Haruhi Manga Quality
- Categories: Manga, News
- Date: Sep 12, 2009 19:14 JST
- Tags: Adaptations, Comparison, Fail, Haruhi, Illustration, Production Controversy
Haruhi has been subjected to a number of dire manga cash-ins; the Makoto Mizuno version illustrated above was thankfully canned, but the Tsugano Gaku version visible below is inexplicably still underway…
It is easy to see who he spent all his time drawing.
Although the quality of the source material is unfortunately a given, both light novels and anime were famed for the high quality of their illustration, so it is surprising that this situation has been allowed to persist.
However, all is not lost: Puyo’s excellent Haruhi-chan manga is both original and charmingly illustrated, possibly making up for the lacklustre quality of the other manga titles.
Top 10 Best Anime Girls of 2015
Hai to Gensou no Grimgar “Has Oppai!”
Picking Up Japan Express Vol. 36 Worth a Pickup
Dimension W Out Of This World
Odin Sphere: Leifthrasir PV Certainly Nostalgic
One-Punch Man Soundtrack PV Packs A Wallop
XmasTrickStar “A White Christmas Indeed…”
Wo-Class Carrier Ero-MMD In Dire Straights
Voice Translation Tool Promotional Video “Inexcusable!”
Luck & Logic Far From Lucky
Yandere Simulator Possibly Headed to Kickstarter
Top 20 Recent Anime Most In Need Of A Sequel
Hyrule Warriors Legends PV Clashes Interminably
Akagami no Shirayukihime English Dub Surfaces
Koukaku no Pandora Really Opens That Box
Gate Season 2 Darker Than Ever
Super Sweet Sonico Bikini Figure
Top 10 Naughtiest Late Night Anime
Shoujo-tachi Mezasu Seemingly Innocent
Final Fantasy XIV Lord of Verminion Trailer Highly Adorable
Delectable Dizzy Cosplay by Lechat
Dark Elf Cosplay by Non Very Dark Indeed
Titillating Tamako Cosplay Perfectly Pink
Goddess of 2ch: “Full of Lust & Urges (& Also Videos)!”
Raunchy Reisen Inaba Cosplay by Tsuyato
Haruhi Bunny Girl Cosplay Rocks Out
Youmu Ero-Cosplay by Madoka Adachi Deadly Sexy
Comiket 89 Cosplay Sickeningly Sweet
Comiket 89 Cosplay A Guilty Pleasure
Comiket 89 Cosplay Ceaselessly Sexy
damm... there are doujins with much better detail and effort put on em than this shit.
kyon using geass is still funny as hell.
The Tsugano Gaku's manga version might not be visually beautiful, but I love the handling of view angle in the panels, new original story and the dialogues interacts.
Tsugano Gaku did a 2 volumes version of 'The girl who leap through time' and I know the art style might be the same traditional hand drawn effort with no little digital help, but the whole books story flows is nicely done, IMO.
I will give the artist another room to improve the art style, as this is still a fresh artist. She show good skill in handling scripts and panels, might be she have experience in doing behind a work scene in drama or something close to it.
I have bought 3 volumes of Tsugano Gaku`s Haruhi manga, and i think it`s not that bad. Story flows quite nicely, and his drawing is improving all the time. I hope he keeps his style close to that in vol.3.
If you want Haruhi manga look like in KyoAni anime, then KyoAni`s key animators has to draw it. I doubt they will have time for it.
Err, I have brought till volume 6 of the Haruhi manga, because I usually don't mix novel, anime and manga story together, I treat them as separated franchises. But I do feel the disappearance arc have the weirdest Kyon facial reaction.
Even though I hate the series, Haruhi has at least always looked nice, till now. >_<
(Finally found it after an accidental wikimarathon...)
Pic no. 7 is especially disturbing; how does that even PASS for an acceptable expression for such a character O_o ?
By the way, that kind of expression is known as a Slasher Smile...
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SlasherSmile
I've seed much much better Haruhi H-doujins than this.
Is Kyon holding a gun? Do it, end it all. Shoot the bitch, SHOOT HER!
Its not really a gun, its some sort of time-altering macguffin.
lolsingularity
BLOOD! BLOOD!! BLOOD!!! BLOOD!!!!
(I agree, kill that biatch. Have Nagato or Tsuruya replacing her as the new main haroine.)
Lots of doujinshi are better drawn...
looks like shit.
Don't forget about Puyo's other Haruhi themed manga, The Vanishment of Nagato Yuki-chan. It's also done quite well.
Lol, I also love that one too.
Well I don't think those are THAT bad.
I think it's the expectations of "how it should look like" that automatically is engraved into everyone's brains that causes one to say "Hmm, this looks wrong!".
>Well I don't think those are THAT bad.
Can you still say that after looking at Haruhi's menacing grin? Otherwise, I agree with you that it's not all that bad.
i simply don't care
Last picture of Haruhi scares me.
Both are official. But Mizuno Makoto's version is dead (due to an obvious reasonif you see the 1st pic)
MY... MY EYES ARE BURNING!
The giant looks cute, and Yuki looks like the quiet girl from Fap Note.
THIS IS BULLSHIT!!
Shit like this makes even the art in the Higurashi VN look good.
That second picture of Haruhi makes me want to write the caption "Do it, faggot" over it.
I see what you're trying to do and it ain't gonna happen.
No wonder people say that I can be a mangaka if I tried... and I am a fail artist!
Yes, the show is dead, shot to death by ragin fans refusing to believe it ever existed... But Nagato is still love...
looks like chines dojin :D
WTF
How the artworks look just justify what's Haruhi right now.
looks better than endless 8
..........funny
Damn That Looks Terrible.. Wel Luckily I DOnt Love Haruhi Like That/
Im gonna *BLAAAAAAAAARGH* ...~puke
We've got the novel and the anime. Why would we need a manga of it?
because haruhi is also konata and so she won't read herself as a visual novel.
That Nagato is a bloody spy!
That is NOT Yuki. I don't know who that is, but Yuki's eyebrows would merely lift and her mouth tighten. She wouldn't show such bland shock.
The most expression that passes over her face is when she's pissed at Haruhi in Endless Hell and when she forgets to remake her glasses.
That is Nagato. You've never read the Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya, have you?
Nagato love.
"I just wanted to see Yuki smile."
FUUUUUUUUUUUUU
I should have known that... Haruhi looked very alluring...
But IMHO, Mizuno Makoto's version is an EPIC Phail. Tsuganogaku's version are so much, MUCH better...
Indeed. Mizuno Makoto = FAIL.
fan made or official?
Both are official, but Mizuno Makoto's version is canned down due to an obvious reason if you see the 1st picture.
Need to note down this formula, 120% come out in exam
Taniguchis fail face scares the shit out of me! o_O
Pretty sure Taniguchi will fail wherever they stick him.
It's why we dig him.
the artist loves to draw troll faces lol