2channers are currently amusing themselves at the expense of the rest of the world by looking at what sort of manga they are buying.
Even if we restrain ourselves from making national characterisations on the basis of the manga being bought, as is rather tempting in the case of Germany, the results are interesting:
2008 April to July:
|
USA |
UK |
Germany |
France |
China |
1 |
Naruto |
Death Note |
How to Draw Manga |
Naruto |
X Complete |
2 |
Berserk |
Art of Spirited Away |
Futari Ecchi |
Death Note |
Advanced Manga for Beginners |
3 |
Let’s Find Pokemon! |
How to Draw Manga: Body and Motion |
How to Draw Bishoujo & Bishonen |
One Piece |
Ginka Eiyuu Densetsu Complete |
4 |
Fruits Basket |
Nausicaa |
How to Draw Digital Manga |
Samurai Deeper Kyo |
Hitori Kurashimo 5 |
5 |
Vampire Knight |
Pokemon |
How to Draw Japanese Style Manga |
City Hunter |
Doraemon |
The US at least looks to have a respectable, if unremarkable, set of bestsellers, as does France and to a lesser extent the UK. Pokemon exerts a hold over the English speaking nations, as does Naruto, it seems…
Is there some reason for this remarkable performance by Germany? Sex and how to draw manga? Or are we simply to assume an idiosyncratic or deliberately slanted source used?
An alternative for Germany is provided by our own Anonymous:
1. One Piece
2. Naruto
3. Detective Conan
4. Battle Angel Alita Last Order
5. Inu Yasha
The date likely differs, and probably it excludes the “How-to” volumes popular everywhere, so don’t get too excited.
Compare to the 2008 ranking of manga sold in Japan… It should be said this set is not on the same order of reliability as those, so take care in interptreting it.
Sorely lacking in sources but eh, interesting I guess..
GTFO Naruto
I love the people nerdraging on onepiece in the japanese article, even though it is good
I totally had that Let’s Find Pokemon book – got it when I was in elementary/early middle school. They even made a sequel to it in 2000.
They released a “complete” version (pressuably with both the original and sequel) in 2006 that had the original book’s cover..so I’m assuming that’s what’s on this list… but, what’s it doing on charts in 2008? How bizarre…
It’s a rather cute book though, that’s for sure.
Berserk in second place brings much joy to my heart