2D vs 3D: K-On! Seiyuu Comparison

Comment by DeGrade

21:46 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Begun these 3D Wars, have.

Reply to DeGrade

Comment by Lj

01:27 27/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

LMAO

Indeed.

Reply to Lj

Comment by Anonymous

21:48 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (+0.2)

for this 3d > 2d

Comment by Anonymous

23:32 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Ah! It appears that you incorrectly used a 'greater than' sign when you instead meant to use a 'less than' sign. Don't worry it's a mistake that happens to the best of us.

Comment by Anonymous

01:35 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

lol at anon2 's post

Comment by Anonymous

01:33 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

are you fucking serious!?!?!??!!

Comment by Ace

21:50 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Bring on the old Lucky Star 2D vs 3D again. And I'll pick the 2D.

Dunno about this one though... Can't really say anything.

Reply to Ace

Comment by Ace

21:52 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Oh I can say that Mio is better in 2D.

Tsumugi 3D is not bad, btw can anyone name the seiyuu-tachi? I feel bad naming them Mio 2D, Yui 2D, Ritsu 2D, and Mugi 2D.

Reply to Ace

Comment by EroMango

22:26 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

mugi 3D is cuter than mio 3D....

Comment by EroMango

22:28 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

actually, Ritsu 3D seems to have a similar feel to yui 2D,

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

12:57 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Who's the giraffe in the middle? I can't tell whose who- lame! Do not Want

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

13:39 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

I changed my mind!!!- I thought they were "Cosplaying" - I didn't realize it's really them. I still Love Mio & Tsumugi best!

I google Minako and found this video from the girls of Sphere? called "Future Stream"- Here you can see how pretty 'In Motion' - Minako is:
http://www.planet-sphere.jp/

english language blog mentions Minako (Mugi-chan):
http://atemonai.com/blog/introducing-kotobuki-minako/#comment-33923
I sooo Love it when the actress is as cute as her character! (rare for USA V.A's).

Minako-Tsumugi Kotobuki has stolen my heart!!

Comment by Vegio

22:32 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

By searching on wikipedia, you find

Yui Hirasawa voiced by Aki Toyosaki
Mio Akiyama voiced by Yōko Hikasa
Ritsu Tainaka voiced by Satomi Sato
Tsumugi Kotobuki voiced by Minako Kotobuki

I see the 3d image is heavily shopped.
I would give a chance to Youko Hikasa and Minako Kotobuki, while the other two.. hurr..
anyway, my loyalty goes to Marina Inoue, and i'm not going to betray her.

Comment by Ace

22:36 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Mine would be Yui Horie then.. Or Fujita Saki just because of Miku.

Reply to ChocolateCrinkles

Comment by Nimas

21:57 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

just like with hentai, anime is the same thing, 2d girls > 3d girls alot, for with 2d girl, the creators tend to make the "perfect", or if something goes wrong they are just redraw them untill there true beauty comes out. Now although i really like those 3d girls, compared to the 2d cute lovable k-on girls, there is no competition.

PS: If i ever find a girl likr yui IRL , i think i might have a stroke, i completely love this girl.

Reply to Nimas

Comment by ChocolateCrinkles

22:02 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D Tsumugi isn't blonde.

2D all the way! :D

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

12:58 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Absolutely!!!!

Comment by Vin-nii

22:02 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D won 3-1 (only Mio won)

Reply to Vin-nii

Comment by Anonymous

23:25 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

its a draw for me. 3D tsugumi and ritsu were the winners.

Comment by KiNA

00:33 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

er.. there's not "the other girl" here.

Only "the moe eyebrow girl"

Comment by Firo

22:04 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

I'm sowwy to say this, but there's just no way 2Ds can lose.

Reply to Firo

Comment by Anonymous

22:09 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2d! ... though 3d look very good too :)

Comment by Anonymous

22:10 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Is it just me or do some of those balloons look suspiciously like a dick with balls

Comment by EroMango

22:30 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

now that u mention it... they modeled those off my...

Reply to EroMango

Comment by Sakagami

22:31 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Mugi's eyebrows are nowhere to be found in the 3D pic. pig disgusting 3d

Reply to Sakagami

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

13:27 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

awhhh!- C'mon...The female voice actress Minako Kotobuki is pretty cute! I'd like to see her with the hair and eyebrows - but she's really pretty as is.

Here's an english blog that features her!
http://atemonai.com/blog/introducing-kotobuki-minako/#comment-33923

Comment by Anonymous

22:33 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D Forever.....

well 3D is not that bad..... no 2D is a lot better *shake fist*

Comment by XIII

22:33 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

dont piss them off guys! or the 2D will lose their voice! XD

Reply to XIII

Comment by Anonymous

22:35 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (+0.2)

I watched the first episode. It's too fucking moe. I can't stand it. Like eating handfuls of sugar. It's a shame too, because I was looking forward to a good music series.

Comment by Rincewind

01:12 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

You lost me... Never moe is too much, never!

Reply to Rincewind

Comment by Buga

23:08 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

both 2D and 3D are win... where's the option?? D:<

Reply to Buga

Comment by alex1_phang3

23:11 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Well you see, as long as you have a cute voice you can voice cute characters . . . . . . thats why I never have been really interested in who voices which character.

Reply to alex1_phang3

Comment by Netto

23:14 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Ritsu's VA would stand a chance.

The rest?

Nah.

Reply to Netto

Comment by ManaYagami

23:19 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Mio's VA doesn't stand a chance against her.

Reply to ManaYagami

Comment by Zedd

23:21 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D Usually always win.
I'm with 2D btw.

Reply to Zedd

Comment by zZzuuUiii

23:30 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3D
nuff said. XD

Reply to zZzuuUiii

Comment by MechaTama31

23:33 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

I'm not one of thoes "3D PIG DISGUSTING" guys, but in this case, yeah. 2D > 3D.

Reply to MechaTama31

Comment by Stewie

23:43 15/04/2009 # ! Neutral (+0.2)

3d is always better than 2d Indeed :p

Reply to Stewie

Comment by Krisantes

23:46 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

3d is not bad,but... who doesn't want a little more of moe?

Reply to Krisantes

Comment by metatron

23:47 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D > 3D

2D is much more marketable compared to 3D

Reply to metatron

Comment by Anon

23:56 15/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D, but 3D Ritsu is the best.

Reply to Anon

Comment by Triple Break

00:31 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Needs that other picture;
http://f.imagehost.org/0824/784b341a_1.jpg

- Toyosaki Aki is 169cm.
- Kotobuki Minako is 158cm.

Not sure on the other two, but I'm willing to guess that Hikasa Yoko/Mio is 155cm and Satomi Sato/Ritsu is around 152cm, give or take a couple of centimetres.

Reply to Triple Break

Comment by Anonymous

00:49 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

minako kotobuki somehow reminds me of yui aragaki.

http://img18.imageshack.us/img18/4240/aragakiyui.jpg

Comment by Triple Break

02:27 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

She actually reminds me of Itou Yuna at times....

Well, here's another picture of the girls;
http://f.imagehost.org/0054/b2c29d00_1.jpg

- Toyosaki's fang really shows in that picture, lol.

Reply to Triple Break

Comment by Anonymous

00:54 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (+0.2)

I scorn to differ.

This is like one of the rare instances 3D triumphs over 2D.

Shouldn't we be celebrating?

Comment by Anonymous

00:58 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D ofc.

Also ugly seiyuus but the one doing Ritsu is kinda cute tbh.

Comment by Rincewind

01:15 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

3D Mio and Mugi are not bad. But 2D is pure win.

Reply to Rincewind

Comment by Anonymous

01:24 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

must say 2d win.
though i do think ritsu 3d is quite awesome
not the rest tho...
but still their voice n music owns^^

Comment by chibiKEN

01:28 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

hmm the good thing about this is that we can afford to have both ...HORRAY

Reply to chibiKEN

Comment by kenjiharima

01:38 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Oh the legs on BOTH 2D and 3D.

Reply to kenjiharima

Comment by Anonymous

01:40 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

2D!!!!! i cant comprehend how any percentage of the poll was for 3d.

honestly.

Comment by neeTHREE

01:52 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Only 3D Ritsu is win

Reply to neeTHREE

Comment by Deth

01:52 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Hmmmm...

Yea, I'm in a minority... I voted 3d ...mainly because there was no choice for "equal"...

In this case, I think that 3d = 2d because actually they are kinda equal (imo).

Yea, the 3d needs a little improvement, in some areas (like hair and all), but they are the VA's, so they are one in the same ~ no?

I say this time around... 3d = 2d.

Reply to Deth

Comment by nyot

01:54 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

2D !!
for 3D i only like their voice

Reply to nyot

Comment by crpibby

01:59 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

you know I'll bet that if the 3d girls had the same hair cut and color as the 2d girls you'd all go for the 3d girls, I know everyone would because everyone who likes 2d girls wishes there were people out there in the 3d world with the same physical traits as the 2d counter parts. That why you all cosplay!

Reply to crpibby

Comment by Deth

02:32 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Yep...

Like I said ~

"In this case, I think that 3d = 2d because actually they are kinda equal (imo).

Yea, the 3d needs a little improvement, in some areas (like hair and all), but they are the VA’s, so they are one in the same ~ no?

I say this time around… 3d = 2d."

Reply to Deth

Comment by Echo

02:10 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I guess the photographer couldn't find some instruments or something a little more musical for the pic

Reply to Echo

Comment by Deth

02:44 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Yea...

I was wondering the same thing?

If they were to make a comparison, why no instruments?

Maybe...laterz?

Reply to Deth

Comment by Triple Break

03:38 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

http://f.imagehost.org/0824/784b341a_1.jpg
ffs

Also another tip:
The seiyuu for K-On! actually learnt to play their respective character's instruments, except Kotobuki Minako already knew how to play a piano at least a bit beforehand. They were apparently credited for playing the instruments for the ED and after checking out episode 4 of Rajion!, they're actually halfway decent playing together.

The full ED is rather boring playing wise, so that's probably further proof that the seiyuu really played the instruments for the song.

Comment by akuma2002

02:23 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Obvious answer, no need for a poll.

2D >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3D

Reply to akuma2002

Comment by Anonymous

02:40 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Can I haz both? :)

Comment by zealtron

04:13 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

no, you must choose one, choose both and you'll end up in a Nice Boat

Reply to zealtron

Comment by Anonymous

03:22 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

You can't even compare them since they don't even look alike. >.<

Comment by AbuKoji

03:32 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Seconded.

Reply to AbuKoji

Comment by Sein

04:33 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I think in this instance...both.

Reply to Sein

Comment by maga

04:49 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D pigs don't even compare to the glory of sweet 2D.

Reply to maga

Comment by Knives

05:12 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

who the fuck would pick 3d?????

Reply to Knives

Comment by Rick

10:08 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

me cuz i love moe .XD

Reply to Rick

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

17:42 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I would cause you'll get paper-cuts fuckin' the 2-D.
The 2-D cannot swallow my 'milkshake'

However, my 2-D self is currently grinding and pounding 2-D Tsumugi on a pile of cheeseburgers in a 2-D reality....no, you can't come.

Comment by Mike

05:22 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D for me. Not all that fond of the character design.

Reply to Mike

Comment by Lisek

05:35 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Ritsu 3D and Tsumugi 3D are pretty nice I must say.
Yui 3D is ok.
Mio 3D is bleh.

Reply to Lisek

Comment by Rick

10:07 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

mio 3D suck .XD

Reply to Rick

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

17:45 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Oh, I certainly hope so! I'd rattle my uh...microphone on the inside of her cheeks. I'd say, You know Rick says you Suck!...and she'd say: "Fuuuug taaaat affffoool quuaalllkkk" and I'd be like "I feel your pain but don't talk with your mouth full honey!"

Comment by S_K

05:52 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I'd say it's close enough that we can all celebrate with a round of fappin' on the house.

Reply to S_K

Comment by Icy-nee-san

06:29 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

2D but i wouldnt mind doing the Seiyuu's either :D

Reply to Icy-nee-san

Comment by CWX

07:09 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

2D wins but not by much.

Reply to CWX

Comment by Enix

07:33 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

Ritsu's seiyuu is just too cute O_O

Reply to Enix

Comment by Anonymous

08:17 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I would hit all of them except for Yui's voice actor.

Comment by Anonymous

09:57 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

argghs not enough moe in 3D

so 2D

Comment by Rick

10:06 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Everybody is drunk .XD

3D always ownz 2D .XD

Reply to Rick

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

13:32 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I stand corrected!- I am officially Nuetral! I love the 3-D versions of Mio & and Mugi chan as asian women as much as I love their characters!

Comment by Anonymous

12:01 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

3D PHAIL!

Comment by Riot Gear

12:05 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D because there is a 50/50 chance you can meet them;in 2D world,you're chances are like finding a sewer pipe straight to Mario's or Captain Lou Albano's world.

Reply to Riot Gear

Comment by Tsuichi Rin

12:06 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (+0.2)

...the Only one that I think alright in 2D is Mio... other than her... well... rubbish so 3D = yeah!

Reply to Tsuichi Rin

Comment by Gantz_Playboy

17:47 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

are you taking a piss? You're not bein' a wanker are ye?

Comment by Anonymous

13:14 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

I'd normally vote for 2D
But in this case it's 3D, 2 of them are hot and if you can get them to do the voices you can just close your eyes and picture well you pound away

Comment by Anonymous

13:21 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

*while

Comment by LegionOfValsu

13:39 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Disgusting 3D pigs

2D for life.

Reply to LegionOfValsu

Comment by LegionOfValsu

13:41 16/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

Disgusting 3D girls = fail

2D for life.

Reply to LegionOfValsu

Comment by Anonymous

13:44 16/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

The one on the middle right is hardly disgusting

Comment by Garvey

02:54 17/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

You sir, are an honorary faggot. I love 2D, but 3D clearly wins here. 'Cept for Mio, she's unbeatable.

Reply to Garvey

Comment by Stormy001

06:02 17/04/2009 # ! Neutral (+0.2)

3D for me, I prefer real woman.

Reply to Stormy001

Comment by unicogirl

01:52 21/04/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

if you would have used the manga pic... i would say 2D
but 3D wins over Kyoani deformity.

Reply to unicogirl

Comment by Anonymous

18:02 23/04/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

I would have to go with 2D, however check out 3D Mio's blog. She's actually looks good in some of her pictures there.

http://blog.livedoor.jp/hiyonikki/

Comment by Crage

09:28 29/07/2009 # ! Bad (-0.2)

only decent one is Ritsu

Reply to Crage

Comment by dootsy

08:46 28/12/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D is always better than 2D, especially where KyoAni girls are concerned.

Reply to dootsy

Comment by Anonymous

10:20 28/12/2009 # ! Neutral (0)

3D hands down!