Comment on Top 25 Anime of 2000-2012 by Anonymous:

“probably because Bakemonogatari requires critical thinking skills, which many lack”
Wrong.
Bakemonogatari requires a deep understanding of Japanese culture, which obviously many non-Japanese lack.
When suppressing your troubles makes you lose weight, lost snails become lost cows, or a monkey’s pawn becomes a devil’s hand, lacking the basic understanding of the underlying culture is what makes that show underwhelming.

Basically, it’s like a show based on word plays. Once translated it loses a lot of its original qualities.


Anonymous made other comments on this post:

  • Top 25 Anime of 2000-2012:
    Most on the list has loli and tsundere heroin. zzzzz

  • Top 25 Anime of 2000-2012:
    lol 2000-2012? i think there are mostly titles from 2008-2012…. yea no GitS SAC… Samurai champloo is also very good anime theres no Macross or other very good animes

  • Top 25 Anime of 2000-2012:
    This list was mistitled. Top 25 Moeblob anime of 2000-2012. Afterall, most of the otaku who vote on these lists are B Type. For us who are A Type, we know whats good for us, and they know whats good for them, while cringing at their choice in anime.

  • Top 25 Anime of 2000-2012:
    monster = overrated boring show

  • Top 25 Anime of 2000-2012:
    FMA and Death Note aren’t on here probably because it wasn’t an ORIGINAL anime (it was manga).

Recent comments by Anonymous:



Popular

Recent Articles