Comment on Top 15 Anime Based on Light Novels by Yamato:

Avatar of Yamato

oh wait, I just checked the full listing. FMP did make the list… at last (25th) place…. with 4 votes… and 24th place got over 40 votes…. and Hidan no Aria ranked 17th…. and I think I’m gonna be sick.

Yamato made other comments on this post:

Recent comments by Yamato:

  • Seiyuu Shirakawa Sumiko Passes Away:
    I stand corrected; looking at her Japanese wiki entry (rather than her pitifully short English entry), it seems that she DID branch out to quite a number of roles early on in her career. However, it seems that once the ’70s were over, she began to restrict herself strictly to Doraemon and Sazae-san.

  • Seiyuu Shirakawa Sumiko Passes Away:
    Agreed that the author’s choice of words are a little off. She may’ve had a long-running career in two shows that are widely popular in Japan, yet those same two shows seem to get surprisingly little recognition outside of Japan (even among otaku, oddly), and she never exactly branched out to a variety of other roles in all this time either (unlike most seiyuu who DO get more recognition internationally). Hell, I probably wouldn’t have even heard her myself if not for the fact that she makes a …

  • Top 10 Best Anime, According to Anikore:
    Oh thank god, someone else out there thinks that Clannad is overrated as hell. Seriously, it’s like everyone who talks about it forget that Air and Kanon existed (both far superior series). Also, fuck that reset button ending.

  • Top 10 Best Anime, According to Anikore:
    I don’t mind Code Geass on there. I DO, however, mind that both Code Geass and Code Geass R2 are counted as separate entries. Fuck that, they should both count as the same thing. Also, Madoka is on the full list. However, it ties for 18th place along with three other series: Scientific Railgun, Hyouka, and Gurren Lagann. And just to add salt in the wound, it’s two places below Sword Art Online (16th).

  • Top 10 Best Anime, According to Anikore:
    It is on the full list, where it manages to outrank such classics as Angel Beats, Evangelion, and Madoka Magica. That is some serious bullshit right there.


Recent Articles