Ero-Doujinshi vs Doujinshi: 2008 Ranking
- Author: Quen
- Categories: H, Manga, News
- Date: Jan 4, 2009 17:08 JST
- Tags: Comparison, Doujinshi, Rankings, Statistics, Tora no Ana
The scope of doujinshi, or unofficial fan-works of existing anime, manga or game series is gigantic, generating over ¥55 Billion (over $600 Million USD) in 2007 alone.
Most otaku know one of the main reasons for the huge proliferation of doujinshi is the fan-artist’s freedom (or sometimes even the original artists) to insert the series’ characters into erotic situations that would be unthinkable in the original work.
Below is shown exactly how much of the total amount of doujinshi for different series sold at one major retailer is of the ero-kind, as opposed to the tamer brand of non-H doujinshi:
Notes
- This chart covers the catalog listings of Tora no Ana, one of the biggest and most well known doujinshi retailers in Japan.
- The results represent titles on sale during January – December 27 2008. This means that no Comiket 75 (Dec. 28-30) titles are included.
- The “Ero %” figure represents the total percentage of doujinshi that are 18禁 / Adult Only.
|
Series |
18+ |
Total |
Ero % |
| 東方Project / Touhou Project |
258 |
1864 |
13.0 |
| 家庭教師ヒットマンREBORN! / Katekyou Hitman Reborn! |
750 |
1801 |
41.6 |
| ガンダム00 / Gundam 00 |
947 |
1629 |
58.1 |
| コードギアス / Code Geass |
753 |
1044 |
72.1 |
| 涼宮ハルヒの憂鬱 / Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu |
378 |
731 |
51.7 |
| 戦国BASARA / Sengoku Basara |
335 |
731 |
45.8 |
| 魔法少女リリカルなのは / Magical Lyrical Girl Nanoha |
323 |
727 |
44.4 |
| 初音ミク / Hatsune Miku |
174 |
571 |
30.4 |
| おおきく振りかぶって / Ookiku Furigabutte |
161 |
426 |
37.7 |
| 銀魂 / Gintama |
199 |
384 |
51.8 |
| マクロスシリーズ / Macross Series |
303 |
369 |
82.1 |
| THE IDOLM@STER |
106 |
349 |
30.3 |
| ガンダムSEED / Gundam SEED |
179 |
335 |
53.4 |
| 遙かなる時空の中で / Harukanaru Toko no Naka de |
46 |
251 |
18.3 |
| 天元突破グレンラガン / Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann |
110 |
178 |
61.8 |
| ヘタリア / Hetalia |
58 |
175 |
33.1 |
| BLEACH |
96 |
173 |
55.5 |
| Fate |
64 |
173 |
37.0 |
| らき☆すた / Lucky Star |
69 |
170 |
40.5 |
| マリア様がみてる / Maria-sama ga Miteiru |
5 |
163 |
3.0 |
| To Heart |
115 |
154 |
74.6 |
| リトルバスターズ / Little Busters |
34 |
140 |
24.2 |
| ペルソナ / Persona |
61 |
138 |
44.2 |
| プリキュア / Pretty Cure |
76 |
122 |
62.3 |
| 鋼の錬金術師 / Hagane no Renkinjitsushi |
71 |
121 |
58.6 |
| ローゼンメイデン / Rozen Maiden |
25 |
114 |
21.9 |
| D.Gray-man |
46 |
112 |
41.0 |
| ToLOVEる-とらぶる- / To Love Ru |
102 |
102 |
100.0 |
| 魔人探偵脳噛ネウロ / Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro |
54 |
98 |
55.1 |
| ラグナロクオンライン / Ragnarok Online |
46 |
98 |
46.9 |
| NARUTO |
47 |
94 |
50.0 |
| ハヤテのごとく / Hayate no Gotoku |
70 |
90 |
77.7 |
| スーパーロボット大戦 / Super Robot Taisen |
72 |
87 |
82.7 |
| 狼と香辛料 / Spice and Wolf |
54 |
82 |
65.8 |
| テニスの王子様 / Prince of Tennis |
24 |
79 |
30.3 |
| 魔法先生ネギま / Mahou Sensei Negima |
57 |
75 |
76.0 |
| ひぐらしのなく頃に / Higurashi no Naku Koro ni |
26 |
75 |
34.6 |
| ストライクウィッチーズ / Strike Witches |
49 |
72 |
68.0 |
| 絶対可憐チルドレン / Zettai Karen Children |
55 |
69 |
79.7 |
| ゼロの使い魔 / Zero no Tsukaima |
64 |
68 |
94.1 |
| 新世紀エヴァンゲリオン / Neon Genesis Evangelion |
49 |
66 |
74.2 |
| QUIZ MAGIC ACADEMY |
35 |
62 |
56.4 |
| さよなら絶望先生 / Sayounara Zetsubou-sensei |
37 |
59 |
62.7 |
| CLANNAD |
22 |
59 |
37.2 |
| ARIA |
7 |
50 |
14.0 |
| BAMBOO BLADE |
39 |
44 |
88.6 |
| しゅごキャラ / Shugo Chara |
30 |
42 |
71.4 |
| みなみけ / Minamike |
29 |
42 |
69.0 |
| とある魔術の禁書目録 / A Certain Magical Index |
21 |
40 |
52.5 |
| ひだまりスケッチ / Hidamari Sketch |
13 |
35 |
37.1 |
| 黒執事 / Kuroshitsji |
18 |
33 |
54.5 |
| クィーンズブレイド / Queen’s Blade |
31 |
31 |
100.0 |
| とらドラ / Toradora |
23 |
28 |
82.1 |
| かんなぎ / Kannagi |
15 |
19 |
78.9 |
| こどものじかん / Kodomo no Jikan |
15 |
15 |
100.0 |
| 灼眼のシャナ / Shakugan no Shana |
10 |
12 |
83.3 |
The average percentage of ero doujinshi to total doujinshi listed here is 55.6%, meaning 44.4% of the books here are non-ero in nature.
As noted in our previous Ero-Doujinshi vs Doujinshi Ranking article, certain titles are much more prone to ero fan works.
Popular titles which have a decent, but not overwhelming amount of fan service elements included in the show/manga/game mostly have high ero ratings – Toradora, Kannagi, Code Geass and Macross all display ratings of over 72%.
Doujinshi based off visual novels are somewhat deficient in the ero ratings (Clannad, Little Busters), something that could perhaps be explained by the perceived lack of a need to make ero fan works when the original source material often include ero scenes themselves?
I have personally always believed that this sort of explanation accounts in some part for the low(er) amounts of doujinshi some series receive – especially service heavy shows along the lines of Ikkitousen or Sekirei receive less doujinshi adaptations than would be expected given the series’ popularity.
The amount of Touhou doujinshi is staggering, as always, and the vast abundance of non-ero books remains much more prevalent than ero versions.
Perhaps what is responsible is the lack of any strong narrative in the games themselves, encouraging fans to create their own?
| 
Netoge no Yome Grinds Hard
King Of Fighters XIV Trailer Boasts Breasts & Brawn
Yuzuruha Figure Sexy & Sophisticated
IdolMaster: Platinum Stars Trailer Happier Than Ever
Top 10 Most Anticipated Anime of Spring 2016
Splendid Abuse Eden “A Heaven of Sorts”
Hatsune Miku Ero-MMD Fit & Tight
Dissidia Final Fantasy Arcade Recruits Garland
Godzilla Resurgence Trailer Unsurprisingly Monstrous
Odin Sphere: Leifthrasir Mercedes Trailer Super Cute
Suisei no Gargantia Pachislot Unveiled
Rin Hoshizora Nekomimi Seifuku Figure
Top 20 Ecchiest Shonen Jump Manga
Hatsune Mike Ero-MMD Stealthily Sexy
Star Ocean 5 English Battles Boisterously
Dragon Ball Super Quite A Hit
Gainax Selling Tomatoes: “Why?”
Black Desert Online Has Much Class
Shojo Tsubaki Trailer Brilliantly Bizarre
Gargantuan Saeko Sasaki Bikini Ero-Figure
Witch Craft Works Cosplay by Kagune Intensely Seductive
Kaine Cosplay by Yuricha Flawless
Kasumigaoka Utaha Cosplay Pretty Pure
Goddess of 2ch “Another Bathing Beauty!”
Tantalizing Hestia Cosplay Busts Out
Kashiwazaki Sena Cosplay Pure & Innocent
Minami Kotori Casino Girl Cosplay Takes No Chances
Shimakaze Cosplay by Ema Sakura
Harley Quinn Cosplay by Miyuko Colorfully Crazy
Sonico Ero-Cosplay by Yuka Hoshikage Super Sexy
Wow @ Hitman Reborn...
Yaoi much?
i havent seen any non-yaoi reborn doujins... are they not interested in the girls there?
The source lists Reborn as having 1797 女向 (Female oriented) books out of the 1801 total, which makes for 4 non-yaoi doujins.
lol @ the 100% for ToLOVEru
Yeah, neither To-LOV-ero nor Ero no Tsukaima surprised me very much in that regard :P
Expected a higher number for Strike Witches though.
As noted, these figures do not include C75 doujinshi, and C74 occured when Strike Witches was only a month into its TV broadcast - certainly a small amount of time for doujinshi artists to produce works based on the series.
Kodomo no Jikan 15/15/100.0
Just as expected from Japan.
I would buy them^^
lolwat? I've never seen any Gintama ero manga.
Need more Aria ero.
Absoloutly not !
Those are some amazing figures. I had no idea that ero doujinshi was so massively popular. There are obviously tons of Japanese guys that can't get laid. What a ready-made money market.
Total 571 doujinshi for Miku? Nice for a year old software. xD
Gintaro? WHERE?
Total 571 doujinshi for Miku? Nice for a year old software.
Who could ever know that a characterized software would have such impact to the world. If only Microsoft uses the OS-tans in their product, that would be awesome.
Because Miku is just. That. Awesome.
It's easy to characterize Miku with the software because it is, afterall, a vocaloid, with its unique voice and stuff like that... but operating systems... that's a different story =S... though it might help sales a little bit for microsoft... and having some OS-tan default backgrounds would be nice.
Miku is nothing less than a virtual idol.
yea to-love-ru,Zero no Tsukaima, Mahou Sensei Negima was no surpise because we all wanted to see the protangist fuck his harem girls instead of running away. to-love-ru plot is kinda boring it's much better seeing them taking advantages.
Ero...does the list includes Yaoi and Yuri?
Yes for both, although Yuri barely exists as an ero category by itself and that sort of thing usually falls under "Male Oriented".
BL doesn't fall under "ero" category either.
As always statics are staggering~ they have their surprising and unsurprising moments as you read down the list.
Rofl holy mao for 3% ero with Marimite.
Hetalia had more doujins than Bleach (okay, not by much, but still). Wow. I knew it was popular, but I didn't think there would be so many doujinshi for it. And knowing how many people planned to draw Hetalia doujins for FuyuComi...
im abit suprise to see Shakugan no Shana fall on the bottom list in comparison with other series
yay for Touhou project...
maintaining the most doujin yet has less ero-work than an other series...
Just thought you might want to fix one of the titles:
狼と香辛料 / Spice and Wold
Nothing major, but still kinda bugs me since I love the series and it's a pretty blatant typo.
Thanks, it was a silly mistake.
i dare to throw my old theory back in: many series don't offer much playground for sexual couplings, or the fans deem the series to be "too holy to be violated".
romantic, girls manga-like or marginally erotic doujinshi seem not to be popular either, and yuri manga usually falls in that category. which, at least to me, explains the lack of marimite or touhou doujinshi.
if anything, you'd find classic adult manga with randomly added monsters, unrecognisable half-drawn gar characters, or just plain futanari.
but who would read a futa manga with yumi and/or sachiko in it? i sure wouldn't.
It's because you usually get your 'romance' or 'whatever you want to see' fix within the canon, so making doujinshi is pretty pointless. Like drawing an ecchi doujin of Bible Black; you already got enough in the original work.
Fans want to see what they don't show in the canon, only what they heavily imply (or even don't imply at all).
Woah, 100% on Kodomo no Jikan.
and on to love-ru
I think with Gonzo's financial troubles and the popularity of hentai we may well see a Mega Milk animated hentai.
whats the source of the Yumiko pic at the top? it looks good enough to be official.
Kodomo no Jikan FTW
I <3 Loli's XD
>Toro no Ana
lol XD
Poor Quen...
Damn it all.
It makes sense, because all of us like different characters and sometime want to pair them up with characters that we know will never happen within the actual series. So Doujin is a really smart and successful way to express that
Let's just say it as "fanfics given a graphic form."
For some reason I think doujins do their "shipping" work way better than what I could think of.
cvcv