Train Failure

Working out what is amiss with this strange image may take a few moments; did the artist do this intentionally, or did they really manage to unintentionally output something so ridiculous?

In case you are having trouble still:

Here comes the train…



    48 Comments
    Comment by vanhoe
    23-11-2008 21:49 # Report

    lol too small

     
    Comment by Sora
    23-11-2008 21:53 # Report

    The train looks so shopped. lol

    Comment by Icy-nee-san
    20-12-2008 11:26 # Report

    Why do i feel like you didnt notice it :P

     
     
    Comment by MasterCJ
    23-11-2008 21:55 # Report

    Didn’t see it at first, lol’d heartily upon noticing though.

     
    Comment by M-Gay
    23-11-2008 21:55 # Report

    Maybe that’s a giant girl, since the scenery is small as well

    Comment by 4giv3m3
    23-11-2008 21:57 # Report

    Then her book is giant as well :))

    Comment by flaskis
    23-11-2008 22:51 # Report

    Well, giant girls need giant… books

    Comment by Anonymous
    11-12-2008 08:35 # Report

    that great pictures put more

     
    Comment by Zhar
    21-12-2008 06:37 # Report

    Giant girls got more than just giant books

     
    Comment by firaku
    27-12-2008 18:09 # Report

    she could swat that train flat with her giant book!

     
     
     
    Comment by Anonymous
    23-11-2008 22:03 # Report

    exactly what i thought

     
    Comment by TheAndySan
    24-11-2008 04:16 # Report

    I was gonna say the same thing!

     
    Comment by Tomo-pyon
    24-11-2008 07:47 # Report

    i was gonna say this lol

     
    Comment by Takkun
    24-11-2008 14:46 # Report

    Maybe shes a mecca in disguise?

    Comment by CS
    07-04-2009 15:07 # Report

    I’d pilgramige to worship that, if you know what I mean!

     
     
     
    Comment by pus2meong
    23-11-2008 22:00 # Report

    Probably a train miniature?

     
    Comment by maru
    23-11-2008 22:16 # Report

    LOL! Had a good laugh xD

     
    Comment by Anonymous
    23-11-2008 22:21 # Report

    She is a Meltrand.

     
    Comment by ToMToM
    23-11-2008 22:36 # Report

    Ever thought of an immense model railroad ?

     
    Comment by kenjiharima
    23-11-2008 22:52 # Report

    looking at the background seems everything is small. A giant girl perhaps?

     
    Comment by Kergfeb
    24-11-2008 00:13 # Report

    The grass and the fence aren’t small compared to the girl. And the power lines above the railroad seems to be at a pretty normal height above the track… Must be a very, very narrow train.

    Comment by Sailor Enlil
    24-11-2008 00:36 # Report

    Actually, only the grass and other foilage would appear to be of proper scale. That fence is too small for its purpose (at least based on all my observations, that type of fence is supposed to be taller than the average adult, since it’s a type to keep unauthorized personnel out), and likewise the wooden pole is too short, and the electric wires and signal lights are too low.

    Comment by Dullahan8
    24-11-2008 15:30 # Report

    Why don’t we all just say that the artist drew the girl and her book too big instead of pointing out that everything excluding the girl is too small? That makes more sense to me instead of listing the longer list of things that look ’small’.

    Comment by StahnAileron
    24-11-2008 16:28 # Report

    I think it’s because the girl is supposed to be the subject/focus of the pic. Or at least is now playing that role. Everyone needs a reference and I rarely see people use the background image as the reference compared to the subjects in a picture/drawing.

    But I’m not graphics/arts major, so I don’t know anything…

     
     
     
     
    Comment by Chris
    24-11-2008 00:27 # Report

    No, the fence is definitely small compared to the girl. She shouldn’t be one and a half times taller then a fence that is the same height as the tunnel a train will be coming out of…

     
    Comment by pl
    24-11-2008 01:02 # Report

    I think I can see what the artist is getting at. The girl is crouching on a raised platform, say about four feet high. If you continue the rails below the bottom edge of the picture you would see the intended perspective. The far end of the platform has been obscured, this would also show that it was raised. Not terribly well drawn.

    Comment by pl
    24-11-2008 01:04 # Report

    … or so I thought until someone pasted a train onto it. NOT well drawn AT ALL.

     
    Comment by Anonymous
    24-11-2008 01:48 # Report

    look at her shadow, she just is big

     
     
    Comment by metatron
    24-11-2008 02:11 # Report

    lol he messed up on the perspective XD

     
    Comment by alex1_phang3
    24-11-2008 02:30 # Report

    Things I saw:

    1. The low fence
    2. The tunnel going into a tree/pyramidal mountain(but lookit the back of the mountain, arent those trees?!?!)
    3. The girl’s on a platform, which made the perspective of the rail/tunnel correct.
    4. However, if you do not see the girl as she’s on some platform, then the whole thing would be a miniature railway XD and the tunnel is a board or something that stands there and not going into the tree/pyramidal mountain.

    and more . . .

    Darn it this artist is a genius!!!

     
    Comment by Artefact
    24-11-2008 03:33 # Report

    Could it be that this artist is in fact some kind of latter day M.C. Escher?

     
    Comment by XSportSeeker
    24-11-2008 04:01 # Report

    If it wasn’t for her shadow and the fact that her feet is in the scene, I’d say she was in front of a poster or something… one of her legs looks more like a shadow.

    But yeah, proportions… she’s a giand girl waiting to crush the little train. XD

     
    Comment by jigglysama
    24-11-2008 07:48 # Report

    I thought she was on a high platform lol

     
    Comment by Metronome
    24-11-2008 08:34 # Report

    Well it does look screwed up. <.<
    even though she is on a platform (which you can see from the shadow of it) I’d assume it would be to ‘get onto’ the train, so,
    weiiiirrrrd D:

    Comment by aireheru
    20-12-2008 18:40 # Report

    If she’s on a platform then the grass on the side of the track are huge.

     
     
    Comment by Dave Baranyi
    24-11-2008 12:11 # Report

    Obviously, it’s a promo still for the upcoming anime remake of “Attack of the 50 Foot Woman”.

     
    Comment by ErkWit
    24-11-2008 14:35 # Report

    Nothing wrong with the picture, she’s simply visiting the amusement park where I work over the summer…
    http://www.tinytownrailroad.com/

     
    Comment by Seravy
    24-11-2008 15:54 # Report

    +One of the power lines ends behind the girl’s head. Besides, aren’t there way too many of them for one line of train tracks? One train only needs 2 I think, not 4 and a half.

    Comment by terrukallan
    21-12-2008 03:28 # Report

    If you look closely you can see that the fifth power line does continue beyond her head. It’s just hard to see against the light background.

     
     
    Comment by Simon Jones
    24-11-2008 16:16 # Report

    Is this a promo image for a commercial product?

    If so, another possibility is that the background and the character were drawn by different artists, and the image is a result of poor compositing by an inexperienced designer in marketing…

     
    Comment by StahnAileron
    24-11-2008 16:25 # Report

    Has anyone noticed the shadow for both the platform and the tracks? Thta’s either:

    A) TALL Tracks
    B) short Platform
    C) Another fail for inconsistant lighting perspective.

    But yeah…Things don’t look at all to scale between the subject and the scenary.

    Nice character though.

     
    Comment by Anonymous
    24-11-2008 18:14 # Report

    I think she is standing at an edge and the tracks are below her making them aper to be smaller than they rille are

     
    Comment by Lord Zero
    25-11-2008 07:43 # Report

    Its a giant girl. Period.

     
    Comment by taishi tetora
    25-11-2008 10:05 # Report

    wow. . . mini train???? ;;^^a

     
    Comment by Quietpower
    24-12-2008 14:10 # Report

    Why does her shadow stop at the tracks?

     
    Comment by Kaishu
    25-12-2008 14:22 # Report

    Speaking from an artist’s stance, it’s just easy most times to overlook the relative perspective of background versus character when the focus is on the character. Most likely the character was designed, and then some sort of reference was used for the background. This reference may have not been to scale with the character but once again… it’s easy to get distracted by the presence of a well designed character. So that’s what I think is happening with this one.

     
    Comment by Giovanni
    19-06-2009 03:30 # Report

    It’s a trap.

     
    Comment by Wolf Nanaki
    22-06-2009 07:21 # Report

    See, had it been a model railway, or perhaps a narrow gauge railway (do they have them that small?), it would make sense…

     



Popular Posts

Recent News

Recent Galleries

Recent Forum Posts

Recent Comments