting (no matter the odds) witout trying to stop it, and you're a bad man. Watch a guy and a guy fighting and you ain't so bad. Also, ever tried to wear a dress in public?
Also you can throw a tantrum when you're angry, throwing things and and hitting guys is acceptable.
1. Pregnancy is completely optional. In addition that, law favors mothers when it comes to e.g. who gets custody of a child.
2. Men can also have such obsession. Also, women don't always have any.
3. Proof? Or maybe men wont simply talk about it? Also, men are probably more likely to be drugged (and then abused) since women can't overpower them. You should also note that men have a MUCH higher chance of being convicted of rape than women. Same for other crimes, but with rape it's far more pronounced.
4 & 5. Men also have biological weaknesses like that. For example, getting kicked in ones balls hurts quite a lot. Women don't have such a problem. Also, men have a higher sex drive and without sex (or masturbation) they can more easily become depressed. Men also have less of a chance of being laid than women.
6. Higher average lifespan.
7. Give me proof that: A) The quality of work women do (working hours, results) is the same as men's, B) they ask for raises and such in the same way and as frequently as men, C) they have the same qualifications as men and finally D) they get paid less. There's no way you can prove those. Also, the (not so credible) studies that have found proof for the "pay gap" have been mostly based on methodological errors.
8. ... Do you think they go to school when they're 2-4 year-olds or something? Anyways, getting a child is completely optional.
9. This is just an excuse for women for being weak. The strong will succeed, whether they are men or women. The opposite is also true, for both men and women.
10. Men are biologically programmed to have sex with as many women as possible. Women are programmed to have sex with one and stay with him. This has shaped the popular opinion, and for a good reason.
Socially acceptable behavior is still much more of a pro to women and a con to men, right?
I wouldn't mind being a man or a woman. All that really matters is your thoughts and actions, not your gender.
1. Completely optional, could be seen as a privilege, and because of this mothers are favored by law when it comes to child custody. In addition to this, men can easily get kicked in the balls for similar experience, but this is rarely optional.
2. This concerns many men, too, and not all women.
3. In contrast, men are MUCH more likely to be convicted of rape. Also, men getting raped is underreported because of societal pressure. It could also be said that men are more likely to be drugged and then abused since women can't overpower them.
4 & 5. Men also have biological weaknesses, such as a much bigger need to have sex (or masturbate), which leads more often to depression than in women, and also men are less likely to get laid - a lethal combo.
6. Longer lifespan, less need for nutrition, more flexibility...
7. The not-so-credible studies on this could easily been subject to methodological errors. If you can prove that A) women work the same amount and get the same results, B) have the same qualifications, C) ask for promotions, raises etc. in the same way as men and as frequently as men and D) that they still get less pay. One of those (A,B or C) almost always explain the pay gap. Or maybe you have *credible* proof of the contrary?
8. ... Do you think they start school when they're 2-4 years old? Anyways, completely optional.
9. Just an excuse for women for being weak-willed. The strong will always succeed, whether they are men or women. The opposite is true as well. Also, "upstream" is relative. There are some places in society where men have easier access, but that applies to women, too. In the end it's up to the individual whether they want to become rich, or have a family etc.
10. Men are biologically programmed to have sex with as many women as possible, while women are programmed find a man who can protect and raise their child. The master key/shitty lock allegory is based on these programmings. Also, try to turn it around. Shitty key (opens only one or no locks)/ master lock (only one key or none). See what I'm getting at? It's all relative.
Also, socially acceptable behavior is still much more of a pro for women and con for men.
I don't mind being of either gender, however, since in the end it's your actions and thoughts that define your worth, not gender.
;tldr - read the whole post, you lazy @$$.
With our current laws and current judges, I don't know which gender is safer anymore. Most men will of course go to hell if a woman(Kid girl) reports the man for some sexual reasons.
One example was, the guy who was naked in his own house and got reported by a woman. Come on!
Women were treated badly in the past, I know, but now they want to be treated like princesses.
Those are the worst points of being a man as far as I know. I don't know much about women's weaknesses, though. And don't go "Pregnancy", because that's optional. At least until you get raped.
Regarding the propensity of being assaulted, it depends on where you are. Women in some countries don't get assaulted/raped/mistreated as easily as those in other countries.
And regarding equal treatment, sometimes women are more protected. I'm a university student, and in tree of my classes, there's this girl who is loudmouthed and verbally abusive of others in a "playful way". I called her a "fucking annoying bitch" to her face and instantly, I was the bad guy for calling her that. Women I have observed sometimes act in a passive aggressive manner to get what they want, but if a man tries the same tactic, he gets shot down in the act.
Of course, not all women are like that. There are downsides for them, like being belittled, harrassed if they have a superior intelligence/knowledge/skill, etc. Still, there is a certain tolerance and condescendence towards women that stems from men's misguided idea of "let's give her a break, she's just a woman".
In short, everything's fucked.
JJ: I'm a woman, and I can say being pregnant is not a privilege. Being able to raise a baby afterward may be, but the actual carrying of the baby?
You do know that having a baby hurts, right? You may miscarry (a horrid experience even if you didn't plan the child). They could come out still-born. Pregnancy is sometimes dangerous. It's hard to be active once you reach a certain stage in the pregnancy and can be flat out dangerous. Pregnancy fucks the body up, hormonally and physically. Morning sickness is another down side.
Oh, did I mention postpartum depression?
I'm pretty sure I missed a lot of things in there.
I'm sure SOME people feel that it's worth going through all of the above (and more, including the years of periods) and that it is somehow a privilege, but it's more like a curse - especially if you're impregnated against your will.
Having a baby is like shitting from the wrong hole
Hahaha, Wrong hole!
I've grown up with nothing but younger sisters all my life. I can honestly say I am happy being a guy, and would not want to be a woman.
However, if we're talking about a temporary transformation, I'm all for it. ... In the name of science of course...
@ Anon15:10 you do know that a womans pain threshhold is heightened during pregnancy right?
or you can just play x-change
Or Raidy for that matter.
I think the love shared by two girls is often more beautiful than that of a guy and a girl. I agree with feeling timid about letting out my emotions, and I know most of it is subconscious. Kinda sucks actually, same with the style. Being able to have fun shopping and finding all sorts of fun combination's is something guys just can't do. I think its part of what makes me enjoy playing the female in an MMO where there outfits are usually quite appealing(but this could be more male tendency).
Being bored as a man is something that resonates to a degree as well. I kind of hate being hairy but shaving down would make me look rofl weird. Also the sensations woman feel during intercourse are more intense than a guys or that is the feeling I get.
the manga is great, the translation is mediocre,
I have to agree.
"7. Same work. Lower wages."
Liar. There are more women in the US economy than women now. Isn't it better to have a job, than "get paid less" according to some bullshit feminist average that says women earn less?
By the way, women are more educated than men nowadays and thus earn more than men. (20s age group, etc.) In France, 25% of young men are unemployed. You are talking total horseshit.
Seeing this makes me think "doujin, sort of want". They have a good artist.
at least they want to become women for entertaining purposes. But if they put the option "I want to become a futanari lesbian woman" what would be the result.
Do want!
i have photoshopped one of my photos and one thing is certain, i would be a seriously ugly woman.
I'm a lesbian trapped in a man's body.
I see what you did there
at least im not the only one ;_;
It's an arguable fact though. I can't say being a woman would be advantageous. Sure, overall, me being a male, being a woman seems way more attractive. Can't say I can't relate to a woman's "trials of womanhood" somehow, so rationally I do consider all the aspects that might come with it. Fashion is a good argument, but I think in a couple of years that'll balance itself out. How things go in society might be more advantageous for women, however the hormonal imbalance and obviously negligible concerns they usually express are remarkable. Having a female body would rock, although I'm DFC being a male, I still lack female curves. That would be nice.
either way imo you'll go crazy in the long run...
If you're a man you don't have to worry about physical problems yet the mind wears down pretty fast due to holding in emotions and poorly dealing with stress. Then being a woman you can do quite alot and not be look at as weird Also you express emotions very free / vividly at times but the physical issues that comes with this freedom even make women hate being on times. So each gender is a double edged sword eventhough being a man is harder and harder now that they're becoming more and more useless.
i want to become a cheeseburger
nom nom nom
I Wanna be your dog
nah... i want to be a cat lol!
"I wish I was a cat because they don't have to worry about trade defecit or gross domestic product"
Becoming a Neko?
I wanna be your canary!
I think I have heard it before...
If only they had a manga detailing non-euclidean geometry. Then I'd be in bliss...
Maybe someone should make flatland into a manga...
I wish school had been this fun to learn from.
Funniest and truest line: "If you were a man, you'd be instantly arrested..."
Nurse Asuna is awesome...
Disadvantage of being a female
- Weak physical force
- Can't run faster
- Can't jump Higher
- Can't participate in some activities mostly sport
- Fear from insect
- Fear from mouses
- Loose easily in video game
- Have always to worry about her outside looks
- Bad driver
- Have to wear High heel shoes to be taller
I consider those ones of the main disadvantage of being a female. But being a female have also advantage, also for men and vise verse that why (Men+Women)+(Love)= Best Team Ever*Epic Win
Briefly men who wish to become female is just because want to explore the female genital part of the body, I'm sure those men were happy with their sex in their childhood. Very unfortunately nobody can choose it desired sex before he born, its all random/Parent wish.
End of story
1-4 Not true. The right amount and type of exercise and a woman can excel at any of these. Conversely, the wrong amount and type of exercise (little to none, which is possible, with all of the intellectual / desk jobs out there) and a man can be absolutely terrible at all of these.
5-6 This is a purely mental trait not a biological trait.
7 This is not gender specific. Your ability to perform well at video games relies on 2 things. Starting at a young age (Activities you do during the age range of the greatest human mental development, stick with you and improve at the greatest rate), and continued "practice" or "exposure". Anyone who starts in their very late teens and/or older, tends to be below average in general, with minimal improvement. Anyone who starts at a VERY young age, tends to be considerably above average and improve greatly rather quickly.
8 Not gender specific. Though there is more emphasis on this for woman, it is still true for both genders. Unfortunately for men, this is harder than it is for woman. Go to any clothing store, it's generally 2/3rds to 90% woman's clothing. Tons of clothes, accessories, styles. You also have TONS of outlets for news/advice on fashion, men have very few. Men get shafted on this, hardcore. A lot of us HAVE to go to men's only clothing stores to get what we're looking for. Even then, it's still a gamble. I have to order stuff online, because NONE of the regular clothing stores or men's only clothing stores around here, carry anything that both, fits my taste/style and fits me properly.
9 I will give you this one. Anyone can be a good driver if they have good awareness and responsiveness. The problem is, men instinctively have a larger zone/area of awareness of their surroundings than woman do (semi-scientifically tested), and are able to react slightly faster. You may or may not be able to be a great driver but.. Paying the fuck attention to what you, and other people, are doing, is really all it takes to NOT be a bad driver.
10 Bullshit. It's common knowledge that men prefer their partner to be slightly shorter than they are. The average height difference between men and woman is only a few inches. You don't NEED to appear taller. If you still want to, you don't NEED to wear high heels (I personally think such things are dumb/ugly). All you need is.. Platform shoes! If all you need is 1-2 inches, then platform shoes can do the job. You can walk MUCH easier in those, and they can be just as (or more) stylish (little black open foot gothic platform shoes anyone!?). If you need 3+ inches.. well, no matter what, shoes are just not going to solve your problem in a "reasonable" or "practical" matter.
You sir are mixing man and Avatar concepts.
You haven't met a female army/marine soldier... I did.
Amazing manga. It's informative and entertaining at the same time without coming out as fake or wannabe.
It's perfect truth put out blatantly, which most Japanese media looks down upon. I think it's great. You can read it and say "that's what I hear IRL all the time!"
Absolutely. These manga comics for Yuu Mental Health are brilliantly done, and with a wicked sense of humour. If only more places took their lead!
Pages 5 and 6 speak volumes of truth.
I second this. >____<
But also I feel like parts of my personality would work better for me if I was a female.
They never quite mentioned that type of reason.
But still proud in being a man, right?
Yes, I love my Y chromosome. :3
...except that Y chromosome is basically a crippled version of X chromosome. If there is an X-linked recessive disease, you got it by default. I just felt that we got the short end of the stick by being guys(genetically speaking) :( Again, it's not like we get to choose anyways.
I need to keep the FAP the god given gift
As men, we have the ultimate ability to take a piss while standing upright!-
-While... women... get... multiple... orgasms...
FUCK!