Comment on Top 25 Epoch-Making Anime by Anonymous:

Dear lord, you guys don’t understand the concept of “epoch-making”? Influential?

For something to be influential, the work must affect OTHERS works. Is like saying how a movie or a manga with revolutionary ideas created a bunch of similar or inspired works.

Like Pokemon. After Pokemon, a wave of “kids with their *monster/robots/csrds/thigs* became famous. The concept of a powerfull pet might have appeared before, but the way Pokemon presented it became worldwide famous, and changed the industry forever.

Madoka can’t be influential because it is so new that *nothing* was inspired by it.


Anonymous made other comments on this post:

  • Top 25 Epoch-Making Anime:
    K-on??? lol… I pity this list. Lucky Star and Haruhi were great… but not epoch-making. There are some good “epoch-defining” anime on this list, but epoch-making? I think the author is confused. Or maybe the translation is incorrect.

  • Top 25 Epoch-Making Anime:
    DBZ is 8

  • Top 25 Epoch-Making Anime:
    Being influenced by something doesn’t mean that something had greater influence though. Otherwise let’s just trace back to the beginning of drawings or something equally ridiculous.

  • Top 25 Epoch-Making Anime:
    Not like that last part means much, almost anything is influenced by something. The list didn’t say anything about not being influenced as a requirement to be in it. That being said, I think it’s a bit new to be considered influential quite yet, that’s to be seen.

  • Top 25 Epoch-Making Anime:
    What? No “Yu-Gi-Oh!”? Invalid list is invalid.

Recent comments by Anonymous:


Popular

Recent Articles