Final Fantasy XIII Denied Perfect Score: “Too Linear”
- Categories: Games, News
- Date: Dec 10, 2009 02:32 JST
- Tags: Famitsu, Final Fantasy, Marketing, Mass Media, Square Enix
Gaming rag Famitsu’s review of Final Fantasy XIII has proven something of an upset, with the game getting 39 of 40 instead of the expected 40, due to the game’s story being “too linear.”
In all other respects the game is said to be exemplary.
Considering that in the last 2 years Famitsu has awarded more 40 point scores (7) than in the preceding 10 years combined, it seems likely Famitsu either felt it had gone overboard or Square neglected to be generous enough with its advertising spending…










|
Top 20 Anime Deserving of a Second Season
Valkyrie Anatomia: The Origin Announced – But…
Strangers Fisting For Candy: “A Pretty Sweet Deal!”
Netoge no Yome Grinds Hard
King Of Fighters XIV Trailer Boasts Breasts & Brawn
Yuzuruha Figure Sexy & Sophisticated
IdolMaster: Platinum Stars Trailer Happier Than Ever
Top 10 Most Anticipated Anime of Spring 2016
Splendid Abuse Eden “A Heaven of Sorts”
Hatsune Miku Ero-MMD Fit & Tight
Dissidia Final Fantasy Arcade Recruits Garland
Godzilla Resurgence Trailer Unsurprisingly Monstrous
Odin Sphere: Leifthrasir Mercedes Trailer Super Cute
Suisei no Gargantia Pachislot Unveiled
Rin Hoshizora Nekomimi Seifuku Figure
Top 20 Ecchiest Shonen Jump Manga
Hatsune Mike Ero-MMD Stealthily Sexy
Star Ocean 5 English Battles Boisterously
Dragon Ball Super Quite A Hit
Gainax Selling Tomatoes: “Why?”
Tasha Tracer Cosplay Truly Tantalizing
Witch Craft Works Cosplay by Kagune Intensely Seductive
Kaine Cosplay by Yuricha Flawless
Kasumigaoka Utaha Cosplay Pretty Pure
Goddess of 2ch “Another Bathing Beauty!”
Tantalizing Hestia Cosplay Busts Out
Kashiwazaki Sena Cosplay Pure & Innocent
Minami Kotori Casino Girl Cosplay Takes No Chances
Shimakaze Cosplay by Ema Sakura
Harley Quinn Cosplay by Miyuko Colorfully Crazy
isn't it technically because, as name suggests it, Famitsu is run by Nintendo fanatics?
After all, there isn't release for Wii. They have right to be pissed.
I laugh at ur comment
Morale: No matter how much you pay to everyone, somebody eventually will tell that the King is naked.
I think you mean Moral, morale is how good the troops feel.
That is why I have guns aimed at my subjects heads so I don't have to ask them nicely.
By the way, It was a kid who told everybody that the king is naked. That kid suddenly disappeared out of thin air.
I don't recall that latter part with disappearing from when I was little.
Who's the OP artist? Pin"E"? What is that?
"... the King is naked."
Pics or it didn't happen.
Finally fabricate focus free finales Final Fantasy.
"Pics or it didn't happen"
The scene was to sudden so nobody took a picture, but they were ready when the king tried to take his revenge:
http://i32.photobucket.com/albums/d42/jdude93/the_king.jpg
Wouldn't people usually read that as "pine"?
ahh you must be referring to the "king of pop" michael jackson, that would also explain why he was naked, why a kid saw him, and why the kid was snatched up.. er.. disappeared.
How can anyone be so retarded as to not know about the story of The Emperor's New Clothes?
Ignorant comment.
Amusingly, Final Fantasy games have been insanely linear for years. Famitsu is just clueless. This game is not a 39/40, nor was FF8, FF10, etc worthy of any of the Famitsu slobery praise.
excuse me but both FF8 and FF10 were gems..imo at least.. i'd bet you're one of those ppl that inexplicably enjoyed FF12.. one of the most boring RPG's i've ever played..
Haven't played any Final Fantasy since 8 but I agree 8 was great. Its personally my favourite one and I think people give it way to much flack and is a lot better then what others make it out to be.
@Anon 3:24 you appear to be one of the people who inexplicably liked FF8, the game where conveniant plot devices were used, over used, then used again like used sperm covered tissues. No I did not like FF12 either.
I liked FFVII, but the GF and magic systems in FF8 were a major pain for me. >_<
Anon 4:04 If you reuse your sperm covered tissues then you're pretty fucked up
Anon 4:04 = so basically like every other FF then? then yes and it turned out fine.
I liked FFXII.
You are so right. That is so me. FFXII was the best.
I liked FF8, and I've played all the rest of final fantasy including the fakes(FF mystic quest) >_<
All of you FAIL.
FF6 was the last GREAT one in the series.
FF7 was decent.
FF8 sucked monkey nuts
FF9 slight redemption
After FF9, it was all crap, especially 10.
Hear hear, Anon @ 13:44 speaks the truth. FF6/Tactics ftw! (And I mean the original Tactics, not the half assed Advance ones)
Ugg. I hated FFVI. It's in the bottom of the barrel for me along with FFII(which had a good story that was killed by the terrible leveling system), and FFIV which was just bad overall. FFIX was my favorite, but I'm looking forward to FFXIII. It's the only reason I'm breaking down and finally getting a PS3.
Anon @ 4:13 - IV + VI, bad? How dumb/young do you have to be to actually believe this? Those aren't just 2 of the best FF games, they are 2 of the best RPGs ever made.
Yeah! FFIV was my favourite out of them all so far.
...
Does ANYONE here even look back past FFIV?
You have to admit the GBA remakes were pretty badass.
it sounds more like a personal thing rather than a professional rating
Looks like it was one rater who took off a point. I don't know if they're rating different things, but the other raters gave 10's.
Nothing wrong with linear in my book. It's better than having a game where you can't possibly do everything you want to do in a single playthrough.
lol. so it's not better to have a game with lots of additional plots/endings? ...a game you can enjoy and play over and over? replayability.
Not if the game sucks balls. Plus who says it doesn't have replayability. How many people have replayed Zelda OOT like a thousand times. If it's fun you don't need to have 30 endings, plus it's possible that because there are so many endings that the endings it does have are lackluster.
An open-ended game doesn't necessarily mean it has multiple endings; it means it doesn't have you dealing with one specific objective at a time, without giving you an option as to how you go about it. The Ocarina of Time is a good example of an open-ended game, along with "sandbox" games like the GTA series and even the Mario platformers.
The Final Fantasy series is actually somewhat open-ended in its design. There are always side quests and optional bosses to deal with, along with mini-games within a number of the titles (though this is definitely a love-it-or-hate-it thing, especially among reviewers). My guess is that FFXIII lacks in those features that are a staple in the FF series, or the reviewer is just being finicky.
I agree with you there nocturne, I was mostly speaking about the anon before me who mentioned that games always benefit from multiple endings and that linear games lack replay value.
Damn, now I'm reminded of OoT and the good old times, where games were about having fun. Well, than I just have to play OoT again, maybe this time I use the japanese language in the menu. After all, I played it like 20 times already and pretty much know what each character is supposed to say. No need for new crappy games or new consoles. I save my money.
I'm really surprised it even got such a high rating. It really looks like a crappy game.
That, Chen-03, is the sign of a real 40/40 winner.
Yeah, to second the objection that in and of itself "too linear =/= fun or lacks replayability" - by that logic, reading a novel or any other kind of book lacks re-read-ability to the same reader, since it has the same story, with the same ending each time you read it.
Chen-03 has the right idea, though personally, I liked the raving insanity of going into Majora's Mask fucking clueless.
Play, beat, don't play until you can't remember, play, get own'd, LMAO until you play better.
the only final fantasy i really liked was ff9 but i didn't get to finish it because my disc 2 is messed up T-T
The only final fantasy I really liked (and played for that matter) was named mystic quest (gameboy). But no one cares, so spare us with your personal favorites unless it includes a punchline or some other fun things.
Not too sound like a douch, but Chen-03's right.
Punchline or GTFO
Only 10 was really too linear. 95% of the game was pretty much walking along roads...
Welcome to the bs nature of "review scores". >_>
Yea right? I can't believe it even got 39....
"Amusingly, Final Fantasy games have been insanely linear for years."
Something tells me this idiot didn't play either FF11 or FF12. FF12 is not linear in the slightest.
Famitsu scores are bull. That 9 actually makes me think better of the game beacuse generally 10 means the reviewer was paid off and 9 means it's actually an amazing game.
I agree. I think SE and Famitsu had a good honeymoon.
they gave 40 to 12
Which was an outrage...
Does this mean that the lower their score the better the game...?
No. 12 is better.
It means the first game deserved it and with any following game that received 100% the score lost a little of it's worth. After all, there can only be one game that deserves it to be called best game. (At least in one decade) The best game of the nineties was OoT, for the eighties it was tetris.
Truth, to the point, but effortlessly futile in the face of America, the "premier gaming empire" of the new age of gaming.
Most of the games that make it out to a non-biased review--Disgaea series from Nippon Ichi Software, among other non-advertising developer companies to be in th' US--were bashed, ripped apart, and raeped by most "Pro Gaiming Mags."
Bayonetta is not going to be released for the Wii yet they have given it a perfect score, you're right they are Nintendo fanatics.
its probably because its so horrible you cant even bribe them... i mean, if they gave 40 to piece of shit FFXII...
FFXII doesn't deserve the flak it gets. It didn't use the same old turn based combat system all the others used (and probably needed a change/to die anyway).
It was extremely open ended, for still having a linear story to follow. Boring? Really? Are people just getting lost in side quests? Maybe not enough explosions and gore?
It didn't completely rely on melodramatic teenage personas in its cast (I'm looking at you especially, FF 8).
And it didn't involve somehow saving the universe from some inconceivable threat hell-bent on destroying everything because mommy threw them in the dumpster as a baby or some crap, by battle to the death.
So, unless people are equating something not being their cup of tea with utter GARBAGE OMG THIS IS HORRIBLE AS A GAME, or dislike it because it strays from the above points, I don't believe the haet is warranted.
And if the elements above are taken to be the foundation of any and all RPGs, we need to reconsider what makes a good RPG. @_@
YOU
LOGIN MARREY MEH NOW
Not serious, but you have a excellent point.
YOU
LOGIN
MARREY MEH NOW
Not serious, but you have a excellent point.