The imminent third season of troubled baka-yarou anime Minami-ke, Minami-ke Okaeri, has been unveiled in modest detail with the release of a brief trailer, allowing a fair comparison between the three seasons.
Minami-ke fans are seemingly split between those who consider the new series to represent a complete collapse in design quality, and those who think it compares well with Okawari. We need not consider the other possible opinion, vanishingly rare as it is.
You can evaluate it yourself below:
Season 1:
Season 1 versus 2:
Season 2:
Season 3:
The short CM itself:
Player 1
This is Asread quality…
[poll id=”65″]
Also, Haruka in the third season actually shows other emotion besides the selfless kind self that is pretty much dominant (or more like all the time) in the second season. I actually seen Haruka show some anger and disappointment towards Kana.
Animation and image wise, I think it got worse. The second season looks way too like the stereotypical drama-anime. However, the style of the art is more like the first season (without the subtile shading and whatnot).
But most importantly, the third season is actually funny again or it is bringing back the funny that is LACKING in the second. The second played VERY MUCH like a typical story driven anime… It lost its comical timing and breaks of the first.
third season shows what a studio can do when they have proper supervision by the author.
1) ep is now structured to contain manga neta.
2) chara design is actually comparable to manga, more so than domu’s version despite domu’s version being more cute.
3) op rips off 1st season’s op
4) bgm ripped off from 1st season.
5) no random ass pussy boy coming in out of nowhere then leaving in the same fashion.
I don’t know about you guys but I am loving the third season. I agree that the second season sucked but you gotta give them a chance.
Hosaka got nerfd!! The quality dropped a lot but..I’m still going to watch it, for the sake of Hosaka