Minka the Meido’s Haruhi Dance Mania

if that was a guy...... he has pretty small hands.... and also...... is a little too effeminate in various aspects... but even so.... WE DON"T CARE !!! BWHHAHAHHAHAHA... I blame MAria+holic, MinamiKe, Happiness! Oto Boku and countless other genderfucking anime/manga

Its girl of coz! If its a guy, its like facing my dad n saying "DAD YOUR A GIRL!"

shemale =.=

Well, it's definitely a girl for me. In the end of the Hare Hare Yukai, when she fell I heard a little laugh and we can also see some boobs xD (it's maybe a trap but I don't think so)

I'd like to add that she is very moe ! and maybe an otaku ^^

Your looking in the wrong place. Any lollicon can tell you tits don't make it female. If your looking for bounce go look at a few American prons and see how much the fake tits bounce. Yeah, not much. If you trying to spot gender look at the arms. When Minka's arm is raised there is a definite curvature towards the body. Now go to the mirror and see if your arm dose the same thing. The guys convinced that Minka isn't a girl probably have ice packs on their arms from trying to get theirs to bend that way. Now what did we learn; girls arms curve-in and boys arms go straight. Minka is a girl.

She's definitely a girl..

I'd vote that she's female =3

Didn't manage to watch this yesterday, but finally did today. =D Got to say she is quite an otaku herself, wonder if she is a spinster or something..... xD

It doesn't matter which she is, because I came already.

A guy is fine too.

Of course she is a girl!! The person who thought she was a guy must have had a bad experience in the past. That's the only reasonable justification for this "misunderstanding".

Those who think Minka is a guy should note the still picture. Her legs spread outward as they move up from the knees toward the pelvic region. This is definitely a female of the species and a very cute one at that.

i'm in love

is a SHE! lol she bounce a lot xD
http://ameblo.jp/minka-ri/image-10214030099-10145202917.html

Did anyone notice an Adam's Apple? I couldn't tell, but I did notice some jiggle in the chest area (not much, mind you, and it could have been the frills). I'd say girl like the majority of you though. S/he's a cutie

She dances Hare Hare Yukai better than anyone else I've seen. Just her skill at dancing makes me think it's a girl. Cross dressers do not generally have years of dancing experience. 100% 美女

aw c'mon! >.< How can anyone think she's not a girl? They do that to be rude, right?

I say woman she has great legs

I don't know, his/her build kinda looks like a guy's - she's tall and skinny and her boobs in the hare hare yukai part looks fake. She seemed flat chested in the first part.

Wtf happened to her.
Different maid cosplay.
Different hair style.
Different thigh highs.
Different movement patterns.

Anyone notice that this 'Minka' looks totally different from the original.
Low res doesn't help q_q

its a guy! real girl's boobies would bounce around when doing those moves

Listen, People, Just because you think you're right doesn't mean you can just tell other people "You're wrong, listen to me."

When Minka comes out and says what gender he/she/it is, then you can say "OMG I WAS RIGHT! HAH! IN YOUR FACE!!!" Till then, respect others opinions, and don't be a douchebag.

Btw, i say male. Just because he/she/it is cute, doesn't mean he/it is female.

A sports bra is just an extreme way to confirm it. I say a girl. All those games and maybe really big boobed girls have made you think that boobs have to bounce around a lot when they move... guys, get a girl with average-sized boobs with a good bra and make her jump. Her breasts will move scarcely. Now, that's it. She's a girl, kinda cute by the way and absolutely owns.

You've have to be pretty fucking blind to think she's a guy.

If that's a guy, he's damn cute! (and has an awfully strange hobby)
Whatever the gender is.. I don't care (I'd say female though), I had fun watching it.

Onna, no doubt, kawaii one too~

I voted female. Then I saw the Haruhi ED dance and thought to myself "Wow, that's quite a bit of padding going on in the chest area,... maybe it is a guy..." then at the end she fell down making a cute little squeek.
If it really is a guy, I'd be very surprised. I don't think that'd really stop anyone from trying to get fresh with minka though. :V

I need simply quote one of the commenters for my own opinion:「彼女にしたい」.

She is definitely a girl; if that's ever proven wrong my life is a lie!

Would like to see her in the same costume in second vid XD

Fuck man that would be one hella cute guy lol

I just tested, called my female partner from work to come for a quicky and I asked her to jump and well they bounce, her boobs are not that big and they bounce, so i voted girl but i think its a male or a woman with 0 cup size (im from eu)