Hmmm.... I had some tough choices to make here. A few were easy but I didn't have any Abstains which I liked.
the 2 girls from "Aria & Scarlet Ammo" were no brainers
Louise the Zero, Tsumugi Kotobuki, Ritsu, Asuka & Rei (Eva), Kuroko Shirai, Shouko (Baka no Test), Yozora (Boku tomodachi), Haurna, Himeji, Kyoko.
The real toughie was Sen "Bento" vs Kurisu "Steins Gate) - In the end I had to go with Sen. She drives me wild - I just love her. Her eyes mezmerize me.