Top 10 Fall 2009 Anime, According to 2ch
- Categories: Anime, News
- Date: Nov 1, 2009 00:03 JST
- Tags: 2ch, Darker Than Black, Mikoto, Rankings, Statistics
2ch has given its verdict on the current state of the Fall 2009 anime season, and the ranking seems to indicate a resounding victory for Darker Than Black.
It should be noted that most of the votes for the ranking were concentrated in the top 5, with the other 25 or so anime generally securing equally little interest…
1. Darker than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini
2. To Aru Kagaku no Railgun
3. Nyankoi
4. Kimi ni Todoke
5. Sora no Otoshimono
6. Natsu no Arashi
7. Kämpfer
8. Kobato
9. Seiken no Blacksmith
10. Tentai Senshi Sun Red
And the least popular? Asura Cryin’ and Fairytale, both with a pathetic 8 votes each…
Gundam 00 Movie Release Date – “September!”
Snow Miku Nendoroid Irresistibly Appealing
Haruhi Movie Reaches #7 in Japanese Box Office
Sea Shepherd to Attack Tuna Fishing Boats
Mugi-Mania Grips Otaku
Busty Yoko Cosplay
Pedobear “Vancouver 2010 Olympic Mascot”
Anime Industry Laments Bust: “We Could Sell Anything!”
Marisa Kirisame Figma
Nippon Ichi Stock Plunges as Profits Wiped Out
Wonder Festival Winter 2010 Mega-Digest
Tony Works Ciel Chronicle Erotic Indeed
LDP Fields “Hair Nude” Candidate Miyako Aso
Noizi Ito’s Lightning
Final Fantasy XIII Sells for $20, Sales Now a Damp Squib
Kinema Kan’s Touhou Anime Music Video PV
Bizarre Japanese Vending Machine Gallery
Sexy Pizza Munching C.C. Cosplay
Ohigetan
Matataku
Mischievous Suzume Gallery
Asuka Langley Cosplay by Kanda Midori
Otaku Bukkake Gallery
Nagato Yuki Disappearance Winter Version Cosplay
Mikupan
Sakuya Tsuitachi
well the fall season is pretty bad on anime at the moment.
Little busters ftw!
Cheers,
Niker
I wish there will be a Little Busters anime.
pffff, no "Aoi Bungaku" this list is GAAAAAAAY.
aoi bungaku is quite a niche anime, from my point of view... ... those who wanna just watch and enjoy(girls and such), won't like it...
This list is garbage.
No Book of Bantorra, Tegami Bachi, or 11Eyes, plus Blacksmith and Sora no Otoshimono should be switched.
Oh lol, first time I read "top 10 fail 2009 anime"... After I saw the list, I affirmed this, duh.
Weird...
pretty good list, just need to add Fairy Tail
No KissXsis?
Kiss x Sis is largely long term. I doubt it should be on the list.
That said, they should include 11eyes, its pretty much an alternative Night Wizard.
11 eyes is terrible you fools
Waaaaay better than Kampfer
I do as well.
also, RAILGUNNNNN
We can only hope...
nyankoy is too high on the list, kämpfer and kobato shouldnt be on the list, replace nyankoy with letter bee among others
After spelling it properly, I think Nyankoi is at a reasonable place. I'm surprised that Kobato's so low though. I would have expected it further up.....then again, with lack of any fanservice (other than "so kawaiiiiiiiii"), I suppose it's to be expected.
I'm dumbfounded by Kämpfer scoring higher than Kobato, in fact. I'd have switched their places in my ranking. And I'd have bumped Seiken no Blacksmith off of the list in favor of 11eyes.
Hm.
Kampfer has more fanservice than Kobato, that's why
again blacksmith>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>11 eyes
whats wrong with Kampfer? I like it
A Certain Scientific Railgun is good~
Asura Cryin’ shouldn't even have gotten a second season.
I've seen a LOT of anime worse than that.
oh wth why is fairytail last? ;-;
fairytail sucks. thats why.
just kidding.
well, maybe it's not moe enough for 2ch-ers??
more like Hirano-san is messing up the casting. Every time I watch Lucy getting serious, I think of an angry Haruhi...
Thanks alot for the stereotyping us all, Kadokawa!
yah.. i wasnt a big fan of the voices in fairy tail either. That, and the parts where they use magic seem overly frilly in the anime, whereas use of magic in the manga flows naturally into the story. I guess I expected something more along the lines of One Piece. I mean, when Luffy stretches, there isn't a flashy and pointless 1-2 minute sequence beforehand.
because of these stupid "sailor Moon"-attacks, or because of the shitty animations, or rie and aya in the maincast..
i cant stand happy anymore, that is not a female tsundere-cat..
It's "Fairy Tail," and yes, the anime sucks.
The manga's not terrible though.
It doesn't suck. It's just abit more childish than the manga.
Really? I haven't had a chance to check out the anime yet but I really love the manga. This is disappointing.
The anime's quality was toned down a whole notch.
And the voice casting turned into some kind of fan-service thing... -_-;;;
No actual promotion of the series itself.
I love the manga, and am thoroughly disappointed with the anticipated anime...
Agreed, they could have made the Fairy Tail anime so much better than they did. I was expecting something more along the lines of One Piece, which it could have been. I mean, I can't help but draw comparisons between Fairy Tail and One Piece. Their setting are different, for sure, and their characters' personalities are their own (although Natsu and Luffy are very similar in that regard), but they both have a very similar sense of fun and epic-ness that the Fairy Tail anime just failed to catch.
If the Fairy Tail anime lasts long enough, maybe it'll hit its stride and become worth watching, but for now it's too annoying for me.
is that even possible?
Nah, it's sucks really. Never bother reading the manga though. Never realy like the art style.
Either way, their making a huge casting mistake, putting alot of big names (Kugumiya and Hirano) into the cast.
They should concentrate on more suitable voices than famous celebrities...
yeah, they should use the same cast of one piece, the characters are pretty much the same after all.
I like the manga but the anime is just fail.
Voices are simply shitty.
More like "Fairy Fail" to me.
Nothing really reliable about 2ch I guess
the top 5 is pretty much spot on
Darker than Black season 2 is pretty much the only thing worth watching this season anyway.
That, Nogizaka Haruka no Himitsu Purezza, and To Aru Kagaku no Railgun are the ones I'm watching this season. All the other anime I am whiles those aren't on are on DVD since the other shows just don't seem that great.
You should wait for that cock tease Nogizaka Haruka to go to DVD. Too much fucking steam on the broadcast.
they aire the uncut version btw...
Even then, DtB2 isn't as good as the first, too much focus on the stupid kid and not on Hei being badass, and wtf at only 12 episodes
I guess 2ch hates setokai? I thought it was popular... Not saying its awesome or anything though.
I started watching it one time, but it slip out of my radar pretty quickly. They wanted to be the next Lucky Star, but failed.
Seitokai is actually number 11. It would've made the list if Sun Red wasn't there
Sweet Loli Jesus!!!
You mean to say that Seitokai no Ichizon didn't crack the top 10?
Really, what the hell?
That show is great fun...
So true...
So... where's my 11Eyes?
- Coolham23 -
What, the 11Eyes anime is already out!? Damn!!
Sorry for forgetting you, Shiori :<
God, that show blows. It could have been good, but no, instead it sucks.
It's because everyone on 2ch saw ep 3.. thats why its not on their
Woot, what happened in ep3? (No spoiler please) The Episode 3 QUALITY Curse again?
heh, thought I was the only liking Kimi ni Todoke.. surprisingly good, although I have yet to figure out why..
Why? You have shitty tastes, that's why.
Sure, downvote me all you want, but kimi ni todoke isn't much more profound than twilight or any other shitty romance novel. It doesn't come anywhere close to karekano.
Seriously. Nothing will ever topple KareKano when it comes to shoujo, but this is really really really close. I swear it's got everything good shoujo needs.
Perhaps it's due to being a school drama that does not rely on moe, or fanservice, yet it's captivating in it's storytelling?
just my opinion though...
That's messed up, asura cryin and umineko aren't on the list...
Umineko is not a Fall anime
I pretty much agree with everything, except #10 since I've never watched it.
I can't really say much about Darker than Black, because I still haven't finished watching the first season :(.
You should seriously fix that. DtB is gooooood.
The only one I like on there in Nyan Koi.
Railgun should be number 1. Konoko Yuri FTW!
Konoko is the main character in the video game Oni.
I think you're misspelling something there.
Ahem.
I watch the top 3 so I can half agree with that. But then again I'm also watching Fairy Tail and AC2 (though I can see that one being low).
Blacksmith should be much higher either way.
No.1 and 2 are agreeable. Although i haven't even finish season 1 of DTB and Index.
You've missed out on so much biting action.
Is that supposed to be a pun? 0w0
where's queen blade? the great body art anime that was "river crab" by the china gov?
Fairytale is pretty much fail. The manga is good, but the anime suck ass.
What about "Umineko no Naku Koro ni"?
:/
U FAIL. umineko isnt a fall anime.
Well, maybe U R RIGHT...
BUT(T) it's not your concern if I fail. So stop being sooooo "smart", FURNITURE.
Best regards
Ronove
>:-]
Not much love for Kampfer?
Well.... I don't mind gender-bending animes or manga. Ranma 1/2 should be proof enough that such a genre can be damn entertaining.
Nice to see one of my current must-watch shows up there though (Railgun). others might not agree with me, but the tension between Mikoto, Touma (when he appears at all) and Kuroko keeps me coming
bucketsback. ^_-Strangely enough, Railgun no Touma haven't said "Fukou da" even once.
Never really noticed it until you mentioned it then just replayed Railgun back over in my head and you're right. Interesting.
Aside from Kimi ni Todoke, this season is an absolute joke. I am pleasantly surprised it actually placed among the more popular shows. DTB2 at #1 - hilarious....
It's a sequel. What do you expect?
But what about kuchuu buranko
looks like 2ch is a bunch of serious guys who dont bother to watch such great psychodelic title just because it's *different*, huh
I think sora no Otoshimono should be a little lower...I have been enjoying Natsu no Arashi and Kobato more....I even enjoyed Kampfer more.
I do agree with the top 4 though.
Lol supreme qualty anime xD
These are most likely to be not watched by me xD
I'm made of metal,
My circuits gleam,
I am perpetual,
I keep the country clean!
I'm elected, electric spy
I'm protected, electric eye
Always in focus, Can't feel my stare
I zoom in to you, but you don't know I'm there~
I take a pride in probing all your secret moves
My tearless retina takes pictures that can prove
WELL! sounds about right.. in my opinion...
I like DTB (although DTB2 so far is way too "Darker than BLACK plus loli fanservice), but isn't it a bit early to determine rankings already?
Yay, railgun's doing well.
I'm shocked!
How could trapeze not be in there... ... how?! that anime is so made of win...
And why is kimi ni todoke in 4th? it should at least be 3rd...
for the 2nd and 3rd place i can deduced that harem liking otakus rules 2ch...
then again darker then black is really quite good, and railgun is not really a harem... .. .
What's number 10 about?
Tentai Senshi Sun Red - The story revolves around the hero Sunred's battles against General Vamp and his shadowy group of minions in a spoof of classic Japanese anime and live-action special-effects shows.
I heard its suppose to be hilarious.
I guess this is slightly less terrible than previous season's ranking. I can agree for most part but Nyan Koi, Railgun and SnO don't deserve to be so high up and Trapeze, Aoi Bungaku and Sunred should be higher.
Kimi no Todoke should be up higher, such tear jerking series (at least ones that's good enough to stir your emotion) isn't common these days. Plus Noto Mamiko is doing a supreme job as usual.
Darker than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini and 5. Sora no Otoshimono, don't deserve that spot.
Damn, I haven't actually gotten around to watching any of the fall anime yet but there's a lot I wanna see, most of which are in the top ten. But I do know that I really want to see Darker Than Black!
2ch, I love you.
Am I the only one watching Armed Librarians - Book of Bantorra? Way better than half of that list.
What the hell Kämpfer is #7?! I call bullshit on this ranking, kämpfer is mildly amusing but on the same level as queen's blade s2 in my opinion if not below it.
Queens Blade is pure garbage, no way you can compare Kampfer with it.
If by garbage you mean Queen's Blade actually delivers while Kampfer is for faggots that like dickgirls.
So where are the dick girls? When he changes, he changes completely = no dicks.
That is until comiket...
What? The 'male-lead' gonna get 'raped'??
Only nerds watch anime
ooooh the little troll that could
Ohohohoho...
Amusing, isn't it? ^^
おやすみなさい精液獣ステンドグラス
Whatever 2ch says is the word of God.
OBEY
Fixed ;)
HaruWHO
my opinion from what I've seen
1. Darker than Black: Ryuusei no Gemini -pretty good-
2. To Aru Kagaku no Railgun -OK-
3. Nyankoi -sub par-
4. Kimi ni Todoke -Pretty good-
5. Sora no Otoshimono -fanservice shit-
7. Kämpfer -more fanservice shit-
8. Kobato -average-
9. Seiken no Blacksmith -zzzzzzzzzzzzz-
haven't seen this season's sunred or natsu no arashi
It's nice to see Teantai Senshi Sunred and Kobato up there
ITT: people who are butthurt when others don't share their tastes in anime.
I'm not marking anyone down because they think Railgun sucks, or they think some other show I hate rocks. Show some fucking maturity for once.
Maybe I'm the one asking for too much here. But sheesh.... a little maturity isn't that much, is it?
But where's the fun in that? I love telling people that their perfectly reasonable opinion is completely wrong and that it makes them look retarded.
You're entitled to your opinions, nocturne. :)
And you're certainly entitled to voice your opinion about other peoples' choices. Just be prepared to back up your rationale for it with something more concrete than 'ur opinion is wrong'.
I concur.
The list shouldn't effect any of the watchers regarding whether they want to watch it or not. And saying "this should go here and there in this list" is just showing how you'd like your opinion to be superior than others, in which it's a very bad attitude, not very sporting at all.
... And I've seen complaints like this surface and resurface then and again from the day I started lurking in Sankaku Complex. But, hey, it's not like we can make people stop, can we? We wish.
source for poll?
Who votes for the list? I think it's not even close to reality dudes...
Darker than Black? it is good but are u sure it worthy to be on top?
the list is so mess up!
SERIOUSLY!!! ~{[(T_T)]}~
2ch voted for it. Either way it's an opinion based poll and nothing more.
Side note: Anyone know who's attacking all of this threads comments or for what reason?
probably a group of butthurt fanboys that can't stand seeing their aaaawwwwsome favorite anime stomped on the ground, or some 13 year old brats (at least in their minds, even if their almost 30, and their crib is papa's basement) having an episode of mind masturbation cuz they think that fading comments in to nothingness makes them less miserable somehow. ^_^ bullseye?
Not really, I'm perfectly content with my life. I'm 21 and have my own apartment. I'm currently in my last year of getting my chemical engineering bachelors and get my living expenses & tuition payed through scholarship/grants. Overall, I agree with the majority of the list. ^_^ Not even close ol' chap.
I wouldn't put it past anyone at this point, Anon.
Maybe some of our fellow posters have a power trip they must fulfill? Either that or just for the lulz.
I'm willing to lay down good money on option #2
then my fellow anon, you are a butthurt fanboy with a good life :)
I agree 1-3, never watched kimi ni todoke, I think Blacksmith is pretty entertaining..
For me,
Kobato
Kämpfer
Seiken no Blacksmith
Kimi ni Todoke
(no perticular order)
,are the only ones holding my attention. Kobato and Kampfer have a participation with the dialog which is shouting out what the character is going to say before it does and responding. SO they are fun to watch. The darker than black storyline in ep.1 sucked arse to me not even bothering to watch it. Also not even bothering to mess with even trying to look at the rest though some have had funny stories here.
Where is Railgun?!!
in your butt
Ooooo.... kinky!
Sucking DTB's cock.
Wow lol, everyone's comments are downvoted and blurred out. Either it's Butthurt votefag trolls or everyone's is straightly standing on their own opinion right now.
Yeah, no kidding, just like the last article...
Well, must be from some despaired kid who had just his goldfish pet ran down by a steamroller driven by his grandma, attempting to make a lame lulz in this site before he finally commit suicide by cutting his throat with a nailcutter.
I guess there is no more sense to comment anymore at all ^^
We need a secret weapon then!
A weapon of mass downvote, so we can nuke those downvoting bastard anons...
Before this comment gets destroyed by trolls.I'd like to say a great big "fuck you" to whoever that's been marking down all the comments by people who have been giving legit opinion based comments(and the not so).
Thanks for reading.Have a nice day.
Agreed.
I'm guessing the ones doing the votedowns for the lulz don't have opinions worth posting here anyway.
Happy Halloween, trollfags. ^^
That maybe true. Sc**w the trolls who do the votedowns for fun.
:[
Nyankoi should be first place and Kämpfer shouldn't even be in that list.
Delicious Sohara and Ikaros, Soraoto is awesome
Full list:
1 346 (50.5%) DTB2
2 243 (35.4%) Railgun
3 236 (34.4%) Nyan Koi!
4 219 (31.9%) Kimi ni Todoke
5 144 (21.0%) Sora no Otoshimono
6 86 (12.5%) Natsu no Arashi
7 80 (11.6%) Kaempfer
8 72 (10.5%) Kobato
9 71 (10.3%) Katanah
10 59 (8.6%) Sun Red
11 56 (8.1%) Seitokai no Ichizon
12 47 (6.8%) The Book of Bantorra
13 45 (6.5%) Letter Bee
14 44 (6.4%) Shin Koi Hime
15 38 (5.5%) Kiruminzuu
16 37 (5.4%) Aoi Bungaku Series
17 29 (4.2%) Sasameki Koto
18 25 (3.6%) Queen's Blade
19 24 (3.5%) Umineko
20 23 (3.3%) Kiddy Girl-and
21 19 (2.7%) 11eyes
22 17 (2.4%) Miracle Train
23 15 (2.1%) NEEDLESS
23 15 (2.1%) WHITE ALBUM
25 14 (2.0%) Haruka Nogizaka's Secret
26 13 (1.8%) Trapezes
26 13 (1.8%) Eagle Talon
28 11 (1.6%) Yumeiro Patissiere
29 8 (1.1%) Asura Cryin
29 8 (1.1%) FAIRY TAIL
Holy shi~ 11Eyes on my favourite number! :3
Okay, not going to complain on that.
Tell that to the trollfag(s) collapsing the comments in here faster than the WTC on 9/11, MaidNiac. :|
You can't just post lists which aren't in Top 10 format! This is the Internet!
Damn.... Umineko on #19??? DAMN THEM..... Just when EP3 was spectacular. :(
Still Bantorra's way too low, while utter crap like Kampfer are ridiculously high.
Sunred should be 1st!
In this comments:
My opinion > Your opinion
Why is all of the comment text grey and fugly????
Go to bed now, votefag. Your mum won't serve your favourite Trix tomorrow if you wake up late.
Since Artefact didn't make the vote system so Anonymous users can vote, it's registered trollfags doing this.
Now I get it..
Thanks for the list Anonymous (whoever you are)
Its just poll after all..
As long as we fans support our favorite anime when a DVD version comes out, they will be the top of our own list LOL
P/s: by the way, who like Needless, give a shout! LOL
Just proves how retarded otaku are, and how terrible is the current state of anime.
Then again, this season is one of the worst so far, so I shouldn't be expecting much.
I don't agree with you, but I'm not gonna hold it against you.
The Fall season's not over yet, and Winter's just around the corner. Don't be too quick to count 2009 a complete-shit anime year yet!
No surprise...
DTB is the BEST!
I believe the first 4 anime deserve there position. And i would agree that Darker than Black is number one.
Hmm...finding that i agree with 2ch kind of makes me worry.
In case anyone was wondering about the vote-griefer, it is InfiniteNine.
This poor Texan child is manually voting down every comment (we know this because he is occasionally clicking the "+" by accident and messing it up) on this post 4 times using a couple of accounts, and he has apparently devoted hours to doing so, despite the fact that comment votes can be cleared with the click of a button...
Lol. Good show.
Well you are half right.
Found 301 votes for user with id = 2598.
Found 276 votes for user with id = 4276.
Found 274 votes for user with id = 4280.
Found 271 votes for user with id = 4281.
Total of 1122 votes removed.
Time on your hands?
Seeing as I only have two accounts on here. Not as much as you think.
Dude, I voted 276 times. God, I'm awesome.
No, you're not.
What's his problem anyway?
Ohohohoho...... XD
I hope he's ready for the internet beatdown that (others) will be giving him for his efforts.
lol got nothing better to do?
I mean truly a real waste of time voting down everyone like that,for what maybe just his evil needs?
Try to do something in your free time like chores,or just watch anime or play a game.
I was actually taking a break from being frustrated at Demon's Souls. Good stuff.
Looks like they're doing it in the other news threads too. The Train Chikan one from just earlier for one.
What sad little people...
Shits and giggles, my man.... sadly enough that's all it is.
How was the voting done? If it was simply a "vote for your favorite" there's a good chance that some of the good stuff that wouldn't crack a person's favorite but would still be a solid number 2 or 3 selection gravitates to the bottom of the list.
That being said, I would have to agree with some of the positions on the list, 11eyes I was looking forward to but it seems to have taken a bit of a dive after the first couple of episodes. Kampfer seems to have struggled with the same problem.
Biribiri seems to be gravitating towards a more moeblob drawing style, and is starting to suffer from a lack of screentime for the title character (It's pretty much safe to label this phenomenon Index Syndrome now I think)
Kobato is enjoyable but is definitely aimed at a younger audience than the average 2ch-goer. Hence the place on the ranking is pretty understandable.
Nyan Koi I think deserves its spot in the top 3, it delivers consistent quality even after the first couple of episodes with a good amount of humor without having to be too ecchi.
Kimi ni Todoke is another pleasant surprise and is definitely something to watch if you're into the shoujo romance drama genre at all.
Kiddy Girl-and is something I'll be watching, mostly from the expectations setup by its predecessor which IMO also got off to a pretty slow start. If it ends up being anything like the second half of Kiddy Grade I'll be happy.
I'm pretty sure I already posted something like the first paragraph you wrote, but I can't find my post anywhere...
Probably it's like other internet votes (cmiiw) where you can only vote for one title. Basically to make the ranking better, they should let people post at least their top 3 (in order of course and top 5 or top 10 would be even better) and do weighted average on the votes.
I usually disagree with Japan but I agree. DtB is awesome and Fairy Tail is shit.
Anime has been pretty awful lately. There hasn't been a quality series that wasn't one massive fan service video in a long time. I miss the Last Exiles and Cowboy Bebops. Everything is moe, panties, breasts, and socially retarded guys amassing harems amidst constant misunderstandings.
Well, true. Cowboy Bebop had some fanservice (Ed and Faye anyone?), but it didn't detract much from the overall flow of the story.
Emmm....Have you noticed number 1?
"EVERYTHING is moe, panties, breasts, and socially retarded guys amassing harems amidst constant misunderstandings."
Trust me, when people say "all" or "everything", pretty sure they didn't really see them whole.
Mahoromatic. Sumomomo Momomo. Love Hina. Full Metal Panic! (1st season, The Second Raid, and Sigma).
All had copious amounts of fanservice. All hit certain demographics in their genres. BTW, I also particularly enjoyed *all* these series, TYVVM. ^^
Does that everyone shares my passion for pantsu fashion, or eye for oppai? No. Do I denigrate, exaggerate, or over-inflate my opinions of *their* anime (dis)likes? Fuck no!
I'll vote them up or down, and voice my own comments.
I love anime! I love manga! I love eroge!
*fapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfapfap...*
Well, InfiniteNine wasn't alone, nor did he dedicate all that time to this. He's also not poor, damn bastard has it better than I do and I'm the Anon that posted: "Not really, I'm perfectly content with my life. I'm 21 and have my own apartment... ^_^ Not even close ol' chap."
And in case you were wondering, those four + comments were not a mistake. The lot of us are pretty high right now, so this is... :)
As for the anime list I personally find DTB2 and Kimi no Todoke to be the best while Sora no Otoshimono to be amusing. I probably won't see Railgun because I was so disappointed with Index's story (or lack of thereof), even if Railgun is good. But overall I think the list is pretty accurate.
Long live the Priest!
... why we can't have nice things.
I agree with the Priest comment though.
out of those im watching
sora no otoshimono
to aru kagaku no railgun
Kämpfer
I'm keeping a close eye on Railgun and Kampfer myself. So far, aside from the copious fanservice, nothing to the story yet. But it is still at the start for those two.
Maybe they'll surprise us yet? I'll not hold my breath on it. But I can dram, can't I? ^_-
FUCK YEAH SUNRED!!!! THAT SHOULD BE IN THE TOP 5 NOT 10!!
Rather than regular votes (where you can only choose one of your favorite), they should make a list of all the animes airing and let the voters at least choose their top 5 (in order of course) and grade it from there (weighted average). Of course I don't know how 2ch voting method, but if it like other internet votes, then you can only choose one. The problem with only choosing one is lets say that there is no DtB, then those who would choose DtB don't automatically choose Railgun as their favorite. This would help massively those anime that are good but bumped down because there is a better anime in the same genre.
For example.. Let's assume that for most people Bantorra is a good anime but since DtB is the better action anime for most people then Bantorra is screwed.
As for the result itself I think it's fair enough considering that (cmiiw) this is just a simple vote.
I'm totally lovin Kimi Ni Todoke!
I like Railgun, but it seems like it's entirely compsed of fillers. There's no actual plot present as of yet, just day to day instances.
It's started to have a plot... The part about the 'invisible' girl wasn't just there for the lulz. It showed the system 'may' have some errors grading people. And also that one of them is a lvl= is intriguing, she should have a power,even if it's useless (Tohma & co. are all lvl 0 with nullification and regen for example)
It maybe a bit off the topic, but You have a cute avatar, Yangth.
Actually many people in this forum do.
:)
im fine with the way they're pacing
not like the first season, where they throw everything on us, this is finer
10. Tentai Senshi Sun Red
Yay! Senshis Parody Go GO!..
Vaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamppppppppppppppp Saaaamaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.. I want karage in my bentooooooo
what about ferry tell and Kämpfer is good to
lol how did nyankoi get so high (even though i follow it too)
What the fuck is Kampfer doing in there, it's total crap.
what a shitty list... it just gets worse and worse...
at least the first four are actually the best 4 of the season
Well, Darker than Black is the best thing airing right now, I'll at least agree with that much. Kampfer shouldn't even be on the list. Blacksmith should be higher.
The line up this season is overall pretty stale.
i thought their list will be
1. queens blade
2. queens blade
3. queens blade
no inuyasha
no fairy tail
and kobato scoring lower than sora no otoshimono/natsu no arashi/kampfer
Because Inuyasha is fail? And random shounen anime is junk?
No love for 11XEyes? 2CH fails this time around.
Sums it up really. You have your odd quality show in the list and then the rest is dominated by the fanservice trash they regularly eat up.
I know it's a rather poor fall season, but come on...
otaku certainly has poor taste
Railgun in second. It shouldn't even be in the top 10.
WTF on Asura Cryin being 8 pts!?! Blasphemy!
Top 10 Fail 2009 Anime?!?
seitokai no ichizon is number one
Sora love YEAH!!!!
No CLANNAD ~after story~ ?!?!?!?!!! :O
Go away.
This really is a horrible season for anime. The Winter list looks much more promising however.
Seiken no Blacksmith shouldn't even be near the top 10. Oh wait, they have K-ON! styled moe girls in a fantasy setting, one of which is a terrible character type. Not even Luke can save this show. Railgun is okay, but really, not deserving of 2nd place. This also applies to Kampfer. Ah fuck it, moe girls sell, its not like people grade anime for actual substance these days anyway.
Errr... As a K-ON! fan, I don't see the resemblance you are talking about. Epic fail there buddy.
Look at Lisa.
Why are people complaining about the loli action?
I thought Sancom liked lolis.
I'm so happy to see that seitokai didn't make the list.
There is still hope...
Kampfer is pretty good unless ur not into traps haha
I'm enjoying Sora no Otoshimono and the 2nd season of White Album the most so far along with my guility pleasure, Nogizaka Haruka no Himitsu ~Purezza~
what about seitokai no ichizon?! i can understand the fanservice shows ranking high, but kimi ni todoke?! sure, the graphics are nice and shiny, but it's simply brainless! >_<"
The lack of Trapeze love upsets me.
Where the hell is spice and wolf? :(
In the summer anime section?
You mean "Fairy Tail", right?
Well, it is pretty generic, though it's fun to watch nonetheless (so far, at least).
Bah, who cares about that, though,
Darker than BLACK for the f-ing win!
more like fairy fail lol
Looking forwardt KOBATO the manga is my favorite work from CLAMP
Darker than Black, well deserved first-place.
well can't say anything since there is no better anime this fall
Considering that Sora no Otoshimono is not "Oh grimdark with plot twists every episode" or a festival of moeblobbery like K-on, it's doing extremely well to rank #5 on that list (and also considering the majority of the votes were concentrated on the top 5).
Sora no Otoshimono is damn awesome, at the very least for having perhaps the best production values this season so far. (can anyone name another series that has a brand-new ED every single episode?)
What, how come Astro Fighter Sunred is #10?!
Railgun, Kobato, Kimi no Todoke, Kämpfer and Sasameki Koto. These are my menu for the fall season.
My personal opinion of fall anime 2009 xD
Book Of Bantorra and DTB 2 are damn great.
11eyes and Sacred Blacksmith, and Railgun are good.
Kämpfer, Nyankoi, and Aoi Bungaku are mediocre.
Needless, Trapeze and Sunred is crap.
Queens Blade, Asura Cryin, and Fairy Tail are all utter garbage and not worth watching.
Havent yet seen Kimi No Todoke or Kobato so aint gonna comment them.
Japan voted right this time~
Darker than Black > All
For all the hate on the fall '09 animes, I personally have more shows I'm enjoying this season than anytime in recent memory; have about 8 or 9 I'm following compared to my normal 3 to 5 per season.
Glad i'm not the only one that found Fairy Fail an utter disappointment. I haven't seen animation quality that bad in a very long time.
FUCK YEAH SUNRED
According to 2ch.
I don't see Seitokai no Ichizon
I am disappoint