Top 10 Fall 2009 Anime, According to 2ch

what a shitty list... it just gets worse and worse...

What the fuck is Kampfer doing in there, it's total crap.

what about ferry tell and Kämpfer is good to

lol how did nyankoi get so high (even though i follow it too)

at least the first four are actually the best 4 of the season

i thought their list will be
1. queens blade
2. queens blade
3. queens blade

no inuyasha
no fairy tail
and kobato scoring lower than sora no otoshimono/natsu no arashi/kampfer

Well, Darker than Black is the best thing airing right now, I'll at least agree with that much. Kampfer shouldn't even be on the list. Blacksmith should be higher.

The line up this season is overall pretty stale.

out of those im watching

sora no otoshimono
to aru kagaku no railgun
Kämpfer

Well, InfiniteNine wasn't alone, nor did he dedicate all that time to this. He's also not poor, damn bastard has it better than I do and I'm the Anon that posted: "Not really, I'm perfectly content with my life. I'm 21 and have my own apartment... ^_^ Not even close ol' chap."

And in case you were wondering, those four + comments were not a mistake. The lot of us are pretty high right now, so this is... :)

As for the anime list I personally find DTB2 and Kimi no Todoke to be the best while Sora no Otoshimono to be amusing. I probably won't see Railgun because I was so disappointed with Index's story (or lack of thereof), even if Railgun is good. But overall I think the list is pretty accurate.

Long live the Priest!

Anime has been pretty awful lately. There hasn't been a quality series that wasn't one massive fan service video in a long time. I miss the Last Exiles and Cowboy Bebops. Everything is moe, panties, breasts, and socially retarded guys amassing harems amidst constant misunderstandings.

FUCK YEAH SUNRED!!!! THAT SHOULD BE IN THE TOP 5 NOT 10!!

I'm totally lovin Kimi Ni Todoke!

I like Railgun, but it seems like it's entirely compsed of fillers. There's no actual plot present as of yet, just day to day instances.

Rather than regular votes (where you can only choose one of your favorite), they should make a list of all the animes airing and let the voters at least choose their top 5 (in order of course) and grade it from there (weighted average). Of course I don't know how 2ch voting method, but if it like other internet votes, then you can only choose one. The problem with only choosing one is lets say that there is no DtB, then those who would choose DtB don't automatically choose Railgun as their favorite. This would help massively those anime that are good but bumped down because there is a better anime in the same genre.
For example.. Let's assume that for most people Bantorra is a good anime but since DtB is the better action anime for most people then Bantorra is screwed.

As for the result itself I think it's fair enough considering that (cmiiw) this is just a simple vote.

10. Tentai Senshi Sun Red

Yay! Senshis Parody Go GO!..

Vaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamppppppppppppppp Saaaamaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.. I want karage in my bentooooooo

Considering that Sora no Otoshimono is not "Oh grimdark with plot twists every episode" or a festival of moeblobbery like K-on, it's doing extremely well to rank #5 on that list (and also considering the majority of the votes were concentrated on the top 5).

Sora no Otoshimono is damn awesome, at the very least for having perhaps the best production values this season so far. (can anyone name another series that has a brand-new ED every single episode?)

well can't say anything since there is no better anime this fall

What, how come Astro Fighter Sunred is #10?!

Railgun, Kobato, Kimi no Todoke, Kämpfer and Sasameki Koto. These are my menu for the fall season.

Darker than Black, well deserved first-place.

Looking forwardt KOBATO the manga is my favorite work from CLAMP

The lack of Trapeze love upsets me.

what about seitokai no ichizon?! i can understand the fanservice shows ranking high, but kimi ni todoke?! sure, the graphics are nice and shiny, but it's simply brainless! >_<"

Where the hell is spice and wolf? :(

You mean "Fairy Tail", right?
Well, it is pretty generic, though it's fun to watch nonetheless (so far, at least).

Bah, who cares about that, though,
Darker than BLACK for the f-ing win!

My personal opinion of fall anime 2009 xD

Book Of Bantorra and DTB 2 are damn great.

11eyes and Sacred Blacksmith, and Railgun are good.

Kämpfer, Nyankoi, and Aoi Bungaku are mediocre.

Needless, Trapeze and Sunred is crap.

Queens Blade, Asura Cryin, and Fairy Tail are all utter garbage and not worth watching.

Havent yet seen Kimi No Todoke or Kobato so aint gonna comment them.

I don't see Seitokai no Ichizon

I am disappoint

I found Nyan Koi to be surprisingly endearing for its type.

Nyan koi is a good example of a lame story told in an interesting way.

And by the comments here, I assume Fairy Tale is the opposite, an interesiting story told in a lame way.

According to 2ch.

FUCK YEAH SUNRED

Japan voted right this time~

Darker than Black > All

For all the hate on the fall '09 animes, I personally have more shows I'm enjoying this season than anytime in recent memory; have about 8 or 9 I'm following compared to my normal 3 to 5 per season.

Glad i'm not the only one that found Fairy Fail an utter disappointment. I haven't seen animation quality that bad in a very long time.

I'm enjoying Sora no Otoshimono and the 2nd season of White Album the most so far along with my guility pleasure, Nogizaka Haruka no Himitsu ~Purezza~

Railgun in second. It shouldn't even be in the top 10.

WTF on Asura Cryin being 8 pts!?! Blasphemy!

Top 10 Fail 2009 Anime?!?

seitokai no ichizon is number one

Sums it up really. You have your odd quality show in the list and then the rest is dominated by the fanservice trash they regularly eat up.
I know it's a rather poor fall season, but come on...

No love for 11XEyes? 2CH fails this time around.

otaku certainly has poor taste

Sora love YEAH!!!!

I'm so happy to see that seitokai didn't make the list.

There is still hope...

Kampfer is pretty good unless ur not into traps haha

Why are people complaining about the loli action?

I thought Sancom liked lolis.

Seiken no Blacksmith shouldn't even be near the top 10. Oh wait, they have K-ON! styled moe girls in a fantasy setting, one of which is a terrible character type. Not even Luke can save this show. Railgun is okay, but really, not deserving of 2nd place. This also applies to Kampfer. Ah fuck it, moe girls sell, its not like people grade anime for actual substance these days anyway.

No CLANNAD ~after story~ ?!?!?!?!!! :O

This really is a horrible season for anime. The Winter list looks much more promising however.

I usually disagree with Japan but I agree. DtB is awesome and Fairy Tail is shit.

I like DTB (although DTB2 so far is way too "Darker than BLACK plus loli fanservice), but isn't it a bit early to determine rankings already?

WELL! sounds about right.. in my opinion...

Yay, railgun's doing well.

I'm made of metal,
My circuits gleam,
I am perpetual,
I keep the country clean!

Lol supreme qualty anime xD
These are most likely to be not watched by me xD

But what about kuchuu buranko

I think sora no Otoshimono should be a little lower...I have been enjoying Natsu no Arashi and Kobato more....I even enjoyed Kampfer more.

I do agree with the top 4 though.

I'm shocked!

How could trapeze not be in there... ... how?! that anime is so made of win...

And why is kimi ni todoke in 4th? it should at least be 3rd...

for the 2nd and 3rd place i can deduced that harem liking otakus rules 2ch...

then again darker then black is really quite good, and railgun is not really a harem... .. .

Damn, I haven't actually gotten around to watching any of the fall anime yet but there's a lot I wanna see, most of which are in the top ten. But I do know that I really want to see Darker Than Black!

2ch, I love you.

Am I the only one watching Armed Librarians - Book of Bantorra? Way better than half of that list.

I guess this is slightly less terrible than previous season's ranking. I can agree for most part but Nyan Koi, Railgun and SnO don't deserve to be so high up and Trapeze, Aoi Bungaku and Sunred should be higher.

What's number 10 about?

I guess 2ch hates setokai? I thought it was popular... Not saying its awesome or anything though.

Sweet Loli Jesus!!!
You mean to say that Seitokai no Ichizon didn't crack the top 10?
Really, what the hell?
That show is great fun...

So... where's my 11Eyes?
- Coolham23 -

That's messed up, asura cryin and umineko aren't on the list...

heh, thought I was the only liking Kimi ni Todoke.. surprisingly good, although I have yet to figure out why..

Darker than Black season 2 is pretty much the only thing worth watching this season anyway.