Father has Daughter Killed for Wearing Miniskirt
- Categories: International, News
- Date: Apr 14, 2009 17:37 JST
- Tags: Bizarre, Crime, Islam, Murder, Religion, Russia, Skirts, St. Petersburg
A Muslim man living in Russia’s second city St. Petersburg paid hitmen $4,000 to kill his 21-year-old daughter, after being incensed by her decision to wear a miniskirt. She was soon kidnapped and shot.
The man, an Azeri immigrant to Russia from the (Muslim) former Soviet Republic of Azerbaijan, was apparently disgusted by his daughter, a student studying medicine, when she opted to wear a miniskirt. He resolved to have her killed.
Perhaps not wanting to dirty his own hands, he hired a pair of Azerbaijanis to do the deed for him.
Police explain: “They admitted to being paid 100,000 rubles ($4140) by the girl’s father. They said he wanted to punish his daughter for flouting national traditions and wearing a mini-skirt.”
The pair kidnapped his daughter from the streets of St. Petersburg, and then took her to the outskirts of the city, where she was shot twice in the head.
Both the father and the assassins now face murder charges.
Via the Herald Sun.









“Immune to Exposure” – FEMEN Topless at -24°C
Highschool DxD Doesn’t Need No Blu-Ray
Gaisensha at Kashihara Shrine: “Itasha for Crazy Nationalists”
Racing Miku Nendoroid Set
Top 10 Cutest Things Guys Do On Dates
Hirasawa Ui Tiny Bikini Figure
Zero no Tsukaima F Yuri Skinship Anime
Yozora Mikazuki & Sena Kashiwazaki Figures
To Love-Ru Darkness Totally Tentacular
Ano Hana Naruko Anjo Anal Dress Figure
Top 10 Most Followed Seiyuu
Wonder Festival 2012 Winter Wondrous As Ever
Ciel nosurge: “Your Date With Ion = $170″
Nisemonogatari – “Where Did All The Ero Go!?”
Police Hunt Ushijima for “Public Indecency”
Cops Bust Cop in Nude BDSM Club Raid
K-ON! “Causes Keionbu Girl Band Boom”
Vippers vs Vankers: 2ch Targets “Korean Propaganda”
Overflow Delays “Final” Game: “We Are Not Going Bankrupt!”
Ritsu Topless Manga Time – “She Has Boobs After All!”
Lenfried Sakuya Anal Tail Ero-Cosplay
Wonder Festival 2012 Winter Cosplay
“Post The Highest Level Cosplay Ever!”
“Share The Cutest Cosplay Ever”
“Dolls vs Figures – Which is Best?”
“Why Do Girls Always Have Such Cute Rooms!?”
Ranka Lee Wedding Dress Cosplay by Tomia
Shoko-tan’s Madoka & Ika-chan Cosplay “Excessively Cute”
Guilty Crown Yuzuriha Inori Cosplay by Sasa
IdolMaster G4U: “Who Needs 3D Idols Now?”
this is not from japan...enough said...zz
Don't forget that you are the product of a female. If they don't should have tights the people that were born by them shouldn't have rights too because they are just a part of them.
Keh, this philosophical debate on religion and nationality is pointless.
This person failed as a father entirely. It is not the religion's fault and it isnt the nation's fault, it is the person that decides to take it WAY too far.
Instead of simply talking with his daughter about the way she was dressing, he had her killed, stupid yes?
You people trying to turn this into a Christian versus Muslim war need to shut the fuck up.
Maybe the fathers muslim friends did say that the father needs to sheed some blood from her daughter.But exactly where did it say that they have to kill her?
I though he would at least take her virginity and not kill her.
Anyway those muslim friends maybe made some threats to him,anyone thought of that??
No, because this is Sankaku Complex.
So killing is okay in his beliefs but not skirts -_-
she shouldn't have worn the miniskirt.
Yaher! Naughty naughty eirabe lady! Shouldve been wearing a potatoe sack over her to make er' more preasentallbe!!
Nastee durtee ceedivell with dhem therr heer skeerts!!!
I understand your rage, but this person was obviously trolling, as was the person below...
It was the only reasonable thing to do...
Yfaher! E seaz!
yher@!!
This is AWESOME.
Just hope other sluts are kept in line by this selfless fathers act.
Go away trolls, there's no food for you here.
well I as a muslim,this is outrageous to kill her own daughter. yes you can wear the miniskirt but just wear a jeans to make it more 'fashionable' rather than exposing your legs. I feel sorry for her...
well, this is one punishment she will never forget... wait... she can't remember anymore... :( GJ Dad...!
Most of the people here are doing the same thing religon does and jumping on the hate-religon bandwagon. There is nothing wrong with religon. It helps people to become better people but some religous ideas in this day and age should be reformed but with religon dying soon there wont be any left. If you think thats a good thing your wrong, without religon there are alot of people who wouldnt even know what morals are.
"there are alot of people who wouldnt even know what morals are."
And nothing of value was lost. We don't need morals, we have liberalism.
i cant imagine why you wouldnt have morals without religion? there also priests who violate children, is this how you learn your morals? Killing your own daughter because of something stupid?
And then you say morals? Religion has nothing to do with morals nor does it have any influence. Its just a way to keep people from advancing, to keep them happy and silent even if they dont have anything.
Let me steer you back to the subject on the case with a little link in regards to women under the domination of ragheads.
http://www.themuslimwoman.org/
Give it a look and repost yourself afterwards.
In fact, lets all you people take a look at the state of affairs in regard to this RELIGIOUS subject matter.
Morals are created by what you learn at a young age. Sometimes the persons already insane in the head so they'll go nuts regardless, but at the very least in America. Morality is taught and followed by the majority of us all under the context of Christianity. Either dogmatically or casually.
...
Are you kidding me?
Ugh, Abrahamic religion is always such epic fail.
"muslim father killed his daughter"
random guy: fuck muslim!
some muslim: not all muslims do this!
"christian father killed his daughter"
random guy: fuck christian!
some christian: not all christians do this!
"jewish father killed his daughter"
random guy: fuck jewish!
some jew: not all jews do this!
Now I wonder why the writer had to put the line "A Muslim man" and "(Muslim) former Soviet Republic"... why emphasize the term Muslim?
Oh, what a bad framing. It is anywhere though.
Here ya go Mr. deathlock. Here's a Real reason to emphasize the 'muslim'.
http://www.themuslimwoman.org/
Get it now?
http://www.mosnews.com/society/2009/04/13/shortskirtt/
Because the father is Muslim and Islam sucks if you are female.
The link I posted has the name and the RELIGION of the father. Check it out.
I beg to differ.
Only conservative + Islam does suck. We still got plenty of liberals here.
Maybe because if it wasn't for the harsh mulsim traditions the girl barely cared about, she'd still be alive?
Go to Iran or Saudi Arabia and hang out in Skirt. You'll see what happens.
Conservative + Islam is never good anyway.
go to morroco or egypt and hang out with a mini skirt no one will care
Only way for the bitch to learn who is the boss
Well a few weeks ago a man in Egypt beheaded his daughter because she was hanging out with a boy.
It might not "because" they are muslim, but sorry to say that, most of the time only muslim people kill people of their family because of such things.
Try to prove me wrong.
Bit soon but hey, why the hell not?
http://www.themuslimwoman.org/
Welcome to ragheadistan!
Very true. Fred Phelps's atheist son may be completely estranged from his father, but one thing I can say is that he's definitely alive.
religion is the root of all evil.
will the result be any different is she wearing a buruma instead?
Sankaku should be necessity material for doujin artist
Poor girl. :(
At times like this I'm glad I was born in Hungary and turned out to be an ateist...> >
But ppl, don't blame Islam like it's the only religion where extremists are killing/raping children/women...
Christians do the same...
The only difference is that Christianity has a bigger budget for marketing...
And this is no offense against FAITH it's an offense againts RELIGION ( which is an institution grounded by humans not gods )
There are so many girls in russia that wear mini skirts... That one father must be really prude.
isnt that kind of cheap? 4K to get someone whacked? (although he did get caught in the end)
>.> What an epic waste of money and female human life. Oh, and its wrong.
"In Russia miniskirts kills you."
that's Islam for you...
"This person failed as a father entirely. It is not the religion’s fault and it isnt the nation’s fault, it is the person that decides to take it WAY too far."
Honour killings happen every week in Islamic countries. If your a Muslim woman, fucking a Hindu man, expect to be killed by your father.
Multiculturulism is stupidity, it teaches people to blindly accept a culture, without doing any research.
Muslims are taught to hate western culture, so wearing a mini skirt is a grevious offense.
Poor girl.
Now that is why I don't like muslim immigrants and gastarbaiters here in Russia.
If they were living in their *stan's she would have thought about wearing a mini, and her crazy orthodox daddy wouldn't kill her.
It reminds me of several cases in islamic *stans that were once a part of USSR: when young girls were murdered next day after their marriage for not being virgins.
haha says someone who lives in the rape/DV country No 1.
in no other country so many women get beaten to death by their drunk husbans or migrants getting hunted down and killed by neonazi groups.
Russians are the last to speak about killing and violence!
100k RUB is now barely $3k. Inflation.
ALSO please note that this was a Muslim immigrant, not a Russian. Crap like this happens everywhere where you can find ultraconservative psychos, and Russia hasn't got shit all to do with it!
Islam: the cancer killing the freaking world
That guy is such a pussy. If he was really disgusted with it, why didn't he confront her in a civil matter? SHE IS YOUR FUCKING DAUGHTER FOR FUCK'S SAKE. But, no, he had to be a little twat and pay people so he wouldn't have to deal with her personally.
...er...so in this father's mind killing someone is better then a girl wearing a miniskirt?
no reap? bitch never learned her lesson before dying.
i think it is not a bout Islam it is more about a man honer it is vary deadly over their to see his daughter acting like bitch he wold kill her before she do so
Gee thanks, religion!
This is why we can't have nice things.
Indeed xD
But don't say "thanks, religion", say, "thanks, stupid people" xD
I'm no fan of religion, but in this case I think Aiko Goddess is right. Seems it's not religion thats the cause of this: if anything, it seems like nationalism is the motive.
I wonder how the father reconciles his love of his country (to the point of executing his own daughter for disrespecting its traditions) with his reasons for leaving it?
for $4,140 he should have done it himself....Damn!
There was a similar incident involving one of the harry potter casts because her father thought she was too westernized =/ its kind of sad...religious and cultural views should never compete against parental love.
they should have given her to me or sell her to me, at least they could make some buck out from it rather than wasting additional money to make her perish. Such a waste...
Good Parenting in Russia.
Um wow, daughter was studying medicine, she wears a mini skirt, father pissed by mini skirt, hires hitmen to kill her, I guess talking to her is just too insane
People say I'm overreacting when I want the religion and culture of Islam and the middle east to be highly persecuted.
I'm not saying burn their books or outlaw hijab or anything, but seriously, they're basically allowing this, because their book justifies it. People who claim to support that whole book should be guilty of advocating terrorism.
have u ever read those books u are talking about ??
50 years....
50 years, and the oil deposits will be gone...and the West will rise for the last time to fight the hordes of goat-fraking-muslim-barbarians. The last crusade...light(ok maybe not so bright light) against the darkness, We will step in the blood reaching the ankles,the knees...like our ancestors...like Vlad Tepes,like Templars... Before we will die out we will free the world from the diseases of Islam. So the Asians,Indians and others could live in peace...
uh, the west can't rise without oil
Hydrogen fuel cells!!!!- You'll be begging US for it! We've got enough Oil here in the US to ween ourselves off it with alternative fuels.....but some asshole in a 'white house' won't let us drill for it!...it's ours!- screw the wildlife!
I just love our oil plan..."Lets drain dem damn towel heads dry of oil, then start drillin ar' own agin!"
It's too bad that when that finally comes around that we will be using synthetic lubricants and alternate fuel sources...plus there's always corn!
senseless. /facepalm!
She was 21; she was an adult and could make her own decisions. This guy is fucking insane and deserves whatever is coming to him and worse.
As for religion...
...I hate no religion. I hate the fundamentalist assholes who do stupid shit like this in the name of their beliefs and ruin it for everyone else. These are the guys who make the news and paint a bad picture for the rest of the people of the same faith.
I live in an extremely Catholic part of America. I'm Shinto. Do I hate the Catholic churches around here? No, not at all. I hate the individuals who get up in my face about me going to hell for being the 'wrong' religion or being gay or wearing boy's clothes or not being married and popping out babies or whatever they're angry about this week. They misinterpret things and go overboard and belittle/harm people to make themselves feel moral and just.
Those are who I hate, not the faiths as a whole. You'd be surprised how many of the most 'hated' religions currently do not advocate these behaviors at all and promote a base message of love and peace.
Seriously.
The thing I see in this story (without joining the religious love/hate discussion)is that he killed his daughter for a reason that isn't nearly as common or as socially acceptable as was in the original country that he was born and raised from.
or I could be wrong
the moral of the story is "mini skirt can take your life away"
That man has failed as muslim also failed as father!!!
"Muslims are evil not Islam". Whatever, anyway no lolis for muslims O_o They will rot in hell instead mwahah
oy. unfortunately nothing new, even the hitman part - a few years ago there was a young Sikh woman from Canada who secretly married a young man she met in India instead of the older man her family was pushing on her. When they found out, they hired some people to "punish" this defiance by killing them. the husband survived, she didn't.
Mm. What he did was right and just. All hail Allah; strike down all who dare to wear miniskirts!
And then blame the Jews afterward, for it is right and just.
And yet you still fap to this website.
lol
me no understand sarcasm
Nothing like a good fap after whipping up some sarcasm!
WHAT?!
Well, I'm a Muslim, but I'm rather disgusted by the father's decision. He just ruined the Islam name. I don't think any sane person would go so far as to kill their own daughter for wearing a mini skirt. Sure, it's against religious rules, but killing is also another. Doesn't this person have any sense?
I live in jakarta
well I know about that part too...
man but really nowadays they use religion to cover up their misdeed but then the religion itself are not clearing their name and thus all those false accusation
but really this father need to be killed by hitman too
didn't the Islam taught that if your son stole something cut his hand so that he couldn't steal again..
so shot the father and then there were none of him
To be honest, I care not about the article
The picture given with the article is fucking hot though, what anime/game is it from or who made it?
Why didn't the father just talk to her about it... this is way too extreme..
* on a side note: nice image, where's it from?
I would also like to know where said image is from plox
http://www.geocities.jp/piro409/
Thanks, shame it's the best one there :(
Religion.. it should be outlawed.
Why can't people just be satisfied with the thought of someone committing such a an insane sin already being guaranteed a spot in hell?
No need to go against 'the teachings' yourself is there?
Just gloat over the fact that everyone that doesn't follow your religion being damned to hell in the afterlife forever.. or whatever else your god decides to do.
very bold for C.C to say religion shuold be outlawed.
To be honest it should be, it only causes trouble
While I do wish I had faith in a higher power (other than Haruhi) it's just not worth all the trouble it causes
I'm gonna start writing something loony here, lol...^^
How do you know there's wind?? you can't see it, but you know it's there... or even better.. Love, all your 5 perception can't understood it, but you can feel it, or even worse, controlled by it...
If you want me to give you scientific base to the statement that God exists... I can't, probablity speaking there's every chance that God doesn't exist.... But I know he is, Pass it as a coincidence, an illusion or just luck, whatever you prefer... But since I was kid I've experienced many things with Him...
From being pulled back from the Death's door, to small everyday miracle... and yes, I'm not exaggerating, In a remote chance it interests you, I can list some of my OWN experience with you here... But yes, I know you have every right to pass it as luck, medical anomaly, or just assume that I was lying, just like all those people who wrote the bible...
As for the concept of creation by pure coincidence... yes, it's as likely as, here I quote, A tornado sweeping a junkyard, and on it's path left a flight-ready 747.... Which is, at a infinite scale of time, could be likely.... but how likely it is??
And regarding science, just like you said, it kept changing and progressing, what we take as scientific today could be regarded as wrong concept tomorrow...
And me, as someone who keen on science, and in fact majoring on something that heavily involves physics and math, the more I study, learn, and discover something new, the more it amazes me how it all was created, and the more I believe that there is God...
Sorry. I wanted to say "nucleic" acid there. Not amino acids - those would have come in a lot later.
Sure it's good to have a purpose in life. But using unfalsifiable statements about some invisible omnipotent being that controls everything to support and direct that purpose strikes me as very foolish. Why not make the purpose of your life "to constantly strive for a better purpose and make it up as I go along the way there"? That's what I did, and I found it quite empowering. And the fact that there is no easy way to visualise wave-particle duality isn't necessarily the fault of scientists - it may just turn out to be that difficult to comprehend for primate minds which have never needed to grasp quantum mechanical concepts during their evolutionary path for the past few millennia.
The main difficulty that many people seem to have with the concept of abiogenesis etc happening "purely by chance" is that they underestimate the enormous timescales involved. It's a bit similar to Star Trek, where Kirk takes a trip to the centre of the galaxy in one of the movies, goes OUTSIDE the galaxy on several occasions in the series etc. with relative ease: the writers did not fully comprehend the scale of the distances involved.
Expose some "primordial soup" containing precursor chemicals for amino acids to prehistoric Earth atmosphere for long enough and you'll get a human? Sure it''s unlikely to happen the exact same way again if you reran the whole process of evolution. But there is an infinitesimal nonzero chance that it could. And all an infinitesimal chance really needs to become reality is time - lots and lots of it. Maybe one amino acid electrostatically attracts another happening to float nearby, maybe a self-replicating pattern emerges after several centuries ... you see where I'm getting, I think.
As for time zero, of course no timescales were involved there. No TIME was involved. But for "how long", in whatever analogue to "time" there was at the Big Bang - I'm out of my depth here, I have to admit - had this densely compressed energy been so? There is no way of knowing. So far at least. But science marches on, as always. That's one thing I like about science, actually. When something comes along and contradicts the established theoretical framework, scientists (at least the good ones), don't hush it up and pretend it's not there to "ruin" their precious theory dogmata, but instead go "oh, that's interesting" and ADAPT their frameworks to fit the new evidence, sometimes even going so far as rewriting large parts of it from scratch.
Sorry If I've never went back here anymore, got an exam and stuffs to take care about... not to mention I'm not a devote fan of prolonged argument...^^
While I appreciate BuggyBY's opinion of me being open minded, which I think I am, and I am interested in these... thanks. But I think anon got a point that, bridging opinion of an atheist and a believer, is pretty much a moot cause...^^; And I do think we spoke enough and stated enough points to each other, I respect you guys and your stance, and appreciate that you guys decide to have a healthy argument rather than flaming me....
just a bit to the Big Fat LOL anon tho... I'm just drawing slight comparison, you know wind is there because it has been defined in common sense, but if not, maybe You'll take it as something divine, just how old people view lightning, or how gravity is defined before the Galilean times... As for God, tho it's unlikely you'll believe it, I'll state it anyway.. How do you explain countless miracles that happened to people daily... let's say medical miracles... there's tons happening out there, just google it, and you should find it not just in christian websites.... And before you claimed them as another Big Fat LOL, do notified that I was one of the people blessed with such miracle as well...
Thanks 4 d good talk, I'm out guys...
It's too bad that the chance of an amoeba forming in the primordial soup is a mathematical impossibility, the chance of which is 1 in 10 to the 4,478,296 power, or that "debunked 747" would hold more water. Not only that, when talking about "natural selection", only a small handful of mutations are possible at any one time. Any more than that and the animal won't survive. Or are we saying it's possible for a lizard to lay an egg that hatches a chicken? Ofcourse, without the complexity of the human brain with it's insane capacity to learn and remember, we would not even be able to contemplate whether or not there was a God (or Gods).
How's about the magnetic field being far too powerful for any life to have lived even so much as 10,000 years ago? Don't forget about the law of Thermodynamics that states all systems decay into a less energized state. What about there being no real links in the Evolutionary Record, since according to Evolutionary "Theory" there should be millions of species linking anything and everything.
Ever heard of the "Radio Halos" that are frozen in crystalline granite, produced from polonium-214 with a half-life of 0.000164 seconds? We are surrounded by so many mathematical IMpossibilities that the likelyhood of the entity known as God cannot be ignored just because you don't wish it to be so.
Dawkins has wonderfully debunked the junkyard 747 analogy. Considering all the intermolecular forces involved in the formation of replicating molecules, it is more like all the parts are magnetically drawn towards one another. Actually Dawkins made a lot better points than these, but I'm too tired to drag my copy of The God Delusion out now. I definitely recommend you read the book, even though you obviously don't seem to agree with most of it - it should at least give you a better understanding of what it is you disagree with.
The bit about "what we take as scientific today could be regarded as wrong concept tomorrow…", while often interpreted as a weakness by some, is one of the, if not THE strongest feature of science in my opinion. Science should never lay claim to having explained every little thing there is. It's just the best model we currently have. Replacing large parts of it with something completely different because of new evidence disproving the old parts only serves to KEEP it the best model currently achieved. Religion sadly does not do that, but insists (many adherents, but not all do) that a book with numerous internal inconsistencies is somehow eternal, unchanging, perfect and divinely revealed truth. Thus the whole Young-Earth creationism movement. If the Bible were continually updated (as opposed to hand-waving inconsistencies away) to reflect new evidence, I doubt I would have even half as many points of contention with its followers.. Granted, it would make priests' jobs a lot harder with all the pressure to know all of the latest version, but maybe it would make some of them actually work for their money and spend less time on abusing kids. Yeah, I admit that was a cheap shot.
Anon: A lot of people care, given the amount of time, research, paper, ink/toner and computer memory they spend on the issue. And while god him/her/itself seems indeed unfalsifiable, there's plenty of evidence contradicting literal interpretations of scripture.
Well duh, I'm not talking about the bible or anything like that, the bible is bullshit
When I say no one cares I mean no one here cares, anyone who is against the theory of evolution and believes in gods absolute rule will not change their mind no matter what you or anyone else says, so you're wasting your time
Sorry for ignoring you so long, lolipedofin.
"Anyway, as far as I see it, none of what the science has discovere (that has truly been approved and not just another concept people comes up with to explain stuffs they don’t understand) had invalidate anything written on the bible…"
There's a nice numbered 340-item list of science contradicting biblical texts here [http://skepticsannotatedbible.com/science/long.html], though I admit some points there hold a lot more water than others.
Look man, no one is going to read any of those links you posted because no one cares
All that matters is that there is no proof that god exists and no proof that he doesn't
Religion is a joke, it's the same as believing in fictional characters like Superman, there's clearly no evidence he exists but you can't prove he doesn't exist
A short excerpt from my first link regarding transitional fossils:
"Some important factors prevent the formation of fossils from being common:
* Fossilization itself is not a particularly common event. It requires conditions that preserve the fossil before it becomes scavenged or decayed. Such conditions are common only in a very few habitats, such as river deltas, peat bogs, and tar pits. Organisms that do not live in or near these habitats will be preserved only rarely.
* Many types of animals are fragile and do not preserve well.
* Many species have small ranges. Their chance of fossilization will be proportionally small.
* The evolution of new species probably is fairly rapid in geological terms, so the transitions between species will be uncommon.
Passenger pigeons, once numbered in the billions, went extinct less than 200 years ago. How many passenger pigeon fossils can you find? If they are hard to find, why should we expect to find fossils that are likely from smaller populations and have been subject to millions of years of potential erosion?"
*shrug* lolipedofin for one seems interested and open-minded enough. I'm not aiming to change any fundamentalist minds so much as to educate on what they're disagreeing with.
As for "no real links in the Evolutionary Record", i presume you mean transitional fossils in the fossil record. Do you know how rare a natural occurrence fossilisation tends to be? You don't sound like it. Have some links [http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/CC/CC200.html] regarding the gaps [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/quotes/mine/part1-3.html] in the record and the supposed absence [http://www.talkorigins.org/origins/biblio/fossil_record.html] of transitional fossils [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-transitional.html].
Whoops, I forgot about the Polonium radio halos [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/po-halos/]. There.
W... whoa... Zelgadis4tw's comment amazed even me... but again, there will still be a rebuttal from the other side...
Anyway, let's just put it this way... as far as I concern, science and bible (sorry to other belief, but I only know of Christianity) never cross way before... well, except back at Galileo era, where people somehow misinterpret bible wrongly... The same doubt placed at Creationism, are true to abiogenesis and evolution.... unless you can show me in a million years, human had transformed into ET, or somehow, one of the hundred of species on earth that's quite advanced actually acquired intelligence at par with human being... then yes, I'll believe in evolution.
Err.. why did I stray to evolution again....
Anyway, as far as I see it, none of what the science has discovere (that has truly been approved and not just another concept people comes up with to explain stuffs they don't understand) had invalidate anything written on the bible...
More reading on abiogenesis and the fallacious junkyard 747 comparison here [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/abioprob.html]. In a nutshell, this image [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/views.gif] summarises the problem with the junkyard analogy.
ll I have to say about this is a big fat LOL really
How can you compare god to wind and senses?
How do we know wind is there? One simple answer would be wind turbines
When someone taps you on the shoulder you feel and possibly hear it and so on and so on, there has never been and most likely will never be any proof that god exists so I go back to my original statement
LOL
Oh boy. Zelgadis4tw. Junkyard 747, Thermodynamics, lizards laying chicken eggs AND the magnetic field in one post. Some talk.origins links are badly needed here, it seems.
First the tornado in a junkyard [http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/CF/CF002_1.html]:
Thermodynamics: This entire section [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/thermo.html], and especially this short and to-the-point rebuttal [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-misconceptions.html#thermo].
Lizard laying chicken eggs: Addressed in January 2001 feedback [http://www.talkorigins.org/origins/feedback/jan01.html], relevant excerpt follows:
'Chickens evolved, or were domesticated, from jungle fowl, less than ten thousand years ago. Anything quite like a chicken evolved much later than organisms that laid eggs, indeed birds evolved from egg-laying organisms; either dinosaurs or something closely related to dinosaurs. And it happened while dinosaurs were still around. In evolutionary biology, this is called a "primitive" trait, or a plesiomorphy, and it is retained, among others, by turtles, reptiles and fish (reptiles and fish are not "natural" groups, but the common meaning is enough here).' For more evidence of lizards evolving into birds, google Archaeopteryx.
Magnetic field strength: Warning, it's a long read [http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/magfields.html].
And to top it off, the spontaneous amoeba formation: February 2001 feedback [http://www.talkorigins.org/origins/feedback/feb01.html]. Excerpt:
"(3) Living things do not spring fully formed from dead matter. The whole foundation of evolution is that living things are the result of cummulative changes to other living things. How life first began is not known, but it seems likely that the boundary from living to non-living is grey, and that the natural processes of change and development were involved throughout. We don't know exactly how life first began; but an evolutionist would generally NOT think life was suddenly formed from dead matter. That is more like the creationist position.
(4) The amoeba is a very complex and sophisticated organism, as much the end result of a long process of evolution as we are. There is no reason to think it is any like our distant one-celled ancestors. That we are related, by some remote common ancestor, is evidenced by commonalities in the genetic code used by humans, ameoba, and other life; but it is a very distant distant relationship all the same."
Well duh, no one said that they COULD be outlawed, just that they should be
Religion can't be outlawed for a number of reasons, mass riots being the most simple one. Humans tend to unite only in the face of certain danger, so don't expect different religions to come close to disappearing unless some alien civilization suddenly decides to wipe us out.
Also I like how you compared preaching to teaching science then said people are entitled to their opinion
Science = fact
God = opinion
"through his own word"
That's why I say it's shit, that book was clearly written by someone who wanted people to believe in god, not by someone acting upon god
Heck it might have even been a practical joke that ened up in people following it
I can accept people believing in god (and that is in fact the same as believing in a holy tree of a sarcred rock) but I won't agree with people saying that what's written in the bible is gods word
Quite a lot of life on earth is most likely coincidence, as far as I'm concerned god has as much chance of existing as vampires and other such things, I'm not saying god doesn't exist but I'm not saying god does exist
and no I don't think it's harsh, if you're gonig to devote your life to something unproven you need a good slap round the face
Well to me, it is... I do know it's written by people... I can go on elaborating the detail to that, but i guess you already know the point of what I'm trying to getting across... It's just a matter of whether you are willing to believe or not... As for me, I choose to believe it...
While from your point my belief is the same to worshiping a tree, to me it's different... I found purpose in living life like this... It's good to know that there's more to life than persevering throughout trivial 70 years, That there's reason, purpose and intention on me being born and living my life...
You can regard me as an idiot who chose to believe blindly, but the reverse could hold true from my standpoint... And maybe the one who need a good slap round the face is the other way around...
As for the science... back at 16th century, people believe Earth is flat and the center of the universe as a factual science... (I know that this is partly the fault of the church and misinterpretation of bible, but let's leave that out of discussion for now)
Until the dawn of 20th century science claim that time is absolute, until Einstein claim otherwise....
Science used to belief in abiogenesis, then claim atom as the smalles part of particle until they learn that atom can be broken into several parts... Do i need to mention how science still fail to create an imaginable visualization of wave-particle duality...
Science has went through groundbreaking progress since the age of renaissance, and throughout years, what people believe as scientific facts are rendered obsolete through new postulates and idea....
Let's talk about the beginning of it all.. How do you explain that at time = 0, somehow, by pure chance, a dense compressed energy and heat that's there for no reason, suddenly just blew and created universe as it is today... Up until today, no clear explanation of it has ever been accepted... not to mention that from that moment on, somehow by coincidence a living being was created, and even further develop intelligence..
Adding it up all in my head, I think science is no more unreliable as your idea of God... heck, for all I concern, I think it's too much of a coincidence unless someone mold it to be like it is today...
I don't get your point.... I do agree that the whole religion and it's existence as organization and hierarchy is wrong...
But I have to disagree with bible being "shit like that"
To worship God that I don't know would make me no different than old people who worship a holy tree or a sacred rock...
Fortunately I know my God through his own word in bible, preaching is fine by me too... everyone needs a teacher, or do you survive all this far by believing that physics should be like this and math should be like that... No, right?? there's someone to teach you all that, right??
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, So if you believe that there's nothing after death, That all exists by coincidence, that Flying Spaghetti Monster is the way and the truth... so be it, you're entitled to your opinion...
But to some people, including me, Our belief in God is what define our life. It's something comparable to life itself, to insult that would be harsh, don't you think so???
If the target of your defamation is religion, then by all means go ahead...
But if you are trying to say that believing in God should be outlawed then we got something to talk about...
If you just believe in god and pray by yourself at night or something fair enough, but the whole aspect of relgion is ridiculous
There is no proof for or against god so you should choose to believe or not yourself, not be preaches at and told that there are people chosen by god to write bibles shit like that
this discussion is not heading the way i expected... you guys know who C.C is? apparently she's a witch who's guilty of turning the whole world around cuz she imposed super power on a british emo boy who has an arrogant accent and a childhood yaoi friend
Don't call the almighty C.C a witch D=
She's more important than god!
Unfortunately in most cases this isn't actually to do with religion
It's more to do with the pride of the father and the daughter having soiled it
It's a culture thing not a religion thing
Yes, but Islam and Arab culture are very closely linked.
Excuse me? There's no evidence that Islam greatly influences Arabic culture? Have you ever SEEN any bits of Arabic culture?
....and?
"It’s a culture thing not a religion thing"
No, it is both. The religion helps to corroborate the culture.
There's no evidence to support that, from what you're saying that would mean that taking away their religion would take away their strong views of pride
Religion is just used as an excuse, these things would still happen
Ahahahahaha, atheist much?
Don't blame the religion, blame the person who did the crime. I mean what the girl did was indeed a sin, but her father shouldn't just jump into conclusions and have her killed. But that is life for you, no good deed goes unpunished, no bad deed goes unnoticed.
religion should be eradicated from this planet, and the whole "its the person's fault, not religion" thing doesnt make any sense, because most common religions shape people's personalities and beliefs with almost nothing to back up their claims and views besides fictional books and imaginary friends.
its like living in a highly radioactive zone and blaming the people for getting cancer themselves when its the radiation that caused it...
just for your information, atheists are not the bad people that most religions have demonized them to be, almost all of us are decent people that are just sick and tired of the bullcrap that religious nuts pull all the time, being a sociopath about their beliefs and actions, we usually dont have a problem with moderately religious people.
by the way... when im talking about religious people, I mean the highly religious people, or people that dont question their faith in a serious manner.
i dont have a problem with moderately religious people that dont have religion dictate their actions.
Well said.
lolololololololol