The Tokyo Metropolitan Assembly has decided to defer consideration of their bill to ban loli manga until their next session, a de facto if temporary rejection.
Although lacking the unambiguous finality of a “rejection” and still capable of being revived, a deferred bill is one way Japan’s generally spineless politicians contrive to avoid appearing to either strongly oppose or support a bill likely to upset constituents either way.
In this case it seems likely politicians were mindful that they faced ferocious criticism from the manga, Internet and publishing industry were they to support the bill, but also faced the deadly prospect of a tearful Agnes Chan lambasting them in the glare of a media spotlight for not doing enough to protect Japan’s imaginary children.
Neither prospect being to any politician’s liking, the members, a fractious mass dominated by the leftist DPJ and with the formerly supreme LDP some way behind, along with a smattering of Sōka Gakkai cultists and Communist holdouts, opted to shelve the amendment until the next session.
Such bills frequently find themselves quietly abandoned at a later date – in fact a similar fate befell the previous national ban in the Diet, despite Agnes Chan’s best weepy act.
The crazed PTA behind the ban is unlikely to give up however – it has already equated opposition to its desire for censorship to “violence” whilst explicitly saying opponents of any ban should be considered “mentally ill.”
The next battle in the campaign to protect the freedoms of creators is likely set to be Osaka, although it is hard to see Japan’s long suffering second city and cultural counterweight to the might of Tokyo being eager to drive its creative industry into the arms of its top rival.
Top 10 Most Followed Seiyuu
Wonder Festival 2012 Winter Wondrous As Ever
Ciel nosurge: “Your Date With Ion = $170″
Nisemonogatari – “Where Did All The Ero Go!?”
Police Hunt Ushijima for “Public Indecency”
Cops Bust Cop in Nude BDSM Club Raid
K-ON! “Causes Keionbu Girl Band Boom”
Vippers vs Vankers: 2ch Targets “Korean Propaganda”
Overflow Delays “Final” Game: “We Are Not Going Bankrupt!”
Ritsu Topless Manga Time – “She Has Boobs After All!”
Top 10 Most Boring Anime of Winter 2012
Behold: The ONACOUNTER
Future Diary Unveils Eye-Popping Scenes of Sex & Guro
K-ON! Pilgrims Invade London
Top 10 Essential Anime Elements
Lolicon Teacher Rapes Pupils 37 Times, Faces 30 Years
Strike Witches Movie Trailer Unveiled
China Menaced by Exploding Coins
TMA Makes “BL” Tiger & Bunny Cosplay AV
Hatsune Miku Takes Over New Chitose Airport
“Post The Highest Level Cosplay Ever!”
“Share The Cutest Cosplay Ever”
“Dolls vs Figures – Which is Best?”
“Why Do Girls Always Have Such Cute Rooms!?”
Ranka Lee Wedding Dress Cosplay by Tomia
Shoko-tan’s Madoka & Ika-chan Cosplay “Excessively Cute”
Guilty Crown Yuzuriha Inori Cosplay by Sasa
IdolMaster G4U: “Who Needs 3D Idols Now?”
Anegasaki Nene Cosplay by Rinami
“I Want To See What The Vipper Girls Wear To Bed!”
Thank you loli goddess! our pray is approve. BANZAI!!!!
I found odd that nobody posted this before, but ok anyways:
This was a triumph.
I'm making a note here: HUGE SUCCESS.
It's hard to overstate my satisfaction.
ALL HAIL LOLI
YES!!
*Cartoon M. Bision style* YES!! YES!!
Its the lobby! xD
Try to ban private Guns in the USA... you wont come far.
Same to loli in japan. But you cant kill people with loli xD
Win!
They can try whenever they like. The outcome will be always the same.
The best thing I've seen in months.
Serves you right, Agnes Chan XD.
She should be kicked out of Japan! Geriatric Pop star or not!!
She isn't ethnically Japanese to begin with!
Okay today is my friend's Birthday and omgosh reading this was the best hahaha im going to get so drunk today for him and for THIS !
Really?
Today's mine, too! I'm 39!
Fun, and first of all ridiculous, to see that users of this blog are still crying every day against hypothetical loli-ban in Japan while loli-manga is already illegal in USA and Europe. Instead of giving your opinion about what should be "Free Speech" in a far-away country like moronic wannabes, make something about your own government and laws.
if it's not legal here why can I go to a bookstore and by Dance in the Vampire Bund? That would have been one of the things banned by new law. And trying to get a sane law or vote passed in the us is pretty moronic thing to say considering we can't even get health care to our people right so every day people die from easily curable sickness.
Sure, if you're willing to have your social life and reputation destroyed without any hope of redeeming or clarifying your arguments to an emotional mass with an intellectual horizon of about a foot.
Why would you care for your place and reputation among such people?
Many of our nations may have a ban but they are not the creators of loli manga and anime. Japan is. So even with out them loli manga and anime won't stop as long Japan can continue. Also 95% of them don't even know about manga and anime so you can have it and no one will chase you as long you are not some sick fuck who's in to real sexual depictions of children and make your self notice.
But despite all that, this is not about loli's but freedom of expression and if i find a way to make a change i will still take it. Unfortunately am not rich not a politician and even trying to make people see the rights of my words by preaching would be pointless since as i said 95% of people don't even know what this is all about or care. Those bans are the kind of laws that they passed in the middle of the night with out any citizen even hearing about it and most importantly hearing the truth about it. Hell half the politicians who vote them don't know well what it was about.
all hail Agnes Chan
Wait,what?
Yes! JUSTICE!
Score one for humanity.
once they start preaching to censor "violence" they effectively already lost the ban on loli.
good news indeed, but I'm sure that the issue will be brought back to light in the future, probably after some incident involving otaku no doubt.
It will probably be brought up again in such a way that they can conceal it's true meaning, then start throwing people in jail using a technicality. It would be much easier to pass and they still get what they want.
Yeah! Legalize! loli-FTW!
meow meow of course it wouldn't pass sillies
a government is an amoral machine. in the end what matters is the bottom line - profit! the loli industry is veery profitable. morality isn't so much.
Just as keikaku
But what if they come with a compromise: we ban loli manga, you can marry 2D characters...
Whats the point if I cannot marry 2d loli characters.
FUCK YEAH!!! LOLICONS AROUND THE WORLD REJOICE!!!
8DDDDDD
loli ftw <33
Victory at last! For love, peace and justice!
You damned lolicons...
can i ask whats the name of that character in the pic?
It's only postponed. We will repeat the same shit until the end of the universe.
doh Sankaku, You and your Misleading thread titles and misleading use of words
"Tokyo Loli Bans Fails"
bullshit, it hasn't Fail, it just been postponed to vote, with means that nothing has changed, and who knows, it might pass this time, and even if it is rejected this time, it could be the last until next year
This is exactly what happened to the national level ban - postponement is equivalent to failure, but with the prospect of revival.
Stupid groups of people that are narrow-minded are annoying to the extreme.
This is the perfect time to stock up on cake before this war is over...
It ain't over yet. It's too early to celebrate. We won the battle, but the loli wars have just begun.
They'll be back harder, bitter, nastier, stronger. I can guarantee you that.
Then we need to continue the assault and deny them an opportunity to regroup.
In the US we have our own moral fags as well some are real steaming piles of dog flop even worse then the loliban people such as Westboro Baptist Church and Calvinist types at large.
The worst are these fraking SOBs I'm at all out war with these wastes of carbon atoms.
http://thinkprogress.org/2010/03/12/texas-education-board-cuts-thomas-jefferson-out-of-its-textbooks/
I have been reading this kind of topics and i thinks that the only way we have to fix their brains is to appeal to count for insulting us by calling us rapists and staff. They wont care for words but if we strike their money they may just get it.
No point in speaking with fanatics.
Agnes Chan is in her hell, all's right with the world.
Why ban loli? I'd much rather have a fictional child get violated than an actual child.
Cake wins!!!!!!!!!!!!
We must eat it!!! But first, we set our sights on Osaka!
we won't get fooled again.
Sweet, SWEET victory~
A round of loli for all us fine gentlewomen and gentlemen! and With more to come!
Certainly a cause to celebrate. Agnes Chan and Equality Now and all you holier-than-thou moralists, please go fuck yourselves, or perhaps we can hire some VIRTUAL AND FICTIONAL 2D characters to do it for you. (Note the caps emphasis, in case they're too thick-headed to understand and end up attempting to sue me. )
Indeed, the number of heavyweight mangakas and nearly all the publishing houses lending their weight against this movement is definitely the deciding factor here. Well done.
That battle may be won, but the war is not, as it seems Osaka will be the next. Keep up the good work, Arte.
Beware temporary fails.
It's a long used political strategy to ram something through that would definitely fail otherwise.
Case in point: "Pluto" being removed from "Planet" status. They made it look like the attempt failed, then snuck it in right after.
Pluto wasn't a loli. He was a dwarf. Although I preferred him in full planet status glory.
I think the guys behind it were just afraid a sizable portion of the Oort cloud would become a "Planet" once the funding for a good probe could be sent combined with "Planet Finder" telescopes capable of finding things in the next solar systems. But, doing so it really freaked people out and the results are being still felt today.
First, the "Snuck in the back door" move fueled anger that's being used by the "Tea Baggers" now in the health care debate. Second, it did hurt donations for funding. Some people even used it to lobby against science funding. Third, it's amazing there's been no vandalism, but a lot of places have increased security accounting for it. It's even used by the "Home Schooler" people, even though those people usually are "Jack Chick" style fundies who reject science.
There are plenty of 'cautionary tales' not to do stuff like that. One time a whole town labored for a month or so in the UK to shovel dirt on their town's "Mountain" shortly after an "Official surveyor" said it was slightly too short.
IMO, it would have been far better if they kept Pluto, named the next one "Xena" then just said "Icy asteroid nearly as big as Pluto" for the rest of them...
I mean, what's next: Should we call earth "Sol 3" like it was Star Wars? And then consider even "Sol" mythological and just make a number that starts in a spiral pattern from the chaotic soup in the milky way, so it's a number in the billions then a dash-3?
lolz that's right dont let em ruin japan!
What Tôkyô needs is a new Metropolitan Governor. Old man Shintarô Ishihara's a sex-hatin' rocker jockey that been in office too dang long!
The guy's in his late 70s, for cryin' out loud.
They should replace him with that Nobuto Hosaka guy from the SDP--the guy who defended freedom of expression and lolicon by opposing this stupid amendment.
We are virtorious.
Not yet... a battle is won, but the war is not over
To Osaka, brethren~!!
As many times Sōka Gakkai cultist have try to convince people to give them money and young men in Japan.Why would you want young men and money when you unless you want young man and money to spend on one of them?
Fools you can't stop the loli! Loli is all powerful!
THOUGHTCRIME IS NOT A CRIME...
My, you have developed quite some boobs there, Beako.
...Oh, and, uhm, FUCK YES LOLIS!!!
not to rain on everyone's parade, but the battle may be won but the war is far, far from over
alot of people are mentally ill according to this PTA
they would not like me at all xD
Lolis will never die.
Another victory for the people of Anime and again multiple losses for the backwards religious brainwashed masses.
RAW! RAW! FIGHT THE POWAH!
srsly, who rly thought banning loli is a good idea. This is what they get...
uh y'all lost again bitches
^_^
So that is how it works,"defer consideration" basically means rejection LOL. That is victory!
The sonorous whispering of the dying tempest fades away and at long last, the beleaguered defenders of Right to Free Speech crawl back up from their battle of attrition with the tyrannical despots hoarding their imaginary children. A silent cry of triumph rises up from the mute throats of spineless otaku and perverted heralds of loli-lovers sing their joyous hymns to their DFC goddesses in praise of their victory.
tl;dr Stay tuned until the next episode of LoliB&ers VS NaughtyTentacles.
YEEEAH!!! With the best alliance none can ban Freedom!
Banzaiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!!!!!!
おうううう!!! \(o_o)/
WIN!
Show them the economic consequences of the ban and they fold right away, lol.
break a cherry for this?
They'll be back. It's postponed, but not forgotten.
Agnes Chan and her cohorts are (like) criminals; if they want something done, they'll find a way, no matter what it costs and they don't care who has to suffer for it.
I just hope the same people who formed the opposition will show their faces again next time, preferably in larger numbers still to get this ban permanently canceled.
Starts end music from Return of the Jedi!
I shall now "Futterwacken" vigorously in honor of this victory.Let the "Futterwacken" begin.
=/ it is impossible to ban lolis...too late loli ban-ners!!
In my opinion, it does seem pointless to try baning lolis from the start. lolicons would go underground...
turns out the politicians, were semi paedophiles!!!
No it doesn't because we are not talking about real lolis.
YAY! LOLI's FOREVER! Seeing that made my night ... I can go to sleep happy now.
Tearful Agnes-chan, I would pay to see that.
I wouldn't. That would just give her more attention than she deserves.
still worth it...
Victory.
This isn't a victory, it's only a moment's reprieve.
L-O-L@P-T-A. If they're so desperate to protect lolis send their pathetic selves over to the middle east where they can protect real lolis.
*Gets out Delicious cake!*
I want my cake with a hint of Agnes Chan's tear of utter defeat. I will smile and laugh after eating a slice, knowing that she will always fail with such stubbornness in this world.
Hooray for lolis. I love lolis. :3
Bandai, bandai, loli FTW
V
V !
That is just an example of how we are being rule by stupid politicians that only know to make and implement the rules and laws without even know the effect of their action...
Because of them we had to suffer a lot... like our favorite manga, anime and games being banned and cannot be produced anymore...
If that was the case then they wouldn't have the power to change the laws or manipulate opinions.
There job isn't to just sit there and do whatever there is in a book, they are there with the responsibility of doing the best for the people and improving life of there citizens and they have to have at least some wisdom and take decisions where they have do.
The idea was to put the most capable people in charge of the ship because it's impossible for all of us to run the ship at the same time since there are too much people to simply gather and talk a matter.
Unfortunately instead of the most capable now we only have rich people who took power and seats, sons and daughters of previews politicians, thieves and fanatic morons.
I could take better decisions than most politicians on earth while i shit at the toilet. Don't be fooled that they are that much different than you and me. They are not. Actually many of them are even bigger idiots and worst of all illogical and greedy.
I am hoping Agnes Chan goes off and gets a throat infection from sucking UNICEF cock so that she'll be mute and leave them alone.
for anime trollers: what Sylar is saying here is "go watch kemono no souja erin, GGKTHXBYE"
That's kinda the point of a society...they aren't suppose to know or do everything. Their job is just to implement they law. Everyone else is suppose to figure out if it makes sense or not, hence opposition and support.
This may sound sad but they are doing their job...it's their "boss" that's fucking up...
Unfortunately the mentally of those who ask this kind of bans is a non stop try of being annoying and they will bring such law proposals again and again until they get what they want. We have to make them shut up.
Yes. Yes you can shut them up. You actually have to have some BALLS to try and do so.
Thomas Jefferson said it best.
"the Price of freedom is eternal vigilance"
this will be quoted again and again and stands true today but for now
Banzai!
We cant shut them up unfortunately... not yet at least. If we shut them up then we are no different from them. We must remain vigilant and rise up to defend our freedom when threatened and show these moralfags that they have no place in our laws.
blackmail is usually the best solution to this, just don't get caught lol.
It's obviously bankai.
How about bangou?
Bandai? Oh come on...
Bandai --› Sunrise --› Gundam 00 --› Celestial Being --› Ptolemaios II --› Bridge --› Mileina Vashty --› Loli ‹-- This
you mean banzai...
bandai banzai.
bandaid :D
he's from bandai
that has got to be the worst typo i've seen in ages...
What does Bandai have to do with this?
And a resounding one at that! The big outrage among mangaka was probably the deciding factor here, since a lot of the ones who spoke out and do 'regular' anime and porn also do loli stuff from time to time.
it's not a victory... there's nothing to gain
only eternal vigilance on whether it will be banned
Yay! ^_^
YES!!!!