Whatever.

>> rofl, you claim I'm missing the point when you, yourself are too geared to thinking I claimed you said all series were from 2009.

Hold on…

>> Anyone who claims this is a strictly 2009 poll, clearly hasn't watched Nanoha. Unless they're dumb as bricks. Your choice.

It might just be me but you pretty heavily implied that I claimed this list to be strictly 2009. *shrugs*

Oh and…

>>…it was because you mentioned disliking Nanoha and Fate, while stating this list could be 2009.

I didn’t even say the list “could be” I simply didn’t feel like prioritizing ALL of my favorite anime characters, so I thought I’d make it easier on myself by narrowing it down to just the ones of 2009, since most of the list was 2009 and I did agree with most of the characters on there just not the position they were in. So that’s when I made the mistake of saying “IF” this were a 2009 list, as in hypothetically making this list 2009, as in not really but let’s make it one anyways, as in my list with my favorite characters on it now.

As a closing comment: I have read many blogs, reviews, and comments regarding Nanoha when it was out and stuff, I even seen small clips and AMVs. But nothing that I saw or read really compelled me to go watch a whole episode. I felt I knew enough about the show and characters to determine if I wanted to watch an episode or not. A few times in the past I had gotten into an anime simply because I read a review or blog and decided to follow up with YouTube videos. Elfen Lied, Elemental Gelade, When They Cry, Shana, these are all show I knew nothing about prior to Googleing. And after reading about the shows I decided to put them on my Netflix queue, I now own them all. It’s just a way that works for me and nobody else has to like it.

True, you're free to make any choice you want, but that doesn't make them right. Sorry, if you did not watch the series, then you can't make a fair assessment of the character. Like it or not, It's true. They're not anywhere near your favorite character because you don't know them, not because they don't appeal to you. However, if you had some facts about the characters via. watching the series, and came to the same conclusion, I would have absolutely no problem with your opinion. But as it stands, I think It's a joke to not like a character based on the few things you know about them. How can you say you "know" their personality, when you don't even know the series.

>> Assuming a characters worth based on their appearance, doesn't work on a favorite character poll. They don't have a large following for nothing, especially when they don't even come from a massively popular series like most other characters on that list. You wouldn't understand what people like about them until you watch the series for itself.

And I don’t want you to repost this claiming had I seen the show I would like the characters. Like it’s impossible for characters with such a large fanbase to have at least one person not agree. How many trolls do you see around here calling people Mio-fags when Mio has been at the top of most character polls since spring? I have nothing against the characters they’re just not anywhere near my favorite characters from anime. And I think I’ve seen and heard enough about the characters to make a proper judgment, I mean I am the one who decides who and what I don’t like after all.

>> Assuming a characters worth based on their appearance, doesn't work on a favorite character poll. They don't have a large following for nothing, especially when they don't even come from a massively popular series like most other characters on that list. You wouldn't understand what people like about them until you watch the series for itself.

And I don’t want you to re-post this claiming had I seen the show I would like the characters. Like it’s impossible for characters with such a large fanbase to have at least one person not agree. How many trolls do you see around here calling people Mio-fags when Mio has been at the top of most character polls since spring? I have nothing against the characters they’re just not anywhere near my favorite characters from anime. And I think I’ve seen and heard enough about the characters to make a proper judgment, I mean I am the one who decides who and what I like after all.

....for not publishing a localized version of their mag with all posters intact.

No, your first post did not mention whether or not you watched Nanoha. Your second did, but my first post wasn't directed towards your second. Neither was my second, for that matter.

>> I have to say this is the most disappointing list I’ve seen! I’ve never really been a fan of Nanoha or Fate so I wouldn’t have put them anywhere near the list.

^That is mainly what I was commenting on. Perhaps It's the most disappointing because you don't know some of the characters, eh?

Assuming a characters worth based on their appearance, doesn't work on a favorite character poll. They don't have a large following for nothing, especially when they don't even come from a massively popular series like most other characters on that list. You wouldn't understand what people like about them until you watch the series for itself.

And since I haven’t watched the series Nanoha or kept up on it for that matter I had no idea when the last season came out. It could’ve been 2009, so I hypothetically said that if this were a 2009 poll (dot, dot, dot) and then went on with my version of the list including my favorite characters from 2009, whether or not Nanoha came out in 2009 didn’t matter. My reason for excluding them wasn’t “justified” by claiming this to be a “strictly 2009 poll” that's just something you made up.