The artists of 2ch continue to supply more direct comparisons of the supposed superiority of 2D to 3D, a debate which seems unlikely to be settled any time soon – and least of all when dealing with such high quality 3D subject material.
Some of these ladies are much better looking than their 2D counterparts, and vice versa. Either 2ch needs to start using pictures of unattractive ladies or start finding better artists, because I'm still not convinced.
Yeah. However i think many fanarts shown here are not that good. From the other hand most of 3d women in this gallery are idols or sth. So the comparison is a bit pointless.
Well, most of the 3D girls are just plain adorable. 28 and 30 makes my heart skip a beat.
2ch can easily prove their point by posting pictures of downright ugly women and then making then moelicious. It doesn't work so well with already good-looking women.
I think each of the d's have their own strength; 3D is real and touchable, plus it has the added effect of having the persons own free will. 2D will always have to be controlled, since it's someones production.
2D on the other hand, is able to go free and beyond boundaries of realism; this makes you able to bend the drawing with only your creativity as it's limit. And the fact that it's 2D and can't be touched, etc; But that won't be a limit for long.
Well this post is oficialy the Round 3: well 3 - 0 The 3D was always over the 2D. Only in this case 14, 18, 25, 43 picture was great but no over the 3D version.
I'm tired how the artists try to show that the 2D is better that the 3D. Are they blind? Why can't see they can not win?
Once again, the 3D largely dominates the 2D side. I'm beginning to wonder if the titles of these are in jest... Forgive me if I'm late for the train on this.
photoshopped 3D > fantasy 2D > real 3D?
Or maybe they are both equal when comparing the best of the best of each? It's no use showing ugly women and good art, or good women and ugly art. >.>
They already can give up.
Did they ever have a chance to begin with?
People suck at drawings, that's why 2D lose here.
Yes. Thank you.
nope. still not convinced...
ACtually, 2D actually wins this one, save for a few badly done ones. I was wondering when there'd be a well done one.
2D is better.
Enjoy being a permavirgin then.
Do you mean a wizard?
Are you a wizard? [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LF_oD9WVUBI]
not like liking 3d would make him lose his virginity lol
Some of these ladies are much better looking than their 2D counterparts, and vice versa. Either 2ch needs to start using pictures of unattractive ladies or start finding better artists, because I'm still not convinced.
Topic picture very gorgeous. anyone know name?
risa yoshiki
http://0.blog.xuite.net/0/a/2/2/24636957/blog_2172340/txt/41252070/2.jpg
heh I like 2D fuko a lot.
Ewww Disgusting 3D never went to disgusting ewwww .
The 2D is the best thing in the world ( Sankaku don' t ever put this 3D filth on here its disgusting )
2D is already past, I just love 1D girls, My Waifu: _____________________________________________________
But your waifu is so plane! She must have been gaining dimensions. You should keep her normalized.
Hipsters visit SanCom?
Sorry, but these only prove 3D is better than 2D.
Yeah. However i think many fanarts shown here are not that good. From the other hand most of 3d women in this gallery are idols or sth. So the comparison is a bit pointless.
#6 is excellent.
Well, most of the 3D girls are just plain adorable. 28 and 30 makes my heart skip a beat.
2ch can easily prove their point by posting pictures of downright ugly women and then making then moelicious. It doesn't work so well with already good-looking women.
28 and 30 are prime examples of 2D by far surpassing 3D.
It's all subjective, I think 30 is hot as 3D but not so much as 2D, but hey, to each their own, non?
LIGHTNING IN FF13 IS ACTUALLY 3d LoL
oh my gawd my Svetlana what the fuck did they do to you transforming you into a 2D so manly???
More importantly, 38->39 anime Lenfried woot!!! :D
See, 2ch thread has the problem where they are taking professional photo shoots and having mediocre-to-decent artists redrawing them.
Even though it's "stacked" in favour of 3D, 2D still wins out in a lot of these comparisons...
WTF?
http://img2.sankakustatic.com/wp-content/gallery/misc-ero-xi/2ch-makes-3d-moe-4-033.jpg
http://img4.sankakustatic.com/wp-content/gallery/misc-ero-xi/2ch-makes-3d-moe-4-055.jpg
These art give 2D a BAD NAME!
it doesn't work so well with already photoshoped pictures
fixed
30 is freaking hot <3
So true. Anything above 24 is a sweatshop.
As long as I can wank out of it, 2D or 3D works just fine.
First of all, remember that 2d is better than 3d because it's there when you need it, and not when you don't. It is free and so on.
The pictures here for me seem kind of even, but mostly because these are some relatively hot girls compared to relatively bad drawings.
Yeah, only cases where the 2d was better was when they used girls with some seriously FUGLY faces..
Also have ones like:
http://img4.sankakustatic.com/wp-content/gallery/misc-ero-xi/2ch-makes-3d-moe-4-014.jpg
which make you question what the hell they where even thinking..
@Vitu 05:38
Sorry, but that's like your opinion.
for the most part absolutely. i will say though that big boobs look better in 2d than 3d.
Basically, the equation we're going use is 3D > 2D And we solved it, the equation is: 1 > 2/3. Yup, the equation proves it's true that 3D > 2D.
I thought the same thing while looking through the pics
I agree
I think each of the d's have their own strength; 3D is real and touchable, plus it has the added effect of having the persons own free will. 2D will always have to be controlled, since it's someones production.
2D on the other hand, is able to go free and beyond boundaries of realism; this makes you able to bend the drawing with only your creativity as it's limit. And the fact that it's 2D and can't be touched, etc; But that won't be a limit for long.
Of course, AI might turn the tables. xD
True
Honestly speaking, these 3D looks delicious...
Well this post is oficialy the Round 3: well 3 - 0 The 3D was always over the 2D. Only in this case 14, 18, 25, 43 picture was great but no over the 3D version.
I'm tired how the artists try to show that the 2D is better that the 3D. Are they blind? Why can't see they can not win?
agreed 3D FTW
i agreee, an again most are only traced photos.
you are correct.
Finding myself siding with both worlds for many of them in this set (except for the loli - always 2D).
Once again, the 3D largely dominates the 2D side. I'm beginning to wonder if the titles of these are in jest... Forgive me if I'm late for the train on this.
Some were improvements some not undecided not as many 2.5 d p
Maybe it's...
photoshopped 3D > fantasy 2D > real 3D?
Or maybe they are both equal when comparing the best of the best of each? It's no use showing ugly women and good art, or good women and ugly art. >.>
Yup, 3D wins this round.
3D wins again. fixed*
Sometime this kind of opinion makes me thinking about the possibility of existence of "Uncanny Wall" on american of comic and games.
(In b4 calling me Jap, I am brazilian.)
yeah. all those 2D vs 3D comparisons just convince me more and more 3D is definitely better than 2D
THOSE THAT DOWNGRADED HIM ARE FUCKING SHIT HEADS!
THOSE THAT DOWNGRADED HIM ARE FUCKING SHIT HEADS!
23452TR3
yeah, the title of the article says one thing, but the content proves the opposite
Im sorry but you have eye cancer...
I 2nd that.
I do believe the amount of people getting eye cancer is growing at an alarming rate.
R.I.P
You are all such wretches.
I still laughed though.
Comedic ingeniousness on Sankaku!
*Laughs and applauds*
I hope you're not making jokes like that at work, or you could be looking for new Jobs...
iTake it u mean iCancer?
Sorry, but these only prove that you are a faggot.
THOSE THAT DOWNGRADED HIM ARE FUCKING SHIT HEADS!