Readers of eroge rag Dengeki G’s Magazine have ranked their favourite characters, but it seems even hardened visual novel fans cannot resist the charms of K-ON!…
Dengeki readers are clearly a class apart from moe-blob loving Megami readers (possibly a lower class, considering the almost uninterrupted list of generic schoolgirls they present us with), although the K-ON! girls are still conspicuously incongruous amongst all these eroge heroines…
Visual Arts isn't really a company per se, but is kind of like a circle made up of three companies. Key, RAM, and one other one I think. Of course, Key largely overshadows both of the other two so you don't hear much of them. Hell, RAM had a several years long hiatus and only recently released another game from them called 5. I guess the Visual Arts shares labour and stuff, since Maeda Jun helped work on the soundtrack for 5 even though he's usually associated with Key. On a side note, 5 isn't too bad. It's the only game that 'almost' turned me into a siscon.
Scratch that about there being just 3 companies. I did some research (the japanese wiki) and turns out a LOT of companies make up Visual Arts. But Key is still pretty much one of it's biggest names.
One thousand times this! I still wonder after all this time how Saber, with her little to no appeal of any kind, beats Arcueid in these areas >_>
List is bullshit in too many reasons to count anyway. I wouldn't be too surprised if there was a K-on eroge/VN type game hanging around somewhere like there is for Lucky Star and Haruhi, but that would give no excuse for this bullshit.
Saber has little to no appeal of any kind? You fail hard, you moron. I like Arcueid, but don't you dis my Saber-chan. Rin-chama beats both of them though.
You guys must be a pretty dumb fucks to compare K-On with Naruto. They are nothing alike, and Naruto is a fuckin' incredible show! Don't you dare insult it! EVER!
Oh well, guess it's like waiting for a $1 million lottery to appear in front of me to expect and hope that Sui (Komorebi), Shiori and Yukiko (11Eyes) to be on that list... :(
I liek Yui and Mio as much as the next guy, but K-ON was a manga, then an anime. I've never seen a K-ON visual novel. Plus, those two took spots from Kyou and Tomoyo. Inconceivable!!
When I first saw the Nagisa picture, the only thing, which came to my mind was: "Since when is she using a vibrator?", but on second look:" Aww, just a msic player."
Sankaku, are you posting these fucked up lists just to piss us off. Or are you trying to make us laugh at the stupidity of the human race, I mean that Lolita Channel shit hardly counts as an eroge.
I think this officially secures K-On's position as "Most Overrated Anime Ever Made". I mean, fuck, people are getting so blinded by these overrated moeblobs that they can't even answer the poll properly without stopping to drool over their "waifu". Sad, so fucking sad.
again, you're talking about overrated show when K-on is all about its characters. Unless you're implying that Mio, Yui, Ritsu, Mugi and ultimately moe Azunyan are overrated characters.
As for the show itself (and the ones you mentionned), you need to realize someday that some people has given up on robot/ninja/fighting/(supposedly) "OMFG AWESOME PLOT" anime, and that they prefer having nice time watching soothing slice-of-life shows with light humor and service (and very light plot sometimes, but rarely)
well, when you'll be in your 20's you'll eventually get it
Lol, you do realize that with the fillers in part 1 of Naruto from 135 and out to 220, you can simply just NOT watch them right? ;D And you must really be on crack when you say there's no development, especially in terms of the characters. Take Naruto himself for instance. Naruto doesn't create a bad image of anime as a whole, it's one of the best series out there. And if you spent any time reading the post on this forum in response to a whole lot of threads, especially ones concerning moe blob, you'd know there are actually quite ALOT of people that care about plot. That the japanese anime industry has started to care less about it though is a different story, though I dare say it is not a good development. I'd rather be a Narutard than an idiot, like you. You fail hard. So kindly go hide under some rock where you don't bother the rest of us, loser. ;-)
Just go watch Naruto, which is still running. You'l get more than enough ninja and fighting, and a really deep, complicated plot(before you protest, make sure you watch far out in the series. the story gets quite epic towards the end of Shippuuden).
Yea, but half of the episodes are still filler. And they butchered the plot from the manga. Plus, not much development, Characters seem way too superficial. It also creates a bad image of anime as a whole, which is probrately Naruto's greatest impact
And besides, nowadays, no one gives a flying fuck about 'Plot'. Ever since the advent of Eva and Tenchi Muyo, all anime's focused on are the characters. Not that that's a bad thing. It's just that plot-centric anime died out along with Yamato and Dragonball and all that good old shit.
>I think this officially secures K-On's position as "Most Overrated Anime Ever Made"[...].
Your point doesn't make any sense. They're not voting for shows, they're voting for CHARACTERS. Even if the show sucks (or so you think), that doesn't make the characters suck (or so they think).
and in before "crappy shows can't have good characters" : Lucky Star. Characters are awesome, but despite being a Lucky Star fanboy myself I can name many shows of this kind waaaaaaaay funnier than it (and K-on is one of them, actually)
Um, yeeee...you see, the thing is, while Rena and Rika are awesome characters, the drawings in the Higurashi no Naku Koro ni visual novel are rather bad, and the creators themselves even said so, which is why they have dubbed it a "Sound Novel" rather than a "Visual Novel". as the focus is more on sound. And as you know, with the lack of eye-candy, female characters will not get the fame and attention they deserve. It's sad, but true. I bet Rena and Rika got alot more popular after the anime and manga adaptions came out.
You're not the most knowledgable about eroge I figure but personal opinions are personal. and polls are usually flavor of the month. we need in-depth research and review.
Actually Komaki Manaka is more popular than you think. She is even getting her own after story AVG called まななつ~委員長と特別な一日~. Best of all it's in 3D. Personally I also like "委員長"
, in fact she was the first path I played on ToHeart2.
You are not alone for loving Kudrayavka. If Kud exists in real life, mark my words, the first thing I do when I see her is to do the Ryuugu Rena thing.
Lol, are you serious? Do you even know how to use the internet? They are shit easy to find pretty much everywhere. For starters, try using the "Channel" on this site. You'l probably find most if not all of them there anyway.
doubt it. anime was worth watching.
the strips were halarious.
however i see the fanbase diversity is actually not so different, just partially, umm wtf am i talking about.. brain fart
need more 2d
Leaving K on out of the question, that was really surprising.
Feena? Kudo?
Are there any Vn chara out of the August/Key/Visual Arts/Circus/leaf bloc?
Didn't August do the games Feena was in?
Visual Arts isn't really a company per se, but is kind of like a circle made up of three companies. Key, RAM, and one other one I think. Of course, Key largely overshadows both of the other two so you don't hear much of them. Hell, RAM had a several years long hiatus and only recently released another game from them called 5. I guess the Visual Arts shares labour and stuff, since Maeda Jun helped work on the soundtrack for 5 even though he's usually associated with Key. On a side note, 5 isn't too bad. It's the only game that 'almost' turned me into a siscon.
Scratch that about there being just 3 companies. I did some research (the japanese wiki) and turns out a LOT of companies make up Visual Arts. But Key is still pretty much one of it's biggest names.
NOUMI I LOVE YOU YOUR ENGLISH IS SUPERB <3
...Why K-On is there?
That's what Iam also about to ask. Probably since there are alot of Hgame girls that have the same hair style as Mio.
Setting aside the fact about the list being dubious.. At least the top isn't....
Kudo is WIN! XD
amen to that
Where is Arcueid? <_<
One thousand times this! I still wonder after all this time how Saber, with her little to no appeal of any kind, beats Arcueid in these areas >_>
List is bullshit in too many reasons to count anyway. I wouldn't be too surprised if there was a K-on eroge/VN type game hanging around somewhere like there is for Lucky Star and Haruhi, but that would give no excuse for this bullshit.
Saber has little to no appeal of any kind? You fail hard, you moron. I like Arcueid, but don't you dis my Saber-chan. Rin-chama beats both of them though.
Paper tissues are expensive unless you buy them from BJs, CostCo, or some other bulk retail outlets.
It should be
1. Rin Tohsaka
2. Rin Tohsaka
3. Rin Tohsaka
4. Rin Tohsaka
5. Rin Tohsaka
6. Rin Tohsaka
7. Rin Tohsaka
8. Rin Tohsaka
9. Rin Tohsaka
10. Rin Tohsaka
You sir... Are Awesome!!!!
Agreed! +9999! Tohsaka Rin FTW! XD
Saber wohoo
id eat them all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
screw K-ON. screw it to the max!
clannad is not an ero ge either.
K-On is becoming the moe version of Naruto. Heck, I'd say it's worse than Naruto.
You're a fucking moron. You realize K-On was THIRTEEN EPISODES, right?
You do realise I'm talking more about the fanbase than the episode count, don't you? Overanimating is one thing, and overrating is another.
Look, you guys can crap K-On for as much as I care, but don't put it in the same level as Taruno. Ever.
You guys must be a pretty dumb fucks to compare K-On with Naruto. They are nothing alike, and Naruto is a fuckin' incredible show! Don't you dare insult it! EVER!
Only one Type-moon character? K-on? List is bullshit!
Now Kudo is one comrade I'd salute to and follow into battle with, even if she is only a quarter Russian.
Still Russian enough, Komrade!
But the correct question is: Is she Soviet enough?
Oh no, not the "In soviet Russia" again...
Saber! My love, you're here!
What the fuck?! Why is Rin not in the list...??!!
I see alot of fellow Rin fans here, lamenting as I do at the lack of Rin, and travesty of this list. Saber is there, but Rin isn't? wtf!?
Yeah!! Saber in Top5 wouhouuuu \o/
Oh well, guess it's like waiting for a $1 million lottery to appear in front of me to expect and hope that Sui (Komorebi), Shiori and Yukiko (11Eyes) to be on that list... :(
And wow WTF, no Tohsaka Rin..?
I liek Yui and Mio as much as the next guy, but K-ON was a manga, then an anime. I've never seen a K-ON visual novel. Plus, those two took spots from Kyou and Tomoyo. Inconceivable!!
Noumi is fine but..Natsume Rin doesn't at least make it to 2nd place!!!?!
超萌啊!!!
I <3 FEENA!!!!!!!! FEENA FAM EARTHLIGHT FTW!!!!!!!!!!!
K-on being on an eroge list nulls the list.
The end..
o AKSU-74 respect )
Saber = slutty whore.
please die. Saber fans unite! Rin is better though...
nahh.. she's not slutty... stupid describe her better... and no, not in a moetic kind of stupid... =p
slutty is dark hole erotica's exclusive.... XD
Rin is not in the list?? This poll is a travesty....
Indeed. Blasphemy is what it is.
Saber! Fuck yeah!
Otome Asakura is from D.C II not D.C., since Nemu is the only female Asakura in D.C. And I think Yume Asakura should replace Otome.
i think that Artefact just wanted to post another Saber pic...
no fault there
=P
When I first saw the Nagisa picture, the only thing, which came to my mind was: "Since when is she using a vibrator?", but on second look:" Aww, just a msic player."
I thought that too, until the (un)dramatic reveal. T_T
The list looks like a good representation to me. Feena is still in it and gotta love Otome Asakura.
WHERE'S RANCE???????
Obviously below number ten
SABEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEER!!!!
No,no,no. It's SAIBAAAAAAAAAAA!!!
Saya deserves a spot ;w;
Depends on which Saya you're talking about. There are actually lots of Sayas.
Sankaku, are you posting these fucked up lists just to piss us off. Or are you trying to make us laugh at the stupidity of the human race, I mean that Lolita Channel shit hardly counts as an eroge.
I'm already laughing at the above comment
I hope K-On's popularity doesn't last as much as Haruhi's did, cause it got annoying already.
Amen.
i've never understood why people like it that much
I have not seen K-On! but every pic of Yui I see reminds me of Minori Kushieda.
they are quite the polar opposites, minorin is energetic, Yui is lazy
I think this officially secures K-On's position as "Most Overrated Anime Ever Made". I mean, fuck, people are getting so blinded by these overrated moeblobs that they can't even answer the poll properly without stopping to drool over their "waifu". Sad, so fucking sad.
Well as messed up as it is....at least Saber is on the list...if shes there im happy.
Amen. Though I miss Rin...
K-ON is one of the many overrated shit this decade. That, and along with Haruhi, Lucky Star, Bakemono, and whatever other moe show that was famous.
again, you're talking about overrated show when K-on is all about its characters. Unless you're implying that Mio, Yui, Ritsu, Mugi and ultimately moe Azunyan are overrated characters.
As for the show itself (and the ones you mentionned), you need to realize someday that some people has given up on robot/ninja/fighting/(supposedly) "OMFG AWESOME PLOT" anime, and that they prefer having nice time watching soothing slice-of-life shows with light humor and service (and very light plot sometimes, but rarely)
well, when you'll be in your 20's you'll eventually get it
I made a typo. It should be "if you spent any time reading the *posts* on this forum".
Lol, you do realize that with the fillers in part 1 of Naruto from 135 and out to 220, you can simply just NOT watch them right? ;D And you must really be on crack when you say there's no development, especially in terms of the characters. Take Naruto himself for instance. Naruto doesn't create a bad image of anime as a whole, it's one of the best series out there. And if you spent any time reading the post on this forum in response to a whole lot of threads, especially ones concerning moe blob, you'd know there are actually quite ALOT of people that care about plot. That the japanese anime industry has started to care less about it though is a different story, though I dare say it is not a good development. I'd rather be a Narutard than an idiot, like you. You fail hard. So kindly go hide under some rock where you don't bother the rest of us, loser. ;-)
Just go watch Naruto, which is still running. You'l get more than enough ninja and fighting, and a really deep, complicated plot(before you protest, make sure you watch far out in the series. the story gets quite epic towards the end of Shippuuden).
Yea, but half of the episodes are still filler. And they butchered the plot from the manga. Plus, not much development, Characters seem way too superficial. It also creates a bad image of anime as a whole, which is probrately Naruto's greatest impact
And besides, nowadays, no one gives a flying fuck about 'Plot'. Ever since the advent of Eva and Tenchi Muyo, all anime's focused on are the characters. Not that that's a bad thing. It's just that plot-centric anime died out along with Yamato and Dragonball and all that good old shit.
In other words, BURN IN HELL, FUCKING NARUTARD
>I think this officially secures K-On's position as "Most Overrated Anime Ever Made"[...].
Your point doesn't make any sense. They're not voting for shows, they're voting for CHARACTERS. Even if the show sucks (or so you think), that doesn't make the characters suck (or so they think).
and in before "crappy shows can't have good characters" : Lucky Star. Characters are awesome, but despite being a Lucky Star fanboy myself I can name many shows of this kind waaaaaaaay funnier than it (and K-on is one of them, actually)
What are K-ON! characters doing on an eroge character list?
Also if this list includes visual novels in general and not just eroge, a lack of either Rena Ryuugu or Rika Furude saddens me.
Um, yeeee...you see, the thing is, while Rena and Rika are awesome characters, the drawings in the Higurashi no Naku Koro ni visual novel are rather bad, and the creators themselves even said so, which is why they have dubbed it a "Sound Novel" rather than a "Visual Novel". as the focus is more on sound. And as you know, with the lack of eye-candy, female characters will not get the fame and attention they deserve. It's sad, but true. I bet Rena and Rika got alot more popular after the anime and manga adaptions came out.
Whiskey Tango Foxtrot!
Where the hell is Higetsu Shino or Higetsu Ayumi from Ringetsu? Not to mention Kousaka Tamaki being 9th?
Holy crap, Kudryavka got 1st? Very suprising to myself...
My list...
1st - Kudryavka
2nd - Konomi (Toheart2)
3rd - Komaki (Toheart2)
You're not the most knowledgable about eroge I figure but personal opinions are personal. and polls are usually flavor of the month. we need in-depth research and review.
Actually Komaki Manaka is more popular than you think. She is even getting her own after story AVG called まななつ~委員長と特別な一日~. Best of all it's in 3D. Personally I also like "委員長"
, in fact she was the first path I played on ToHeart2.
Yea I admit I haven't played much eroges :P
You are not alone for loving Kudrayavka. If Kud exists in real life, mark my words, the first thing I do when I see her is to do the Ryuugu Rena thing.
Kudryavka is the best
わふー!
わふー!
筋肉~!筋肉~!
Chrouya here. I totally agree about Kudo being 1st.
lol wut at k-on. I wish nagisa was higher on the list. It's still good that she's there.
Don't you mean Visual Novel? Clannad is not an eroge.
True...but I think they also include doujins, fanart, etc of the characters...
I would expect to see Asuka and Rei up there if that's the case.
Huh... you'd think a list of the Top 10 Eroge characters would be comprised entirely of Eroge characters...
I mean, it's not like I expected to see any characters from my favorites here (Words Worth, Viper series, Utawarerumono), but even so...
Urushihara's rendition of Saber <3
I KNEW I recognized that style of pic. So he's the one that did it. Oh that makes me happy in my manly area.
its not bad at all, but i'd prefer the tony version. its GOD-LIKE!
Dam right! Well done :3 I wish I could find the CG Scenes from the game itself, haven't found them anywhere :(
Lol, are you serious? Do you even know how to use the internet? They are shit easy to find pretty much everywhere. For starters, try using the "Channel" on this site. You'l probably find most if not all of them there anyway.
kyoani should just make k-on into an eroge
With a female lead protagonist? I can see that.
*Miroku74 drools imagining the yurilicious CG sets...*
Mugi's Saga? Sold. <.<
doubt it. anime was worth watching.
the strips were halarious.
however i see the fanbase diversity is actually not so different, just partially, umm wtf am i talking about.. brain fart
need more 2d
Tamaki is only #9? No wonder the race is dying off.
Second that, love that characters wry humor and flat out sex appeal.
Sadly there hasn't been many doujinshi on about her...
I never really watched much of To Heart 2 but I got on how Tamaki had amazing sex appeal which I did very much :3